正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

The utopia that lied. Here's the truth... PragerU

215,832 次观看 • 3 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

35 条评论

Konstantin Kisin 的头像
Konstantin Kisin3 个月前

Or watch the video on YouTube here | @prageru

Eli Sinyak 的头像
Eli Sinyak3 个月前

@prageru My family immigrated from USSR to the US in 1975. I was a teenager. Everything Konstantin says is 100% correct. The feelings he describes are shared by everyone who ever lived in a socialist/communist country

annonymus 的头像
annonymus3 个月前

@prageru Take a country, divided in 2, one capitalist one socialist, put a wall between and see who is fleeing where! Already done! See Germany! The eastern part, the socialist one, had it so good, that they built a wall to keep people from fleeing to the west!

Matt Rellew 的头像
Matt Rellew3 个月前

@prageru Should be mandatory reading. The level of cruelty there (and China today) was/is almost inconceivable..

Mr. Dye 的头像
Mr. Dye3 个月前

@prageru I visited a friend in Hamburg around 2010. We traveled to East Germany and the even then the difference was immediately clear. Nearly every building was a drab gray. It seemed drained of life and joy.

liberty and justice for all 的头像
liberty and justice for all3 个月前

@prageru

simon douthwaite 的头像
simon douthwaite3 个月前

@prageru Thanks Konstantin. I grew up in Hong Kong. The big bad wolf lived next door. Still does. It's a complicated story because some say the big bad wolf is now fat and happy. Fat beats starving under Mao, sure. But Uyghurs? Organ harvesting? You don't want to live with a wolf.

Francis Loveday | Author: Our Two Democracies 的头像
Francis Loveday | Author: Our Two Democracies3 个月前

Life is hard. Wanting to make it better for you and your family is aspiration. Wanting someone else to make it better for you and your family is socialism. Promising you can make it better for people and their families is populism. Listen to governments who will open doors for you to make a difference to your own life. Take responsibility for yourself, you’re the only person who cares. I promise.

Faith ramos 的头像
Faith ramos3 个月前

People aren't listening, they have blinders on, they have no conception of what's to come. They can't see, for some reason, the truth of what will be, if they allow these people in office. We have to stop this immediately. I can see what will be, for now we have to stop this, so then they can see, we are protecting them, because they can't protect themselves

Jess 的头像
Jess3 个月前

@prageru This is what the democratic socialist party wants for us. The very ones who opened our borders, the legislative branch of our government who can’t and won’t explain how they all became millionaires.

John Smith 的头像
John Smith3 个月前

@prageru Thank you Konstantin. And thank you Elon. It is men and women like you who made this Constitutional Republic the envy of the World. As Franklin quipped; "If we can keep it."...... Well, we're fixing to find out.

alexandermenashe 的头像
alexandermenashe3 个月前

I know this is true. I visited the USSR in February 1991 with my school and we received a curated and guided historical tour of sites selected for their ideological significance. If you don't believe me I can show you the clock in the Winter Palace which stopped at the exact moment the Bolsheviks stormed the building.

Simon Adams 的头像
Simon Adams3 个月前

I travelled around the USSR before the fall of the Berlin wall, and it was enough to smash any sympathy I may have had with Marx after reading the Manifesto. The stark greyness of *everything* - only broken by murals in red and gold. Huge queues for a handful of sawdust sausages, while the beriozka shops we could go to with foreign currency had Communist Party members able to buy things that we just tooks for granted in the west. It was grim, and anyone who claims that the Russians just didn’t do Marxism properly are idiots. This is just how the system works, because Marx didn’t understand humans.

Liza Lockwood 的头像
Liza Lockwood3 个月前

@prageru Speaking of useful idiots, here’s a hot take from @TheLancet “It is a moment to reappraise Marx's contribution to medicine and to discover if his influence is quite as harmful as contemporary wisdom would suggest.”👇🏽

Just Jen ℞ 🫡🇺🇸 的头像
Just Jen ℞ 🫡🇺🇸3 个月前

@prageru I remember the USSR and how bad it was for the people. We will NEVER let that happen here in America. NEVER.

BNOneil 的头像
BNOneil3 个月前

@prageru Academia and elitists live intellectually, outside of reality, while the rest of us have understand what really works and why. Many many millions die because of their commitments to the vision.

Shenandoah 的头像
Shenandoah3 个月前

@prageru I love the way you present the unvarnished truth, a truth derived from personal experience. Problem is the masses are stupid defined as willful ignorance. In a majority-rule political democracy that is fatal. They believe they can get something for nothing, which is impossible.

Suzette’s still tired of the BS 的头像
Suzette’s still tired of the BS3 个月前

@prageru For all of the Democrats, leftists,far-left, socialists, wannabe communists, DSA, Islamic Muslims (whom are the only ones out of the bunch who actually know what they’re doing as they trick all the rest) Here’s your UTOPIA you useful idiots! Choose Communism or Sharia Law??

Mats Hansen☦️ 🇳🇴 的头像
Mats Hansen☦️ 🇳🇴3 个月前

@prageru Stop mentioning Norway, Sweden, and Finland. We are NOT countries with this leftist, bat-shit-crazy ideology. Start including Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini when speaking of leftist, bat-shit-crazy ideology. They also promised a 'better tomorrow' based on the same premise."

McLaudInvest 的头像
McLaudInvest3 个月前

@prageru This is music to a DSA member dude. It doesn’t have the effect that you and I or any normal person has …. The Democratic Party is done. Is all communist now And they hate America Good Bless 💪🏼😎🇺🇸

Olivier 的头像
Olivier3 个月前

@prageru Beware of those who promise you utopia, they will send you on a one way-ticket to hell. Let's keep utopia for nightmares and horror movies.

Amy 的头像
Amy3 个月前

@prageru BEAUTIFUL JOB TELLING YOUR REAL EXPERIENCE WHAT SOCIALISM TRULY IS IN REAL LIFE! I THANK YOU BECAUSE IN OUR UNIVERSITIES&K-12 THESE MISTAKEN TEACHERS&PROFESSORS ARE TEACHING OUR CHILDRENS LIES-WHEN THEY NEED #TRUTH&REAL HISTORY! THANK YOU 🙏 ❤️🇺🇸👏🏾👏🏻👏🏽

TXIND1836⭐️FEMALE, REG. VOTER, RURAL TEXAS! 的头像
TXIND1836⭐️FEMALE, REG. VOTER, RURAL TEXAS!3 个月前

@prageru A look back to a time in that movie (1954) when everyone knew the ramifications of what Socialism/Communism was!

KJELL B. ✝️ ____🇸🇪_🇺🇦 🇪🇺_🇮🇱🇺🇸 的头像
KJELL B. ✝️ ____🇸🇪_🇺🇦 🇪🇺_🇮🇱🇺🇸3 个月前

@prageru

Hadi 的头像
Hadi3 个月前

the question is why we are so vulnerable to this lies? my answer would be we all grow up in a family, and the structure of a family is a social system, so some of us take the “provider” granted for the rest of our life, which is not true! there’s no guarantee for providers out of family. governments are not providers! they are as dependent as the rest of the society to people who create value in the economy. the value generators of the economy are not interested to be everyone’s provider like they provide for their kids, and nobody can force them to be, based on history!

PFNavyMom 的头像
PFNavyMom3 个月前

@prageru @BernieSanders this is who you fucktards are voting for...except it's worse! Buy a pet pig and take it everywhere!

Bahamasmark 的头像
Bahamasmark3 个月前

@prageru Let’s make this real simple for everybody – modern liberal Democrats are “useful idiots” who are being used as pawns to destroy the most successful and wealthiest nation on the planet Earth. And who’s voting for this again ???

Elle 的头像
Elle3 个月前

@prageru This is brilliant Konstantin. Thank you. 🙏 @XnutNat

Warren Winkleman 的头像
Warren Winkleman3 个月前

@prageru I also grew up in communist utopia…. Within my parents household. They supplied our every need, we did the chores that we were able to do according to our ages and abilities. It was supported by their jobs in the capitalistic economy.

Innessa 的头像
Innessa3 个月前

@prageru I was born in the same place this so-called “utopia” as you.

Lucien Tarr 的头像
Lucien Tarr3 个月前

@prageru We have past rhe point where continuous warnings is not helping. The Islamist-Socialist threat, financed by a powerfull enemy will defeat your attempts at teaching reality.

Kari Reinikainen 的头像
Kari Reinikainen3 个月前

@prageru I recall a student friend of mine going to what was Leningrad then who was advised to bring her own toilet paper from Finland.

jc_emerelda_pearl_violetta_0007 的头像
jc_emerelda_pearl_violetta_00073 个月前

@OldRoberts953 @prageru My father (a union shop steward) went on a tour to the ussr. He was appalled by the complete lack of safety in the factories & steelworks & the standard of living

Damien A. Hughes 的头像
Damien A. Hughes3 个月前

@prageru what's the argument here? if the us gets universal healthcare and adopts measures to address wealth inequality all of a sudden food, appliances, and cars will be scarce? we'll be forced to abandon our capitalist system for an authoritarian command economy? i don't think so

Mike Jones 的头像
Mike Jones3 个月前

@prageru But, surely the left will eventually get it to work and we should be grateful to be collateral damage in their achievement of this glorious nirvana? “You will have nothing and you will be happy” is a command and not a prediction of how we will feel about being destroyed.