Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
The Iran War is America First
225,809 views • 4 months ago •via X (Twitter)
47 Comments

Regime change in Iran = massive, immediate GDP boost for the US - Kills the Middle East instability that's a huge drag on the US economy. - Opens a new market the US lost for decades. - A young, talented, energetic, pro-US population, while Europeans drift away. - A real ally in the most strategic spot on earth, which could reshape everything.

Shaun; I suspect you’re a good guy, & think you’re sincere. But you’re smoking crack …it was far more dangerous (and remains so..) to speak out against Israel than it is to blindly support it. I’d recite examples of careers ended, families harassed, election chances destroyed …all by Israeli lobby & its minions if ppl has courage to say Israel needed to be reigned in or defunded. You’re too smart to lie abt it. I’m happy to hear the rest, even if I disagree , but we have to stop lying to each other on basic shit if we want to start listening & finding compromise on right

This was true in the past Hasn’t been true for 12-24 months

was just voted out of office for crossing Israeli lobby & President. AIPAC literally gloated over Meriam Adelson & Paul Singer investing $25m+ to unseat a very popular libertarian. Not an antisemite, Shaun, a libertarian who votes the same way no matter the social spending issue. Jamaal Bowman, Cori Bush, Elizabeth Magill, Claudine Gay, Thomas Massi, Tucker’s son Buckley (largely rumored to be pushed out bc of brother & Uncle’s commentary)…i could do this all day. This administration has harassed universities, forced institutional & states to pledge fealty to Israel in order to win public contracts…hell, @RonDeSantis passed state law in Florida (signed in Israel) amending hate crime definition that includes "applying double standards" to Israel or "demonizing" it. That’s a hate crime now, Shaun!!! What are you examples of tide turning except a few moronic & largely obscure podcasters screaming a few antisemitic slurs. What the Democrats do (with regards to Israel) is largely performative & lacks teeth. The vote to defund Israel was nothing more than opportunity to placate their voter base who bleeds over Gaza. Republicans voted (-1 Massie) in unison & lockstep to continue funding Israel despite legitimate concerns over humanitarian issues. What you’re saying just isn’t reality. Israel is becoming less popular with general public bc of its overt abuses & ethnic cleansing in Gaza & Lebanon & treatment of Christian Arabs - that is serious debate- but its grip on power has largely just been refocused from a Democrat party to being all-in on GOP. Try saying anything negative abt Israel in any board or executive meeting in NY, LA or Palm Beach. Let me know how you think that would go, because I actually know firsthand. 😂

@shaunmmaguire @RepThomasMassie Regarding funding Israel….how much are we giving them? I heard it was 5bilion annually, meanwhile they have to buy our weapons, provide intelligence, tech, etc.

@shaunmmaguire @RepThomasMassie We’re okay if they just fuck off completely

If only everyone were as smart as you, Shaun.

Is it a coincidence that Iran is the arch enemy of your ethnic homeland?

The Iran War is AMERICA LAST!

Shaun your rich you don’t need war profits bro, your better then this too.

Profit is not the motive brother.

Only G-d knows what is in your heart, I do believe your pure hearted so if I was wrong I apologize.

You have to go back to Israel

Every time I see one of your long form content pieces come out i make sure to stop and listen. Always thought provoking and well reasoned. Thanks for all that you do, Shaun.

Appreciate you

You are clearly super smart and I respect what you do to fight against the left, your incredible investment acumen / ability to forecast. But do you believe you have an accurate theory of mind for the median American Conservative? Could you articulate why it’s good for them?

Good question. I’ll respond later tonight.

Thank you - looking forward to it.

This is brilliant, Shaun. Thank you for saying it.

"Break Iran and you break China's grip on the oil, the proxies, the black market… every path Beijing needs to take Taiwan runs through Tehran, and we just closed the road."

@StealthMedical1 We will face mandatory fuel rationing by the end of the year, Iran will have a nuke inside of 9 months, and a range of governments will collapse around the world. Good work.

@StealthMedical1 not true...

@StealthMedical1 I guess we’ll find out. I hope I’m wrong.

This is one of the few serious attempts I've seen to frame the Iran war strategically instead of tribally, and the strongest parts are airtight. Roughly 90 percent of Iranian crude flowing to China, the Malaysia laundering route (China "imports" more Malaysian oil than Malaysia produces), the blockade as a hand on Beijing's oil valve, the Shahed timeline, the Houthis waving Chinese hulls through, the Lebanese Canadian Bank case. All checks out, and the Taiwan deterrence logic built on those facts is under-argued in public. You're right that almost nobody is making this case. Impressive work. Keep making it.

Spot on! The Islamic regime has killed Americans and will continue to do so. The Iranian people are among the most pro-American nations in the world. By removing the regime and paving the way for them to reclaim their country, America would unlock one of its strongest allies.

You're right. Thanks for being brave enough to say it.

@DrEliDavid None of this is America first, it’s destroying our prestige and credibility on the world stage. Things were better before this dumb war

🙌

Spot on. Iran is the key to control China and Russia. Iranians are true friends of the US despite the IRGC thugs

@wolfejosh Shaun is in his YouTuber era

I don't have 15 minutes for the video right now ... I'll circle around later. But I agree. If the Mullahs didn't condemn the United States as the Great Satan then we wouldn't have to worry. But, they do. And the President needs to take threats seriously. You can't have a regional power pursuing weapons of mass destruction and threatening the United States. I don't know of any other government which uses language like that about us. And, how legitimate are they? The Mullahs got into power during a revolution. Shady as fuck if you ask me. Iran was likely better off with the Shah: revolutions allow the wrong people to get into power.

An opinion like that is a disgrace to an Irish name like Maguire.

All the experts talking defeat while this will be remembered as one of the best strategic moves in the last few decades . History will be the judge and it ain’t over. Peace through strength 🇺🇸

everyone in the US should watch this

This 👇 u?

Great take Thank you for your service 🫡

Your argument is solid, I think the stronger argument is maintaining the nuclear equilibrium. When you take the time to think through the sequence of events after Iran gets a nuke, p-doom increases by double digits.

@Micro2Macr0

@CharlieShrem It’s not Shaun. Iran is literally irrelevant to 🇺🇸. Other than the high oil prices it caused. The Israel talking points are played out and time proved them irrelevant.

Bingo.

This is great. You should make more of these I’ve been to Iran several times. Among the most wonderful people. Unfortunately we live in a world where military action is necessary I agree that this will delay a war over Taiwan. Most people underestimate the threat and don’t realize how critical Taiwan is for both China and the West

Appreciate you sharing this Shaun. Had a pretty good understanding of the first three points and was less informed on the fourth. With that said, I hadn’t really thought about the last portion of your third point related to the regimes use of Chinese resources to test out their technology vs western weapons. Completely agree that the Iranian people are truly brave, intelligent and brave. Hopefully this can be over soon and put the general population in a much better position.

- well said. Don’t you think the US is deliberately not naming China for the exact reason it has maintained 30 years of strategic ambiguity around China/ Taiwan? Trump and previous presidents deliberately avoid confirmatory and confrontational language there - to create strategic space and generally deescalate. When it comes to Iran / China, this is a continuation of that policy. Unfortunately it creates a PR vacuum, but it protects the overall interest of US not to draw China into unnecessary global confrontation.

Yes I agree with you and I think it's a massive mistake I think whenever China is named they immediately change their behavior They respond to being named as it plays to their "face" culture If you don't name them they won't respond.

If America already controls the ability to shut off Chinese imports of Iranian oil, why is an invasion necessary? If China can’t sustain a war to take Taiwan without Iranian and Venezuelan oil, isn’t the battle already won? Would a better deterrent against China taking Taiwan not be to project force in the South China Sea vs. concentrate them in the Arabian Sea and the ME? If ongoing escalatory kinetic action is giving China free battle testing of its air defense equipment, wouldn’t not giving them that opportunity provide less actionable intelligence and prevent subsequent innovation?

I've never advocated for an invasion. Simply just continuously bombing their war production infrastructure and blockading their oil shipments is a massive win IMO. Do that for two years and see what happens.

Fair, maybe that works. But (and I’m no expert) it seems like: - regime can’t / won’t be dislodged from bombing alone, and years long bombing campaign may instead create a rally around the flag effect - the war production infra that matters (for rockets and drones) is mostly in self sustained hardened sites in mtn complexes - the domestic appetite for another years long ME war is low - the ME’s appetite for absorbing Iranian retaliation is low (unilateral direct dealing reported) - US naval blockade control notwithstanding, so long as the strait remains a major trade choke point, the length of the coastline means Iran’s ability to impose high costs on global economy are as simple / low cost as a dude in a dinghy with a rocket What you’re suggesting feels like half measures. some might argue half measures are worse than the extremes on either end: diplomatic solution or whole hog invasion to hold coastline and definitively topple regime.
