Skip navigation
Warning: This Carl Sagan explaination has caused existential crises.
0:00 / 9:29

Warning: This Carl Sagan explaination has caused existential crises.

Darshak Rana ⚡️

@thedarshakrana129K followers

Visit on X
19,763 likesDownloadOriginal post

1,543,835 views

Warning: This Carl Sagan explaination has caused existential crises. He explains how 5th dimensional beings perceive 3D creatures, and the implications are so disturbing, I paused it three times. He said: A being from the 5th dimension could reach into your locked house, take an object off your kitchen table, and place it in orbit around Jupiter without ever crossing a wall, a door, or the vacuum of space. People ridiculed when Carl Sagan said this. But, he was walking through the cleanest piece of geometric logic in modern physics, and most people who watched it never realized what he actually gave them. The demonstration starts small. Imagine a flat creature living on a sheet of paper. Its entire universe is length and width. It has no concept of "up" because up doesn't exist in its world. The direction is literally unthinkable to its nervous system. Now take a three-dimensional apple and push it slowly through the paper. What does the flat creature see? A dot appears from nowhere. The dot expands into a circle. The circle grows, shrinks, then collapses back into nothing. The apple was always whole. The flatlander only ever perceived cross-sections of something its dimensions could not contain. That's the entire trick. Sagan's move was to rotate the analogy upward and let you feel the vertigo yourself. You are the flatlander. Your body, your brain, your sensory apparatus evolved to process three spatial dimensions and one directional slice of time. Anything existing in a higher dimension would pass through your world the same way that apple passed through the paper. As fragments, apparitions, sudden appearances, inexplicable disappearances. A 4D being could see every organ in your body simultaneously from the outside, the way you can see every room of a dollhouse at once from above. A 5D being could observe your entire lifetime from every version of you from infant to corpse like a single unmoving sculpture stretched across time. What's interesting is it's a direct consequence of how dimensions mathematically nest inside one another. Every dimension has full access to the interior of the one below it. A 3D hand can touch any point inside a 2D square without crossing its edges. A 4D hand could touch any point inside your sealed body without breaking your skin. Sagan has really handed us a quiet reframe of every "impossible" phenomenon humans have reported for thousands of years like visions, presences, objects moving through walls, beings that seem to know your past and future. Though his Geometry doesn't confirm any of it. But it removes the argument that such things would violate physics.

33 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Sir Woofington's profile picture

    @SFluffybollocks

    Is that why I have no matching socks?

    160 likes

  • RIFT's profile picture

    @RIFT_589

    Can't shake the feeling that Mr. Smith from the Matrix movies took his on-screen cadence and entonations from this Carl Sagan video. The similarities are too close!

    72 likes

  • Darshak Rana ⚡️'s profile picture

    @thedarshakrana

    Freedom is having thoughts that are actually yours. So you stop living someone else's life and feel miserable. Here's how I broke out:

    72 likes

  • Joe Smith - Parody 🥇's profile picture

    @WaveWisperer

    Yes, it clearly explains the supernatural and is a strong premise for the argument that: 'No one can claim ( from their limited 3 dimensions) that there is no God.' It also matches what God has revealed about Himself in the Bible, that He is the Alpha and Omega. He stands outside of time. Outside of His creation. Far above all that we are or could imagine. If your worldview starts there, a lot of things will make a whole lot more sense. 'The fear of the Lord, is the beginning of wisdom' Proverbs 9:10

    64 likes

  • Info2Consider's profile picture

    @Info2Consider

    A Flatlander would be foolish to insist that reality contains only what can be explained from inside two dimensions. We should be equally careful about assuming that the Creator of space, time, matter and the laws governing them must Himself be confined by space, time, matter and those laws. Scripture made that distinction thousands of years ago: “Behold, the heaven and heaven of heavens cannot contain thee.” — 1 Kings 8:27 “Whither shall I go from thy spirit? or whither shall I flee from thy presence?” — Psalm 139:7 “For a thousand years in thy sight are but as yesterday…” — Psalm 90:4 Higher-dimensional geometry doesn’t prove God exists. But it demonstrates something important: our inability to visualize a mode of existence does not establish its impossibility. A creature living inside creation should be particularly cautious about declaring what the Creator of creation can or cannot be.

    59 likes

  • Carla Digrugilliers's profile picture

    @CarlaDigru38122

    @elonmusk Carl Sagan is one of my hero's and writers ✍️ he saw beyond the matrix

    42 likes

  • Sheep Suit's profile picture

    @SuitSheep

    Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions book by Edwin Abbott explored this in 1884. The book has been in print since then.

    35 likes

  • Les Reed's profile picture

    @NewageReed

    This explains why we cant find our apple slicer that just mysteriously disappeared from our house. We've looked everywhere! Now we know it was a member of The 5th Dimension!

    34 likes

  • Alyx's profile picture

    @Qubit36

    @elonmusk Sagan’s geometry is correct. Kaluza already showed a 5th dimension can touch every point in 3D without crossing a wall, that’s where electromagnetism comes from.

    31 likes

  • Val Saven's profile picture

    @valsaven

    > A 5D being could observe your entire lifetime from every version of you from infant to corpse like a single unmoving sculpture stretched across time. But doesn’t that mean everything is already predetermined and we are simply playing out pre-written scripts?🤔

    26 likes

  • Nayaswami Kamala's profile picture

    @NayaswamiKamala

    @elonmusk Didn’t anyone read Edwin Abbott Abbott’s “Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions”, first published in 1884? It explains all this very well.

    26 likes

  • Diogenes The Cynic 🚫🐂💩's profile picture

    @AcePrimero

    Except that the 2D square is actually 3D. It's just infinitely thin compared to a 3D object. This isn't a lesson on dimensions. It's a lesson on perspective, which as they say, is everything.

    24 likes

  • Bmanfu's profile picture

    @BBmanfu

    Tertium organum by P.D. Ouspensky goes into this pretty deep.

    22 likes

  • Tina✨🕊️'s profile picture

    @TinaHar5315

    @elonmusk These are the conversations I live for. Give me a mystery or something that spikes my curiosity and I’m all in — my mind just won’t stop. I love that there are dimensions we can’t even see. Is there time travel between them?

    21 likes

  • Charles Waters's profile picture

    @RelaxedPop

    A Flatland movie was made and is on Youtube...

    21 likes

  • AnOldMan's profile picture

    @RecklessOldMan

    @elonmusk Billions of people just living out their lives, oblivious.

    18 likes

  • Hope d'Amore's profile picture

    @10ATexan

    People like to mock those with extraordinary ideas, it makes them feel less small while proving how small they are. The same people work to make science as opaque as possible and disliked Sagan for making science accessible to ordinary people - they mockingly called it “Saganizing” science.

    18 likes

  • Siouxie 🕊️ 🇺🇸 "We hold these truths..."'s profile picture

    @SiouxieChit

    Interesting because Sagan's 5D explanation could illustrate why so many Near Death Experience (NDE) retellings include what's called a Life Review. If we arrive at a higher dimension at death, seeing our entire life at once makes sense. Just because we can. For the first time!

    16 likes

  • 🤡🥊𝕃𝕪𝕝𝕖 𝕥𝕙𝕖 ℂ𝕝𝕠𝕨𝕟🃏's profile picture

    @LyleClown

    Carl sounds like a white Morpheus. Similar chair too.

    15 likes

  • Kyle's profile picture

    @KylePostingOnX

    I always liked this explanation.

    15 likes