Skip navigation
Philosopher Nick Bostrom says delaying superintelligence could mean delaying breakthroughs that…
0:00 / 1:55

Philosopher Nick Bostrom says delaying superintelligence could mean delaying breakthroughs that…

a16z

1.1M followers

Visit on X
1,568 likesDownloadOriginal post

808,334 views

Philosopher Nick Bostrom says delaying superintelligence could mean delaying breakthroughs that radically extend human life: "Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares had this book, 'If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies.' And it seemed to me that we have at least as strong evidence for the claim that if nobody builds it, everyone dies." "Successfully developing safe superintelligence, I think could lead to enormous breakthroughs in biomedicine and in anti-aging interventions that could radically extend the lifespan of currently existing people." "If you think about what our life expectancy would be if we weren't aging, it's something on the order of 1,200, maybe 1,400 years or so. And that maybe is a quite conservative lower bound because in this situation you might also have other ways of reducing other mortality risks like accidents and so forth." "You might think that if we spend more time doing AI alignment research, the existential risk from developing AI goes down at some rate. And then on the other hand, every year that we delay it, we have millions and millions of people dying." "You don't want to delay a single day longer than you really need to."

30 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Geoffrey Miller's profile picture

    @gmiller

    Bostrom is ignoring his own 2003 paper, which demonstrated that catastrophic risks have much bigger downsides than faster progress has upsides.

    210 likes

  • Khalid E. 🔸's profile picture

    @khalidelra

    "Invent it quick, I'm 53, don't want to die, and don't care if accelerating greatly increases the chance we all die because I'm getting old anyway" is all I'm hearing

    112 likes

  • MattFromSMM's profile picture

    @MattFromSMM

    Yes we get it all the aging tech and science bros are willing to take giant risks so they don’t die

    66 likes

  • Robert Scoble's profile picture

    @Scobleizer

    Been saying this for years. Totally agree. Start with autonomous cars. They save lives and are here now. Or farming robots, like at @reservoirfarms, they dramatically improve our food quality by needing less pesticides. And we could talk for hours about how AI is improving everything else from drug discovery, to retailing.

    42 likes

  • Trevor Levin's profile picture

    @trevposts

    Bostrom is, bizarrely, speaking as if ignorant of these obvious arguments, some of which come from his own work.

    37 likes

  • Final Korp's profile picture

    @finalkorp

    "I'm getting old, so now I want AI to cure aging."

    36 likes

  • Chris's profile picture

    @cdnegri88

    Gambling with my kids’ lives to live to be 1200 isn’t a priority cuz I’m not a fucking idiot. But maybe an artificial superintelligence could figure out how to fix Marc Andreesen’s hideous cone shaped head so it looks less like an enormous phallus?

    35 likes

  • riley reality 🦇's profile picture

    @ilvos01

    yes, it's possible. but also:

    10 likes

  • baouws's profile picture

    @baouws

    this is right. Nick is the only person you should listen to when it comes to superintelligence. don’t listen at your own peril.

    6 likes

  • He-Man, Principal MLE's profile picture

    @RandolphCarterZ

    Good

    6 likes

  • Roman Semenov 🌪️'s profile picture

    @semenov_roman_

    Nick getting older and getting concerned that he might be the last generation that didn't make it before anti-aging is invented and everyone else gets to live for 1000 more years?

    5 likes

  • Kairo Sage's profile picture

    @Kair0sage

    Isn’t that the way nature works, why do we all get to live longer, why are we special? what happens when same amount newborns and less n’ less people dying ?

    4 likes

  • Oscar Davies Writing on AI's profile picture

    @OscarMDavies

    Bostrom's books are not based on any scientific evidence. He's a fraud

    3 likes

  • Joshua Schoenaker's profile picture

    @JoshSchoen

    he’s just like me, one day I think we’re all gonna die and the next day that we’re gonna live forever

    3 likes

  • Wanderer of the Stars's profile picture

    @Joel__Collinson

    I feel bad for the person who will be the last one to die naturally.

    2 likes

  • lady luna faye's profile picture

    @ladylunafaye

    this is the part i keep thinking about. every year of delay is a year of cures we don't get yet

    2 likes

  • Dr. Julie Gurner's profile picture

    @drgurner

    People forget pediatric cancer wards exist, and so do many diseases and infections. I mean, science 101 says that work on aging does not prevent death or disability. Do people really not think this through?

    2 likes

  • Alban K's profile picture

    @APatricius

    Just like in other domains, in philosophy you also have dumb philosophers & smart philosophers! This one belongs to the former!

    2 likes

  • Mitch🦖's profile picture

    @mitch_7w

    Currently re-reading Superintelligence and it's crazy how far ahead of his time he was

    1 like

  • kurt's profile picture

    @wwwolf1980

    Who wants to live forever with no job or money

    1 like