Video wird geladen...

Video konnte nicht geladen werden

Zur Startseite

Wales is getting screwed over the Treasury (again). A deliberate decision has robbed public sector bodies in Wales of money while protecting those in England. This is fiddly but really outrageous. You can either watch the video or read below... [Thread]

89,099 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr •via X (Twitter)

11 Kommentare

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

Last year, Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced that on April 6 this year, employers will have to pay higher National Insurance contributions. Obviously this will hit public sector employers as well as private sector ones.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

To make up for this, Ms Reeves had said that the UK Treasury would cover the increased public sector costs for public bodies. Fair enough right? However Wales has a proportionately larger public sector than England.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

Why is this a problem? Well it wouldn’t be if the Treasury were simply going to give Wales the cash to make up the shortfall. Alas, they are not.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

Instead they are calculating the amount of money using the Barnett formula. Under this, Wales only gets an increase in funding proportional to England which means… Because England’s public sector is smaller, Wales proportionately gets less money.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

If you want this in plain simple English then here it is:

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

Mark Drakeford has said that he had pointed this out to the Treasury but they haven't changed the decision... He said:

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

Seriously, is this what a partnership in power looks like? Yet again the UK Treasury is using accountancy sleight of hand to leave Wales worse off for the sake of what would be not much more than a rounding error on their spreadsheets.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

This is exactly why it is not acceptable for Labour to say they do not want to engage with constitution debates. These arguments are not important just to constitutional anoraks.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

It's about enshrining into law the safeguards to Wales’ future funding. It is simply not acceptable for Cymru to rely on Mark Drakeford making supplications to his fellow party members in London. Wales’ prosperity should not be dependent on the goodwill of a Treasury official.

Profilbild von Will Hayward
Will Haywardvor 1 Jahr

If you value this sort of journalism please consider signing up to my news letter (see pinned tweet). Thanks!

Profilbild von Vance Ginn
Vance Ginnvor 1 Jahr

Imagine a government where big government doesn't burden your future with excessive spending, taxes, and regulations. Here's how... 👇

Ähnliche Videos

Here are 3 ways that the current system screws over Wales. If politicians are not talking about these issues, they are not serious about fixing Wales' problems. ---------- 1. The Welsh Gov has less borrowing powers than a council. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿Wales can only borrow £150m a year (and £1bn in total). That is the equivalent of just 0.57% of our budget. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿Scotland can borrow £450m a year (and £3bn in total). This makes it really hard for Wales to make big investments like building hospitals and schools unless we use super expensive funding models like PFI. The worst thing is, Scotland's borrowing rates have increased with inflation every year since 2016 whereas Wales' have been frozen! ---------- 2. Wales’ can’t even spend its own money If Wales makes good financial decisions and has money left at the end of the year, it is only allowed to carry over a very small amount. The total the Welsh Government can have in the reserve is £350m. While that might sound like a lot, it really isn’t in a government context. The Welsh Government’s budget is £27bn. This means that the Welsh reserve is just 1.35% of its budget. And that £350m isn’t per year, that is the total it can carry. This means that if the Welsh Government reserve is full, then any money that isn’t spent is just taken back by the Treasury in Westminster. What makes this system even worse is that the UK Treasury has imposed limits on how much of its own reserves Wales can even use! Of the £350m Wales can only access £175m a year. Scotland has a reserve of £700m AND it has no limit on how much of that it can spend. Plus yet again, Scotland’s was linked to inflation whereas Wales’ wasn’t. There is simply no justification for Wales being treated differently to Scotland. The UK Government isn’t able to get away with treating Scotland like Wales because the Scots wouldn’t stand for it. ---------- 3. Rail Because rail is devolved in Scotland, when the UK Government spends money in England on rail, Scotland gets extra cash. Scotland gets billions of pounds in extra funding because of HS2 (which is only in England). But because rail isn’t devolved to Wales, the Treasury can class HS2 as an “England and Wales project” meaning Wales gets nothing. It is worse than that. Because HS2 is counted as a Welsh project, it stops Wales getting extra money in the future because on the spreadsheet it looks like Wales has already had investment (even though it all went to England). ---------- You could have the best politicians in the world in Cardiff Bay but they still couldn’t fix Wales’ problems because the tools at their disposal are not fit for purpose. The challenges Wales faces are not because of immigrants, they are because the system of funding we have is set up so that we can’t fail to fail.

Will Hayward

17,345 Aufrufe • vor 2 Monaten