This exponential increase in these rodents will eventually cost billions.
@MartinKennedyVP2.1K followers
162,569 views
43 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@DougWanstall
I’m a farmer, we have beavers in the area & I am very pleased we do. Farmers need to work out a way to manage land in harmony with nature not consider it a threat. We are entering a new paradigm in land management & the choice will be either work with nature or exit the industry
358 likes

@MartinKennedyVP
I have worked with nature all my life and am proud of all the lap wings, oyster catchers and curlews etc that are here. That’s happened because of a managed balance and good farming practice. This is different, as there is no understanding of the eventual cost to our taxpayers.
16 likes

@matthay44
@DougWanstall There is more to nature than ground nesting birds. You can’t cherry pick which bits of our natural heritage belong and which don’t. If we’d hunted curlews and lapwings to extinction, as we did with beavers, they’d merit reintroduction just the same.
63 likes

@MartinKennedyVP
@DougWanstall Strange statement, there is no conflict with the aforementioned. 400 years ago there was only 500m people on the planet, there is now 16 times that and we need to play our part in helping to feed that growing population. In global terms we can do that more sustainably than most.
1 like

@DonnachadhMc
@matthay44 @DougWanstall Simple. Plant based diet feeds humanity & 30% of land 4 nature. We need to end centuries of obliteration of wildlife by rich landowners.

@DougWanstall
I agree that is a very simple way to look at it. No doubt plant based diets would be far better for the environment and no doubt we need to see significant changes in land management to reverse the damage done by industrial agriculture. BUT giving up all meat is not a pragmatic solution, if you believe it is, just look at the % of veganism globally, it may be edging up but not at a pace that exceeds increased consumption.

@gow_derek
What complete and utter nonsense. I am always astounded when videos like this turn at the end to tell taxpayers that the fictitious bill for non existent nonsense is coming their way when tax payers are already paying their narrators handsomely for simply existing.
105 likes

@howemill
How much food is at risk given that 80% cereals grown in Scotland aren’t eaten by people?
50 likes

@ASPaton
Beavers should be found thriving & widespread throughout our countryside. They are biodiversity enablers & help mitigate against some of the extremes found in a climate & nature crisis. Time to have some enlightenment 🦫
39 likes

@LowAuldgirth
But how much will they save? As they beaver away reducing the risk of extreme flooding, extreme drought, increasing fish stocks. Our current land and water management systems are failing us, why shouldn’t we look to more natural impactful ways to deal with the issue?
36 likes

@The_Q_R
*Puts on dusty Zoologist hat* Beavers are, overwhelmingly, of benefit to the health of forest ecosystems. This isn't a matter of opinion, it is a well-established fact. With solid management, Beaver enhancements of ecosystems are of huge benefit to farmers. The Scottish Government has a solid licensing system in place, and long-term plan. Time will tell if adjustments are needed, but folks aren't just tipping beavers into the country and hoping for the best. As to their infrastructure impacts - overwhelmingly good when it come to flood risk, and mixed in other respects. Well there are around 15 million beavers in the USA, and their bridges and agriculture haven't collapsed. So leave the beavers to get on with improving the environment and make the most of the licensing system.
31 likes

@colin_mcp
Ah so how many trees have farmers cut down? But please cut the hyperbole - Beavers are coming back so work out how to live with them. They will likely cut down flooding - are you against that too?
28 likes

@RewildScotland
What is the threat you are pointing at on the far bank?
27 likes

@TimKendall70
More evidence, if any were needed, that the NFU sees biodiversity as an inconvenience at best.
27 likes

@rewilderlands
Trees in rivers are part of nature, beavers are part of nature, untidiness and chaos are nature, words like ‘green agenda and rodents” pretty much sum up your perspective, millions are sick of the tragic loss in biodiversity, learn to live with nature, not having to control it.
21 likes

@gow_derek
What utter shite.
18 likes

@SamwiseGandy
What utter twaddle, but exactly the kind of thing I've come to expect from @NFUtweets. Beavers provide a range of important ecosystem services with economic benefits, and the costs of beaver management will be far out-weighed by the benefits they provide.
18 likes

@JeremyDBarrell
This is utter nonsense, where is the real harm? Thankfully, not all farmers are in this mould, but it shows why we are in such an ecological mess. Just one agenda being pushed to the exclusion of all others.
18 likes

@ASPaton
In a climate and nature crisis, farming and conservation groups should all come together to offer positive solutions that can help mitigate against climate change. Beaver re-introduction is one of those solutions, with appropriate management, that allows solutions.
13 likes

@WildByrne
I appreciate your perspective, but it seems like at a minimum there might be a wee bit of exaggeration or more likely, a complete fiction (others on this thread have already highlighted the reasoning). Being hyperbolic helps no one.
11 likes















