正在加载视频...
视频加载失败
Reductionism has been a powerful force for understanding fundamental aspects of complex systems, but its very success has blinded most biologists to its crippling inability to make sense of complex emergent dynamic systems. We have the tools now to noninvasively observe and perturb living cells in their stunning holistic... show more
11 条评论

The Popper sentence confuses emergence with ontological discontinuity. The fact that a phenomenon appears novel at one scale does not prove that it is independent of, or irreducible to, preceding stages. It only shows that our descriptive frame has changed. Reality does not need to break its own continuity in order to generate complexity; what we call novelty is often the sequential expression of prior relational conditions, not an exception to them.

if a thing can be modelled by an AI, especially a transformer, then by definition that thing is reducible and reductionism is the only correct interpretation, as it means its built up, bottom up, from simple, learnable, parts. only things ai cant learn may be non reductive

Interesting point. In my simulations of collective regimes, systems develop coherent, metastable patterns only when temporal integration (via memory + self-model) is present, resisting collapse under noise. The emergent transitions are quite striking.

Reminds me of wolfram’s intrinsic randomness

Are you the same Eric Betzig that did lattice sheet microscopy?

Yes.

Good to see a fellow collective cell dynamics guy here. :)

wow great work!

a wise man once told me, images are our interface with reality another wise man once told me, it's easier to check images with V1 the inbuilt GPU than with L1

@carb1n_ If only our V1 worked in 5D...

Interesting point. How would the tools you cite help to build virtual cells non-reductionistically?
