Nothing even close

The clip of Belichick telling the defense to force Manningham to make the play makes this even more epic

This is hardly arguable in my opinion. This was the most perfect, clutchest throw I’ve ever witnessed. The timing, the ball placement, this exceeds the helmet catch

It’s this or Big Ben to Santonio

Throw and catch tbh both had to be perfect

“MAKE THEM GO TO MANNINGHAM”

Maybe not the best throw or the best catch but together it ia undoubtedly the best throw and catch

It’s so fucking peak it’s not even funny. HOF on this literally this throw alone

Best throw he's ever made. Absolute dot.

I’d have to really think about it but as a GIANTS fan I won’t disagree.

Never been a better ball.. ever

I know there's a lot of debate about Eli's HoF resume, this throw should tip the scales imo because he doesn't win the Giants yet another Super Bowl or himself a 2nd Super Bowl MVP without this throw

Such an epic throw. The situation. Down by 2. Less than 4 minutes left in the Super Bowl and Eli throws this absolute dime of a pass. That opened up the entire field for them after being pinned down at about the 10 yard line before he made that throw.

Brady could have 9 if not for 2 impossible Giants completions

I thought this catch was better than the helmet catch. Perfect throw. Perfect catch. Besides the obj catch. This was the best.....

Only a Hall of Famer can make a throw like that in that game/situation.

I’ll always remember it

🤔

I was this in person. Incredible

💯

Agreed, better than the other throw in the previous super bowl. For the time and the game it was in, best throw ever

I agree that this is #1 for me. But I can't say that "nothing is close." That throw by Big Ben to Santonio Holmes (over DRC, btw) to win the SB was just as perfectly placed, and tbh, was even higher stakes. It was the game-winning play!

It's right up there with the best.

Straight Facts 🔥🔥

It aint nothing without the catch, lets be clear 🐐 🐐 🐐

Ben Roethlisberger To Santonio Holmes For The Go Ahead Touchdown In The Super Bowl Vs Cardinals.

two feet in !! Mario was Awesome at that.

Game, Set, Match !

The reason I’m a Giants fan

On first down ?

Damn you Kyle Williams

No debatable

Yes it is

Definitely the best pass I can remember watching