Video wird geladen...

Video konnte nicht geladen werden

Zur Startseite

Should blue-collar workers be able to retire early? Craig Phillips- Mr DIY believes people in manual jobs should be able to retire early. However, Dr Alison Edgar MBE disagrees as she tells Kate Garraway and Richard Madeley that it is 'unsustainable.' What do you think?

GMB's profile picture

Good Morning Britain

1,026,208 subscribers

211,374 Aufrufe • vor 3 Jahren •via X (Twitter)

Gesundheit & WellnessBildungNachrichten & Politik
LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

10 Kommentare

Profilbild von Christopher Farrelly
Christopher Farrellyvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Would you expect a footballer or Athelete to still be running at 68? No, of course not. Working in heavy work in all weathers takes a horrendous toll on you physically and mentally, for the lowest pensions in the developed world. The argument shouldn't be choosing between workers

Profilbild von Christina Beard
Christina Beardvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Ask the woman in the interview to train up and do a manual job like building and see if she still agrees in a few months time

Profilbild von Tony Pressland
Tony Presslandvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Most men in the building industry are knackered by the age of 60.

Profilbild von Magnus Johnson 🇪🇺 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
Magnus Johnson 🇪🇺 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿vor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 I agree. Manual workers should be allowed to retire when their bodies don’t allow them to work efficiently. Would you trust a surgeon with Alzheimer’s?

Profilbild von Tracy Mathioudakis
Tracy Mathioudakisvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 I think Alison doesn't have an idea of real life "People have choices in their career path" Hello 👋 Choices???

Profilbild von Sarah Mallinson
Sarah Mallinsonvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 My husband is a builder and 54 yrs old the thought of him doing what he does for another 10 years or more is scarey.

Profilbild von Gee
Geevor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Get that thing in orange off the telly. It has no idea of real life or doing a hard day's work! Get it on a building site for even just a week, it will soon have a change of heart then.

Profilbild von Stuart Smudge
Stuart Smudgevor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Craig is spot on, many manual workers start 7 years earlier, the body just cannot take it. 50 years of carrying heavy loads. I realise everyone has a different job and many won't have done that work, but it's like the argument is dismissed. Also it's not as simple as choice.

Profilbild von Cainsy
Cainsyvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 People in the UK should all be protesting to retire at 62 like the French. Life’s to short!

Profilbild von Bob Britain
Bob Britainvor 3 Jahren

@craigbigbro1 @thealisonedgar @kategarraway @richardm56 Don’t raise the age and let all retire at same age 65

Ähnliche Videos

Ben Shapiro thinks nobody should be able to retire at 65 years old. In fact, he thinks nobody should be able to retire at all, ever. Do you agree with Ben Shapiro?
0:24

Ben Shapiro thinks nobody should be able to retire at 65 years old. In fact, he thinks nobody should be able to retire at all, ever. Do you agree with Ben Shapiro?

Concerned Citizen

43,572 Aufrufe • vor 7 Monaten

What I’m fighting for is an economic vision that does 3 things: You by the age of 30, should be able to buy a home and get married. You and your wife should be able to raise your children on a single income. When it’s time for you or your relatives to retire; they should be able to do so with dignity.
0:24

What I’m fighting for is an economic vision that does 3 things: You by the age of 30, should be able to buy a home and get married. You and your wife should be able to raise your children on a single income. When it’s time for you or your relatives to retire; they should be able to do so with dignity.

James Fishback

23,242 Aufrufe • vor 20 Tagen

Is it inappropriate to send kisses on work messages? Neev Spencer tells Ben and Kate Garraway that it is 'weird' and 'inappropriate' to put kisses on work messages. However, Sadia Asmat disagrees and says there's nothing wrong with it. What do you think?
2:55

Is it inappropriate to send kisses on work messages? Neev Spencer tells Ben and Kate Garraway that it is 'weird' and 'inappropriate' to put kisses on work messages. However, Sadia Asmat disagrees and says there's nothing wrong with it. What do you think?

Good Morning Britain

44,095 Aufrufe • vor 3 Jahren

"You're incentivising work and you're incentivising saving." "Nicola, I think this is genius." Caller Nicola tells Tom Swarbrick that she believes young people should be able to work tax-free for five years after leaving education.
1:44

"You're incentivising work and you're incentivising saving." "Nicola, I think this is genius." Caller Nicola tells Tom Swarbrick that she believes young people should be able to work tax-free for five years after leaving education.

LBC

54,402 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

There is dignity in work. And if you work hard, you should be able to build a life, raise a family, and retire with dignity. That’s the Nevada we’re fighting for.
0:29

There is dignity in work. And if you work hard, you should be able to build a life, raise a family, and retire with dignity. That’s the Nevada we’re fighting for.

Steven Horsford

10,886 Aufrufe • vor 4 Monaten

Sometimes the more intelligent ones just need to think it through 'Why do you think undocumented immigrants should be able to vote'... Maybe the SAVE Act needs to be passed, what do you think?
0:28

Sometimes the more intelligent ones just need to think it through 'Why do you think undocumented immigrants should be able to vote'... Maybe the SAVE Act needs to be passed, what do you think?

Dangerous Thoughts

12,085 Aufrufe • vor 2 Monaten

"No schools and Colleges should have internal tests during Ganeshotsav. It is our festival and students should be able to enjoy it. I have requested the Maharashtra Government to look into it." - Amit Thackeray. What do you think?
4:05

"No schools and Colleges should have internal tests during Ganeshotsav. It is our festival and students should be able to enjoy it. I have requested the Maharashtra Government to look into it." - Amit Thackeray. What do you think?

पाकीट तज्ञ

169,933 Aufrufe • vor 11 Monaten

At a campaign event on women’s rights, I asked Kate Forbes if she personally believes a woman who has been raped should be able to get an abortion. This is what she said
0:59

At a campaign event on women’s rights, I asked Kate Forbes if she personally believes a woman who has been raped should be able to get an abortion. This is what she said

Paul Hutcheon

606,762 Aufrufe • vor 3 Jahren

#GMB discusses, should we increase the pension age to 70? Rich people will still be able to retire, but without the state pension poor people will have to carry on working. And as Owen Jones points out, poorer people die earlier.
1:44

#GMB discusses, should we increase the pension age to 70? Rich people will still be able to retire, but without the state pension poor people will have to carry on working. And as Owen Jones points out, poorer people die earlier.

Saul Staniforth

280,724 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

Most Americans know that after you work your entire lives, entire life, you should be able to retire with dignity and security. So my goal is to increase Social Security benefits & ask the wealthiest people in this country to start paying their fair share of taxes. - Sen. Bernie Sanders
1:38

Most Americans know that after you work your entire lives, entire life, you should be able to retire with dignity and security. So my goal is to increase Social Security benefits & ask the wealthiest people in this country to start paying their fair share of taxes. - Sen. Bernie Sanders

Social Security Works ❌👑

12,957 Aufrufe • vor 1 Monat

Linda McMahon: "Universities should continue to be able to do research as long as they're abiding by the laws and in sync, I think, with the administration and what the administration is trying to accomplish."
0:59

Linda McMahon: "Universities should continue to be able to do research as long as they're abiding by the laws and in sync, I think, with the administration and what the administration is trying to accomplish."

Aaron Rupar

2,019,544 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

‘The only way she will be able to do it... is taxing working people.’ Writer Charles Amos says that working people should be taxed more, as Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been accused of ‘killing off middle class’.
2:06

‘The only way she will be able to do it... is taxing working people.’ Writer Charles Amos says that working people should be taxed more, as Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been accused of ‘killing off middle class’.

GB News

46,200 Aufrufe • vor 11 Monaten

Imagine being a boomer that has it so good you think somebody is going to retire by saving $100 a month. 9/10 boomers advice should be ignored.
0:31

Imagine being a boomer that has it so good you think somebody is going to retire by saving $100 a month. 9/10 boomers advice should be ignored.

Housing Bubble Disrespecter 🏡🫧❌

1,456,589 Aufrufe • vor 3 Jahren

The SUMMA boys say that the roofing of the Hoima City Stadium could start as early as April and they should be able to hand over this as a Christmas gift to Ugandans, in or before December. We should be studying these guys to understand their secrets in construction, mobilization, financing and sticking to timelines in countries that ordinarily do not experience such excellence.
1:50

The SUMMA boys say that the roofing of the Hoima City Stadium could start as early as April and they should be able to hand over this as a Christmas gift to Ugandans, in or before December. We should be studying these guys to understand their secrets in construction, mobilization, financing and sticking to timelines in countries that ordinarily do not experience such excellence.

DBwambale

49,198 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

Andrew Cuomo is the father of poverty pensions! 👎 He’s the one who gave birth to Tier 6, the plan that guarantees you’ll work your whole life and still won’t be able to retire comfortably. Now he’s trying to rebrand himself as pro-labor? Nah. We remember. 🧾 You can’t be “for workers” when you’re the reason they can’t retire with dignity.
1:45

Andrew Cuomo is the father of poverty pensions! 👎 He’s the one who gave birth to Tier 6, the plan that guarantees you’ll work your whole life and still won’t be able to retire comfortably. Now he’s trying to rebrand himself as pro-labor? Nah. We remember. 🧾 You can’t be “for workers” when you’re the reason they can’t retire with dignity.

Tramell Thompson

12,423 Aufrufe • vor 9 Monaten

SNEAKO believes it's a moral failure of society that Elon Musk was able to become a trillionaire 😳 "Yeah, you should be able to make your money, but the fact that somebody like this exists while there's a wealth discrepancy and many people starve, it is a moral failure. What do you need all that money for? It's for power..."
2:31

SNEAKO believes it's a moral failure of society that Elon Musk was able to become a trillionaire 😳 "Yeah, you should be able to make your money, but the fact that somebody like this exists while there's a wealth discrepancy and many people starve, it is a moral failure. What do you need all that money for? It's for power..."

Daily SNEAKO

22,581 Aufrufe • vor 1 Monat

The year is 2026.. Retire is at 10 Billion Netflix picks up a story after thousands of lives were changed in a year from holding a coin called $retire You are on vacation on an island somewhere because you were able to $retire early Your kids ask you “how did you do it?” You gather your family around , grab the remote, and turn this on.. The rest is history..
0:21

The year is 2026.. Retire is at 10 Billion Netflix picks up a story after thousands of lives were changed in a year from holding a coin called $retire You are on vacation on an island somewhere because you were able to $retire early Your kids ask you “how did you do it?” You gather your family around , grab the remote, and turn this on.. The rest is history..

Shadow

20,664 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr