正在加载视频...
视频加载失败
Rewatching Voyager this week. Janeway was right.
46 条评论

That's a tough one, but Tuvix was fully aware of everything that happened, and truly wanted to continue to live as Tuvix. Essentially, Neelix, and Tuvok are still a part of Tuvix, so that alone should suggest that their wills were part of Tuvix's desire to live. Janeway was wrong.

Tuvix was the anomaly.

He was a healthy, sentient, and aware individual. Just because he "technically came from two dads"... doesn't make him any less important!

He shouldn’t have existed. I did say it was an ugly truth, but there is no train of logic that would lead me to think janeway made the wrong decision. Tuvix mattered only to Tuvix.

However his rights were trodden upon 🤣

Tuvix mattered to the crew! I think... it's been a while since I've seen that episode.

But did he really? 🤣

“Damn straight she was right!”✌🏽

Janeway was right, I hear the arguments but their lives were in the balance and souls are infinite. At least he didn't revert to being a salamander slug, not like that would ever happen

"Janeway was right." Damn right she was. Tuvix was never a individual he was the result of an accident and returning the two back was nothing more than a correction. Tuvok and Neelix never once complained.

No, she wasn't. She took the life of a self-conscious being.

i recently started watching voyager for the first time. im half way through season 2. love this show.

It's a good one. My second favorite

One of my favorite re-binges. But I start getting anxious waiting for Seven of Nine's entre. Everything improves almost at once with that Super character enters the scene. I love the Voyager Odyssey.

They were just virtue signaling As they knew Janeway would not allow 2 people to be sacrificed for what is essentially a transporter accident "I can clear my conscience as I know it would have no practical downsides"

Janeway is totally a murderer.

BTW, my daughter loved the idea of getting me a copy of your paperback book for Christmas. We always have a hard time figuring out what to get each other.

That makes my entire year that ANYONE would buy it as a Christmas gift.

i'll let you know when it arrives.

They should have just removed the neelix part.

Fair 😂

Strapping a struggling man down to a table, so you can cut him open and harvest his organs, to bring a legally-dead guy back to life....

Standard federation hypocrisy. Their entire mission is to seek out new life. All life is created by accident. Tuvix was intelligent and expressed he didn’t want to die. It didn’t come down to difficult ethics, it was janeways guilt and not wanting to lose her friend.

To this day, I still don’t see why they couldn’t clone Tuviks with the Transporter and then separate out the patterns of Neelix and Tovok.

No, she wasn't. It's clear murder.

just finished TNG, and the accompanying movies, rewatched the first 2 J J Abrams movies too. Wondering what to watch now?

If you can make it through the first couple of seasons, DS9 is good.

@Echo4906 I need to get Paramount Plus through Prime so I can watch this again. Never finished DS9 or Voyager, life happened!

@JayDook @Echo4906 Theres a whole channel dedicated to Voyager on Pluto TV for free. Also DS9, TNG, TOS, and Enterprise.

@JayDook @Echo4906 Yeah but then you have to watch commercials. And I just can't stand doing that anymore, LOL

@burkhardDan12 @JayDook the ads on Paramount without an adless subscription are fucking bad. On TNG, you'd get ads if you just clicked onto the show on a new episode, then 8 minutes later, and immediately after the intro another ad break, then about 2-3 more during the show, and one right at the outro

One of my favorite series ever, I love all Star Trek.

She was not right. Tuvix was a sentient being that was not a threat to the ship and not a Starfleet officer, so Janeway had no right to murder him.

This episode was the equivalent of a person getting injured, suffering brain damage, developing a different personality, then trying to refuse treatment for their brain damage because they didn't want to "change" personality back by being cured.

Nah she wasn’t but everyone prefers having Tuvok so it’s fine.

"Get in the damned transporter, Tuvix."

She executed a sentient being, a bridge officer under her command, who was no threat to ship or crew. Her justification: "I believe the dead would prefer to be alive" "They have loved ones that miss them" You are either a psychopath, retarded, or have zero media literacy.

The Doctor was right.

Tuvix 🤣🤣

Janeway was absolutely right. She was faced with a harsh decision but chose to save 2 crew members from 1 mutation that she cared for and loved as much as family. She made the right choice.

Currently watching the homestead episode. Kinda tearing up. Nelix is annoying and gutted he never got to the alpha quadrant 😂

Yeah fuck Tuvix

Well only the doctor objected. No crewmember objected. The while crew are also part of this choice. Janeway was the boss, she was the one who had to do it. As cold hearted as it may seem

This is a hard episode to watch. I have never watched it again after that first time. I just can't. I always skip it. But I have always believed that Janeway did the right thing. Tuvix was nice but sacrificing two members of the crew for his continued existence wasn't ok.

I still think they could have had all 3. In TNG Riker was copied by the transporter, that data should have been in their logs. All they'd have to do is recreate that and split the copy while in the transporter.

I'd say you are a blue check, engagement ragebaiting grifter.... If you weren't absolutely correct in your statement here. 🤣.
