The Reds could really regret trading Jonathan India

Yes and no. Yes because I bought his city connect jersey No because we have a lot more leaders than India on this team. The sting would be short lived when we finally get Luke Weaver off this rotation for someone even half as reliable.

He’s 26, and his agent never extends with the Reds as is. He’s been average to below average since his rookie year. His defense is subpar. Our young guys behind him are going to be, or already are better than him.

Fraley looks the best in the Viking hat tbh

I’m a Reds fan, next year we have a starting infield of 3B Marte, SS Elly, 2B McLain, 1B CES, we also have Steer, so yes you absolutely trade India

I agree. Pulling working parts tends to break something somewhere down the line.

Considering that the teams out of the playoff picture will let solid starting pitching go for prospects that won’t be as good as India. Seems like a bad decision. If you’re gonna trade India you better make sure it’s in a package to get a stud back…

Get to end of season and pitching woes come back, you’re going to be getting shat on. Either way, there’s risk. Trading India just makes more sense, especially with the guys still due to come up from the minors

India being a team leader is all media driven. last year, he lead us to 100 loses, other guys come up and we start winning. India is a losing recipe, sorry not sorry!

Terrible take. India did Jack shit in those wins

I agree. Do not trade Indy