Pat McAfee was a menace..

Alright I will give it to him he’s a annoying sportscaster but as far as punters go he was one of the better ones

This didn’t make the list?

How did I not know McAfee was such a bad man? I missed out back in the day!

McAfee had some good moments but not in Ray Guys league…Guy redefined punting and took it to a whole new level

Ray Guy is the only punter in the Hall of Fame. So there's that.

The spin move on that return was absolute filth.

Ray Guy! Not even close

Ray Guy easily

Had no idea he was this good

Ray Guy all the way. Quintessential kicker. Mcafee was good

His nose-down rugby style punt was absolutely lethal dude

Ray Guy was so good it changed forever how teams defended punts. McAfee was good, but not HOF good like Guy.

If only Polamalu didn’t line up in the C gap.

Teams kick field goals from most those coffin corner punts now

Punter and menace should never be put in the same sentence. Stop it

Ray Guy. No contest.

Ray Guy was the best, but also: He was drafted 4 times as a pitcher by the MLB. He was also the starting safety on his college football team, setting school records for interceptions. He kicked the longest field goal (at the date of the kick) of the NCAA in a snowstorm.

he makes a decent salary now not punting

good times

Wait he was a QB and kicker? Thats tuff

Ray Guy

Ray Guy by a mile. As a punter. Mcaffee just an espn head.

An entire multi year career and dude has less than 5 balls downed inside the 3 yard line ?

Toughest kicker I’ve ever seen

I live in Indy. That guy was not only so much fun to watch play and now makes every event he's a part of so much fun to be at.

Ray Guy was a much better punter

@PatMcAfeeShow @PatMcAfeeShow took down AB 😂💪🏾💪🏾

Just because fuck head has a show doesn’t mean he was an all time great punter Not even Top 10 Ryan Lindell was better than McAfee

🤩

I forgot he was a punter 😂😂😂

This guy is an ass clown

The colts had a crazy kicker and punter.

Until Polamalu ruined him . 😂

By far, the best punter ever not even close.