"We Have Some Planes" -- Is that really Mohamed Atta??

I mean another expert identified “Jewish” dialect

Full report:

Linguist here-- this is incorrect. It is all a matter of where English is learned and who the impactful speakers were when he ingested and learned English.

She discusses his English exposure, his German exposure, etc. If you're really a linguist, read the report and then comment, citing actual statements from the report.

Yeah, because that person is Israeli. A native Hebrew speaker from Israel, not like the true Hebrew, but the Hebrew from Israel.

this is Caribbean accent, most probably a black person.

According to the forensic linguist, this person is right 👆 Very interesting how so many people want to hear an Israeli accent Can we please try to be a little evidence-based and rigorous?

Thank you. This is 100% NOT a native Egyptian speaker. More of a Hebrew native speaker.

"Mom, this is Mark Bingham. I want to let you know I love you". Who calls their own mom and identifies themselves by first and last names? No one, that's who! Plus, she seemed very happy in the news interview. Not mourning at all.

Yeah, they went to school in America. They learned how to fly planes in America. They were literally American students.

What is your point? Foreign students who spend a year in America don’t suddenly sound American. Besides, the accent in the audio is not American. It’s consistent with Caribbean and West African varieties, according to the linguist.

The degree of people hearing what they want to hear (it's Israeli!) or conjuring up explanations to explain the lack of Arabic features is wild. Read the report, and if you disagree with the analysis, cite exactly which statements you disagree with and why. Otherwise it's noise.

We all know who did it but afraid to say one word …. It’s the one that benefited the most, very simple

Mohammed Atta spoke German well before fully settling in Germany, lived there primarily from mid-1992 until 1999/2000 (roughly 7–8 years), and reached strong fluency through study in Egypt plus years of daily use and academic work in Hamburg. Analysis of his accent - pointless

She discusses his exposure to German. Read the report and then comment.

Don't tell me what to do I am not going to download the pdf file in order to get the report If you want to tell me why my comment is incorrect based upon the report, I'll read it

@DesignerDeb3

Matches “Hebrew accent”

It’s this idiot

What a surprise 🇮🇱

sounds jamaican! wtf?

Yes, the forensic linguist concluded it was most consistent with a Caribbean or West African varieties of English.

Hebrew accent

He sounded Jamaican

The linguist concluded the collection of accent features in the audio is most consistent with Caribbean and West African varieties of English, so it would make sense that's what your ear hears.

🇮🇱

Sounds Indian

9/11 Flight AA11 Audio with transcripts:

Israelis did it

The word airport almost sounded Austrian.

Nowadays he would be labeled as a “Massachusetts man” that’s a mossad agent Your biases are glaring again

Sounds Indian to me

Sounds very Israeli

We all knew what happened why do we still go to this bullshit? We know Wat did it. We all know who did it

It sounds like a Jewish accent

@SeharaNatural Should include recordings of native Arabic speakers pronouncing the word “airplane.”

You found a good grift. I applaud you.

This is the same accent that we are now surrounded by just trying to go to the grocery store. Let that sink in.

What low level hasbara is this? Lmao this dude sound like he born and raised in tel aviv. Just watch any video of a tel aviv inhabitant speaking english. Carribean? Yall are fucking retarded fr

what of Atta's girlfriend Amanda Keller, did she comment?

Clearly Israeli accent