The ONE QUESTION Palestinians cannot answer honestly

“I am the victim!” You’re gonna do big things with that mentality bro

Interesting and telling they cant respond to that question.

Because if they do, they might recognize the Jewish connection to the Land of Israel.. and if they will - they will be Zionized

At least they seem to discuss in good faith and with manners. I never see this in similar videos

That’s very true

Nah - there are no Palestinians, just Arabs who should go and live in one of the 22 Arab countries. Gaza, Judea and Samaria are Israel and Jewish.

If I married a white man & for the next 67–80 generations every single one of our descendants married someone who wasn’t Palestinian, they’d barely have any Palestinian ancestry left &if 2,000 years later they showed up in Palestine claiming the land was theirs bc their ancestors lived there, started taking land from the ppl already living on it, & decided to build their own state, then I’d call that settler colonialism.. ya habibi Idgaf where your ancestors lived 2,000 years ago..that doesn’t give you the right to show up & take someone else’s land.

Okay, so you are against the Palestinian right of return. That’s interesting

After 2,000 years? Yes, actually. 😂 I wouldn’t give my own descendants an automatic right to Palestine just bc I lived there 2,000 years earlier. & you’re comparing that to Palestinians returning to homes they or their grandparents were expelled from 78 years ago? Be fucking serious.

@inondankehati So when? 500 years ago? 100 years ago? Where do you put the threshold?

@inondankehati Funny you don't wanna answer that, habibti @popdizz

Habibi, it’s not about some number of years…u seriously don’t understand the difference between someone returning to a home their grandparents were kicked out of and someone showing up claiming land bc their ancestors lived there 2,000 years ago? u can have ancestors from somewhere.… doesn’t mean u get to take land from the ppl living there now. What part of that is confusing?

@inondankehati Yeah, but i asked what's the threshold in which people can't claim it is their homeland. 100 years ago? 300? 500?

Habibi, u can call somewhere your ancestral homeland after 10,000 years for all I give a fuck. 😂What u CAN’T do is use that ancestry as a property deed to someone else’s home….ya ro7 immak I’m not putting an expiration date on ancestry….I’m questioning your entitlement to other ppls land..try to keep up.

Based on their historical Islamic sources Muhammad describes how he led military and stole the land from Jewish tribes, modern Saudi Arabia, so not only Muslims not indigenous to Palestine but I believe IDF should deport the Muslim to Madina let them live next to where the prophet is buried 😉

Bro, your ancestors probably came from Egypt and other countries around it 🤷🏻🤣

How can it be his country if he has never lived in Israel?

So why does he think he is entitled to live in Israel?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

He forgets that while jews were expelled in the 2nd century, there were still Jews living there; there are the lebaneese jews, the misrahi jews .. What rights do they still have? Are we only going to see it from the "colonialist" perspective and deny the Jewish state's existence because many Jews fled from extermination in Poland? Jewish state not allowed; only 50 Islamic states?

False equivalence and that explains why the video has so many cuts and edits. If this man's tenth generation descendants returned to Palestine from the UK and killed and displaced natives along with theft of their property, then they would be the same as Israelis: CRIMINALS

Image a line like this: "I live in the UK, but was born in Athens. My greatgrandfather came from Trabzon as little boy .... Therefore you Turks are all squatting in Pontic Greece." Would anyone even listen?

You are aware that the Turks were central Asian tribes that indeed invaded Greece

But a Turk told me on "Conquest of Istanbul"-Day that they were actually indigenous.

You steal the land, kill innocent people, and then say, “This is my home.” You claim that God gave you this land through a divine promise. You liars! Is God sitting around with nothing better to do, handing out land deeds to human beings? Your claims have become well known.

No land was "stolen". That's a lie. Nobody lost their home until there was a war. Wars create refugees and population transfers and are horrible. There has been a peace plan on the table since before 48 which is partition. Compromise is the only way forward.

Yes! 🎯

By your logic, all the jews who lived in usa,uk, Poland, ukraine etc for centuries before 1900s, all of a sudden want to come to Palestine and live there? So ok, no right of return for jews then.

Your logic was far away from understanding my logic

Lol. Logic fks them over everytime!.

Not only that, but he's a colonizer in UK. Africans and Muslims are colonizing UK, destroying its culture and brutalizing its peoples. How dare they accuse others of such things; it's projection.

Dumb. Of course there is a difference between people expelled within living memory (their parents / grandparents) and people who believe they are connected to people expelled thousands of years ago. Totally absurd to equate the two.

So in 200 years from now, when the Nakba will be just a far far memory, it will be absurd for Palestinians in the diaspora to want to come back to Palestine?

They may WANT to, but they shouldn't have to RIGHT to at the expense of those then living there.  If everyone had a right to preferential abode in the place they think their ancient ancestors lived, the world would upended. This is a special privilege claimed by Zionists only.

@inondankehati Lets say they do go back. And just move there. Maybe buy their own house and land. But then the jews start a war against them trying to kick them out Lets say the Palestinians win that war. And instead push out the jews. Whos fault was that?

@inondankehati ...and then the remaining Jews are made de facto second class citizens, whilst millions of Jews who were pushed out are held indefinitely under a brutal Palestinian military dictatorship for decades? My sympathy would be with the Jews. See, easy.

Fk Israel

Terrible analogy. It's more like 100 generations. Not 10. And there is difference between wanting to return and wanting to return with the intention of taking over political control and kicking people off their land. But typical Zionist is dishonest as fuck as usual.

I disagree with that mentality. Arabian migrants shouldn't be treated the way Jews in diaspora were. Arabian migrants pray towards Mecca, spean Arabian language and have Bedouin culture. NONE of it originate in the Holy Land.

It makes no difference where people used to live. Using this logic, the British had used the theory of the Aryan race as a pretext to invade India. They called it ‘the homeland of our ancestors’. Peace can only come by accepting the current situation.

With respect, it’s important where people used to live - as long as it’s not just a myth. But yes, I generally agree with the last part of your comment.

If it matters where nations lived in the past, then all of humanity would have a claim to the land of Kenya. Our ancestors all lived there. This line of reasoning amounts to imperialist pretexts. By that logic, everyone in the world is an immigrant.

Okay, so according to your logic Palestinians who were expelled during the Nakba and their offsprings were born in the UK have no more claim to Palestine

Whether or not they can lay claim to their rights depends on the circumstances under which they left. Those who were exiled may wish to return to their homeland. However, those who left of their own accord have no right to return.

Bro making a palestina think for a moment. It's dangerous to make palestina think. Very dangerous. Hamax don't like a thinking palestina. Aljazeera will go jobless

Fuck Palestine

Aye yes by that logic I’m going to move to your house becuase 10,000 years ago my ancestors lived there I am deciding of Fred of the filostonians

In theory aliyah sounds all good and dandy if you portray it as normal immigration but we know that Herzl and Jabotinsky intended for this to be a colonial endeavor Palestinians can identify the names of their ancestors who lived there and the house that they lived in, Jews can’t

Fk this Jew and his lies we speaking about the Palestinians that live in Palestine

I have a question so if his family wants to return to palestine does that mean that they can come and kill whoever lives in the house throw them on the street and take over the property and home. And strip who ever is currently living there of their human rights.

UN 194

A rather fundamental chapter of history is MISSING. In 1947, the United Nations proposed two states: one Jewish, one Arab. The Jewish leadership accepted partition. The Arab leadership rejected it. Israel declared independence in 1948, and neighbouring Arab states went to war. Many many many wars, one after another. They lost, every single war. Let me tell you something about my own country, Italy. After the Second World War, Italy lost Istria, Fiume and other territories to Yugoslavia. Hundreds of thousands of Italians became refugees. Many suffered persecution, and thousands were killed in the violence associated with the foibe and Yugoslav repression. Their families had lived there for generations. Did Italy spend the next 78 years waging wars to recover Fiume? No. The Italian Republic had to accept the territorial consequences of a catastrophic war and rebuild. Therefore, he is not a victim, he is a fucking loser.

Don’t even bother to argue with these morons. Arabs and Muslims of a mindset that will not and refuses to learn. They do not value learning. They value adherence to an dogma. They’re from the seventh century and has never changed. They’ve never had a reform.