“This is practically a science experiment to see what Hamas actually cares about. It is entirely about the humiliation of having a Jewish state on that land.” @Coldxman debates Dave Smith on why, despite both countries blockading Gaza, Hamas rockets fire only at Israel.

I love Douglass Murray as a writer and guest speaker, but he didn’t have the temperament of Coleman. Coleman is so calm and even deadpan at times that he scares me. Just the nicest guy on earth that can hold his heart rate at a perfect level to carry bad arguments to their eventual end without getting caught in any debate traps.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Expelled… they went a few miles down the road and could’ve had any life they wanted. Gaza city had nice shops, universities, cafes etc. it looked like a regular city. They had their land and squandered it bc they can’t stand living next to a Jewish state.

@TheFP @coldxman @ComicDaveSmith about as spot on as it gets and @ComicDaveSmith (who has never told a joke) just throws out random events without context, reasoning but adds layers of contempt and condescension as his “humor”. It’s fucking weird.

great reply to the failed comedian! He also stated some misleading info and the actual facts are: Israel fully withdrew from Gaza in 2005 under its Disengagement Plan, removing all troops and settlements. Since then, Gaza has been governed internally by Hamas, not under Israeli military occupation. Israel and Egypt jointly control Gaza’s borders for security reasons.

.@coldxman: "Egypt occupied Gaza for 19 years. Did not give them a state. Could have given them a state. Did not." Sorry, but no. Just read the Egypt-Israel General Armistice Agreement. Egypt couldn't have given Palestinians a state even if it wanted to. The 1949 Armistice Demarcation Line around Gaza wasn't a border; it was a temporary ceasefire line. The Agreement was explicit that the line was "not to be construed in any sense as a political or territorial boundary, and is delineated WITHOUT PREJUDICE to rights, claims and positions of either Party to the Armistice as regards ultimate settlement of the Palestine issue." While Egypt administered military rule over that land, Egypt did not have sovereignty or title to the land to give away. Egypt treated it as Palestinian territory pending a final settlement.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith I would say Coleman schooled Dave, not debated him.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Roughly 250K already lived in Gaza/WB and only "displaced" because Jordan and Egypt denied citizenship. Israel also offered over 100K to return, they declined. Nearly 1M Jews were expelled from the Arab world in 1948..."that happened too"

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith @coldxman I appreciate having the conversation with @ComicDaveSmith, but there is so much in what he said that woefully inaccurate. There is a lot of material on this subject to domonstate that. Ilan Pepe’s work, which Dave is citing has been debunked for 50 years.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Dave is a failed science experiment of liberal Jew.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Coleman is so damn good at this.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith @ComicDaveSmith has a moral universalist code- that Israel dominating Palistinian land is indefensible, even if to keep Israeli's safe. This stands in contrast to @convoswcoleman Hobbesian/realist take, in which Israel's foremost moral responsibility is the safety of Israelis.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith I'll admit, I had to pause and take a break from listening to Dave several times to get through all 3.5 hours, but it was well worth the listen.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Have said this so many times now. Dave Smith is an idiot

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith God bless you for your calm demeanor in dealing with this buffoon.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Truly amazing composure by Coleman. My big takeaway from the episode is that in Smith's worldview, undisputed facts are still theoretical, but theories are actually undisputed facts.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Dave Smith is a fool

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Excellent debate. I passed along to someone who continues to claim Smith has credibility just because he’s on Rogan.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith This failed comic spits hate for money and fame after reading one book by a hack who does the same. Hard to imagine anyone sane still taking this jihad fanboy seriously ,except other jihad fanboys.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Put it in my veins. I ❤️ Coleman

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Absolutely right, Coleman. If the folks who ethnically cleansed Palestine had created a Christian or Hindu or Buddhist state, Hamas would be totally fine with that. It's having your people killed and your land stolen by Jews that's the problem.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith This wasn’t a debate. It was a massacre. Someone dial 911

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Islamic terrorists blow up inanimate statues that didn’t do anything to them. Yet when they blow up human beings suddenly it’s because those humans must have done something to make the terrorists angry.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Coleman Hughes is so much smarter and better read than the comic.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Egypt wouldn’t open the border to women and kids in a “genocide” to prevent Hamas infiltration, which pro-Hamas folks defended on the basis of not “facilitating Israel’s ethnic cleansing campaign”…yet by their own arguments, that left women and kids in a “genocidal” war zone! 🤷‍♂️

@TheFP @coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Exactly - it’s like the elephant in the room

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Why is smith so thoroughly deranged??? By what? I don't get it

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith No, Uncle Coleman, it's about resisting white European land-thieves and their servant-class of Mizrahi, Sephards, Yemenis and Ethiopians.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Smith got schooled! Badly. And you did it in such a respectful way.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Dave has de intelectual profundity or a leaking sink. Dumb as a fucking rock this pompous ass is. He is the actual reason why shampoo bottles come with instructions

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith I did not know how Coleman was till I watched this podcast. Now I am huge fan .

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Dave hates that Hamas is losing 😂. Dave, they’re not rational people.

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith People in the west not understanding honor-Shame culture is why they feel so strongly about this yet miss the mark so epically. West Point Military Academy does teach this though

@coldxman @ComicDaveSmith Coleman owned that idiot .