Nothing justifies this…
@InspiringPhilos78K followers
80,032 views
32 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@Murray_2nd
Man, I'm glad I'm not a Muslim, so I don't have to defend this heinous doctrine.
44 likes

@Ahraz__
Once again ʿĀ’ishah was considered an adult both biologically and socially. There was no demonstrable harm that came towards ʿĀ’ishah. She went on to become the greatest Islamic scholar. This is a lame presentist argument,nobody that can critically think should be taking this srs
13 likes

@MacG_313
It's just disgusting residual cultural practices that islam allows because the fake prophet said it was okay. How morally decay is this cult that is also very violent. There is no end to the limit of evil, and once you're duped into it, you can't even see it as wrong. Can't believe they made a video to defend It's own disgusting child marriage practices! They don't have any shame! That's how much brainwashed they are!
12 likes

@red_staterebel
Rebecca was not a toddler! She literally drew water for 10 camels. Verse 57-58 it was her own decision to leave home.
4 likes

@KontrRevolucija
Dawah-afflicted Muslims: 🗣️ "Pdf is fine lol coz of 19th century Delaware. Delaware is sahih."
4 likes

@DragozPlantman
I will be sending this to any Muslim trying to refute this point, thank you IP
4 likes

@tony_ghazal1
abu bakr did complain about the marriage and Mohammad did not allow Abu bakr to marry Fatima because she was young
4 likes

@luisfpsc
Yestereday I had a discussion with a muslim that was defending marrying and having sex with a girl of ANY age as moral and scientific as long as she was an adult. Including 9 years old!
4 likes

@lostnowheretogo
History is filled with horrible people doing horrible things. It’s almost as if we need a savior.
2 likes

@stephenhall1983
The bit I love, and haven’t seen argued is why is an argument people died at 30 yet Muhammad was almost double this age??!
2 likes

@GamingDespair
@AliyaDissents, this is the guy I was referring to. IP aka Inspiring Philosophy on Youtube. Watch his Halloween takes.
2 likes

@SophiaAgape_
The Protoevangelium of James says she was 16 “when these miracles happened.”
1 like

@AishaM69066
This response was 100%. I'm so sick of this argument. Jesus commanded Christians to love their neighbours as they love themselves, so when people were cognitive enough to see these practices as harmful they were then commanded by jesus to be against them. Jesus was for all time.
1 like

@Garden_Groyper
IP believes in the Perpetual Virginity of Mary? Bro just tell us your denomination already.
1 like

@CarmelitaBaca
Thank you for calling out the death penalty criminals . If they don’t agree with rape they should renounce their religion, since they do, working on death penalties for their intent including proselytizing to pull men in to rape and murder should be automatic for their leaders

@BraunHB0
The video is poorly researched, but your broader philosophical and theological posture is deeply inconsistent. First of all, you argue that because Muhammad claimed divine guidance, he should have instituted modern pediatric age-of-consent laws.

@MetalDude142678
It isn’t really a whataboutism fallacy(or atleast whenever I do it) since it’s usually just a consistency check. If you act like Muslims are disgusting for defending the A’isha thing but are perfectly fine defending stuff like Samuel 15:3, which is way worse, shouldn’t you-

@iancarrollcool
Ure entire bible is unreliable so same thing

@red_staterebel
During Muhammad’s time people were living to their 60s and 70s what the hell are they talking about? Muhammad lived till he was 62.

@sanf42149
Sunni sources are the ones that claim the Prophet married Aisha at the age of 9 Y/O, whereas as Shia, we estimate her age to have been 18–20 Y/O at the time of marriage.










