This is the second time in a row I've asked the First Minister about protecting women and girls from male violence. This summer, three Scottish women died at the hands of men. It is a failure of Parliament if we don't reverse this trend and protect women and girls. #fmq

Alex, being direct here - unless and until you properly explain your comments about "we did it for you Beth", a male who has posed online with weapons, threatening women, it's impossible to take you as a credible voice on this important topic. Literally impossible.

Women need protecting from violent men like “Beth” and you voted for men like him to be allowed access to women’s single sex spaces. Sit this one out Alex you raging hypocrite.

What are women and girls, Alex?

You want to put men in women's spaces. You don't give a fuck about women's safety

🙄 I don’t know how you have the gall. Perhaps you could prevent men like this one from entering our spaces and services. That might help 👍

You refused to back survivors of the male violence of prostitution when they bravely spoke of their experience of being dehumanised by men who bought and reviewed them as sexual products, fueling the market demand to sell, groom, traffick and adverise them. They tried to tell MSPs that most entertain the sex trade as children because young and vulnerable is the porn driven demand. You ignored them, despite LibDem voters being amongst the highest supporters of criminalising sex buyers. The shame is on sex buyers who exploit and harm and on those in power who refuse to take responsibility to act - it is not the shame of those exploited.

But Alex you and your party cannot tell us what a woman is - so how can you protect what you do not know?

Have you figured out whether "Isla Bryson" is a man or a woman yet Alex?

Oh shut up. You think violent men should be in women's prisons.

Look at you, proud as the dad in The Sullivans that knife-playing, woman-hating "Beth" was one of the men fronting Sturgeon's campaign to destroy the rights of women in Scotland. Shame on you.

The absolute shame of this After everything you did to remove sex based safeguards & women's rights All you did to protect & enable dangerous men with paraphilias access girls and women when most vulnerable

You are one of the politicians that are getting called out for supporting literal violence against us - working through the night so Beth Pickles can self ID into rape crisis shelters, cross our boundaries and threaten us online with axes and Glasgow gangster talk. You have a fucking cheek.

Oh your hypocrisy is off the scale. You defended men in women's prisons, you deny women the right to safe single sex spaces, you pander to violent, abusive males. Your party enables abusive men.

You told GRR activists you passed the bill for ‘Beth,’ a campaigner linked to abusive posts featuring knives and targeting women, including ex‑MSP Joan McAlpine. Feminist groups say this exposed MSPs’ bias, sidelined women’s safety concerns, and normalised hostility toward women.

You previously said you were ‘doing it for Beth’ ie writing policy to allow this man into female only spaces - a man who posed with axes & knives, & regards female supporters of sex-based legal rights as fascists who should be “throatpunched”. Why would any woman trust you now?

Until you recognise women as a completely separate category from men, you have nothing of any value to say on this.

If those men put wigs on and called themselves "Becky", would it make a difference?

You'll not achieve anything while you perpetuate the hostile environment for women created when women are expected to pretend some men are women.

From the man driving a horse and cart though women’s rights Ever come across the word chutzpah?

Are you trolling us? You were willing to open up women’s spaces to every man and probably still are a supporter of self-id. Voted against Ash Regan’s unbuyable bill. This is just peformative tosh.

How dare you pretend you care about the safety of women and girls, Alex. You’ve flatly refused to put our most basic needs - dignity, safety and privacy - before the needs of some very strange and entitled MEN.

Oh shutup you big fraud

You support men in women’s spaces ! You’d have men boxing women and call it inclusion. You favour letting many thousands of unvetted migrants from 3rd world countries into Scotland - then blame social media for the increase in sexual assault. HYPOCRITE!

“We’re doing it for Beth”

The brass neck on you. You can’t even define a woman, and you don’t give a shiny shit about our safety and privacy. Your public, drooling adoration of “Beth” proved that.

How do you NOT see the contradiction in advocating for the protection of women and girls while being rabidly pro opening up all of our safe spaces to men?! Seriously?!

wasn't Beth a violent male? but I thought you do it all for him. remember that time you voted AGAINST adding protections in the GRR bill for women and girls, IN FAVOUR OF SEX OFFENDERS? i do.

You doing this for Beth, Alex?

So you can define what a woman is now? That's refreshing. Now that you know what a woman is. Can you tell us why violence against them is any worse than ahyone else. Was Liam Fee, just for example, unimportant because he had a penis?

If you cannot define us, you cannot protect us.

You’ve got to be fucking kidding?!?! YOU would put male rapists in places where women are vulnerable because they claim to be women. Sit the fuck down Alex.

You will always be thought of as a misogynist, trying to remove women's rights to keep your violent transvestite men-friends happy. You don't care about women's safety. You're a liar & hypocrite & we will never forget

Are you doing this for Beth as well?

You’re so performative. You don’t seem to stand for much except that which makes you feel warm and nice, such is the success of your campaigning. Politics as an act of self-pleasuring.