This is bad writing?

She has nothing of substance to offer except braindead takes when she should be offline taking care of her kid.

Nemik's character was handled with such dignity. It stood out to me when I rewatched it this month just how easy it would have been for him to come across as the cliché young nerdy character. But no. The character was smart, philosophical, comforting, and filled with such hope.

“One of the most dazzling and inventive books I’ve read in a very long time—a novel I continue to describe as indescribable. I’ve now read it twice and can’t decide if it’s a thriller, a farce, a political commentary. I don’t know what it is other than I love it” —Writers at Work

Meanwhile, their examples of great writing:

ThatStarWarsGirl has no real opinions. She’s a cosplayer and that’s about it.

The biggest problem of Andor is that SW fans are watching it

Obviously not. Which do you think is best: Luthen's speech about scrifice, Maarva's funeral recording, or this? I can't decide.

Luthen’s speech is the best one, however, I’m biased towards Nemik’s.

Her brain doesn't function so obvious she'd think so

Yes. It's all overly edgy slop but you imbeciles think it's smart because it's not done in pastel colours

Nemiks manifesto ⚒️ Love it