Gezinmeyi atla
We might have misunderstood the Dunning Kruger effect
0:00 / 5:56

We might have misunderstood the Dunning Kruger effect

Sabine Hossenfelder

@skdh243 B takipçi

X profili
1.461 beğeniİndirOrijinal gönderi

82.325 görüntüleme

We might have misunderstood the Dunning Kruger effect

33 Yorum

Yorumlar X (Twitter) üzerindeki orijinal gönderiden alınmıştır

  • Mr. K. profil fotoğrafı

    @sirstripy

    (Shows a vague cloud of dots.) "If we drew a line here..." Modern science in one picture.

    14 beğeni

  • Sabine Hossenfelder profil fotoğrafı

    @skdh

    😂

    4 beğeni

  • Mr. K. profil fotoğrafı

    @sirstripy

    I mean, it's not a surprise they struggle with reproducibility. There is nothing to reproduce in the first place.

    1 beğeni

  • Pepe-chan profil fotoğrafı

    @2v987b6c6x

    What if the data analysts were the idiots we met along the way?

    13 beğeni

  • Sabine Hossenfelder profil fotoğrafı

    @skdh

    yes

    8 beğeni

  • Chris Fraser profil fotoğrafı

    @defrisselle

    Hmm maybe Dunning & Kruger thought they were smarter than they really were then they came up with this "effect"

    5 beğeni

  • gru profil fotoğrafı

    @rocket_rui

    if i don’t read Psychology studies, saving my brain, i will get things more right just by chance alone

    4 beğeni

  • Roger Sayer 💙 profil fotoğrafı

    @Borissidis89

    Truth is everyone can be idiots.. Crystalised intelligence isnt intelligence its memory that it can be recalled upon..

    3 beğeni

  • Marcos Sánchez Muriel profil fotoğrafı

    @MarcosSnchezMu1

    We thought we understood it very well, but that's just because we barely understood it, a meta Dunning-Kruger effect.

    3 beğeni

  • Noora profil fotoğrafı

    @gynemimesis

    Brilliant. This should be the introduction to how to lie with statistics

    2 beğeni

  • K.J. profil fotoğrafı

    @Kerberuzs

    Another stupid psychology paper proving another stupid psychology paper is stupid. In other words, another normal day in science.

    2 beğeni

  • synont profil fotoğrafı

    @synont_official

    Nice blob. If it wasn't the system problem, I'd find energy to laugh instead of eye bleeding. Bros at Cornell don't know how to calc the simple Poissonian error bar ±√N for each data point to invalidate own work. Two possibilities: 1) either the entire blob becomes a precisely defined single data point and cannot be fitted; 2) or each point as a single measurement acquires a 100% uncertainty error bar, letting the error cover the whole blob.

    2 beğeni

  • Hookah profil fotoğrafı

    @ThisGuyHookah

    What I've noticed is the the Dunning Kruger effect requirers persistent incorrectness. Idiots today mix match knowledge of something they do know and have great interest in while in the same sentence or conversation make an ignorant confident conviction of a claim they know noting about.

    2 beğeni

  • Murry profil fotoğrafı

    @Murry_Rhodes

    Haha, I run across folks using Dunning-Kruger or similar mechanisms by folks in higher positions of authority insisting they know best at home because of age, at work because of rank, or in communication with well-read recital academics who never understood the basic principles but could recite a textbook version verbatim and all the names associated with them, unfortunately, though they can't improvise and engage with the content of a question and so run the Dunning-Kruger of authority to gain some kind of superiority instead of just sharing information. By the time you get older, you realise that time is only an opportunity to learn something. Not everyone uses their time to learn so the home rank-by-age system is busted, and not every high-ranking officer at work got their position from learning the ropes, busted again. As far as academics go, using their post letters or Dunning-Kruger, they simply don't know enough to engage with the content intelligently, or they are just rude twats whose answers would most likely be geared to belittle others. Ironically, I have recently seen a few years ago a classic of an old knowledge pursuit institute that may not be recognised as being quite astute in the pursuit as a university but still has quite some sway in the economy. A speech that included a clear and present dismissal of higher authorities of universities for their arrogance in not listening to what their higher officers had to offer, like a cry of having been Dunning-Krugered, but later in the speech regarded their own hierarchy of knowledge to be sacred and insisted that you of lower rank will never be more right than an officer of a higher-ranked officer and proceeded to recite a Dunning-Kruger equivalent. My conclusion of this is that some people can become conflicted with their own insecurities and will use cheap tools of degradation to feel higher by diminishing others. They don't seem to realise that almost everyone in the room sees it for what it is but very rarely calls it out. The good thing is, though, that not everyone is like this, so you generally find the info you need if you ask enough folks or find the right notes.

    1 beğeni

  • Audens profil fotoğrafı

    @Audens6

    Next up: Can 2 people who know nothing about a topic know less than 1 person who knows nothing? Give a listen!

    1 beğeni

  • deepsight profil fotoğrafı

    @DeepsightDelta

    Nah . . lets just simplify it Shit talkers always deliver shit People who work don't have for shit talk because they are working To talk shit, you have have to be ignorant about the actual subject . . thats why its shit Apply it to the project life cycle You get this

    1 beğeni

  • Chabranigdo profil fotoğrafı

    @chabranigdo

    Dunning Kruger is such a mass hit with the normies, because everyone knows people with delusions of adequacy. It's one of the most basic "Yea, no shit" observations.

    1 beğeni

  • Heath H profil fotoğrafı

    @workhostage

    Some more than others. I think there is a graph that might explain why...

    1 beğeni

  • Jaime Cooke (Old Greenone) Space Pirate. profil fotoğrafı

    @GreenoneOld

    I saw this and thought that there must be something I'm not seeing here that makes sense to them. I'm just a builder and line cook so I don't have the education.... Nope. A real scientist looks at it and is wondering the same thing. "look at the data!"😆.

    1 beğeni

  • Rusty Shackleford profil fotoğrafı

    @fingeringblacks

    It depends on the category. Dunning Kruger effect won’t apply to arm wrestling. But it will apply to card games like poker.

    1 beğeni