WE STILL DON’T GET BRACKET 4
@playtowinmtg1.8万 位关注者
38,734 次观看
32 条评论
评论来自 X (Twitter) 上的原帖

@laidbacknoble
It’s just suped up bracket three. Leave us in peace lol. I don’t wanna have to win with thoracle or breach everytime.
32 个赞

@tkwg0
Bracket 4 is for people who don’t want to worry about the bracket system but are smart enough to not play “cedh”
28 个赞

@kc_ranger
To me, it probably boils down to making the deck the most optimized it can for that specific commander. For example, an Alela deck isn’t cEDH because the commander is bad. But if I make a deck optimizing it to its top potential, it’s too strong to sit at bracket 3
10 个赞

@Ory_Senpai
bracket 4 is for people who want to play cEDH, but don't want to play with THE PEOPLE who play cEDH.
6 个赞

@JT_Greis
Bracket 3 and 4 are for people who know what theyre doing but care more about having fun and playing what they want.
4 个赞

@mojaamusic
"your commander is strong, and you optimized your deck around it, why not throw that all away and play thoracleslop with the rest of us?"
3 个赞

@cytrexdestroyer
The basketball analogy doesn't make too much sense. Its more like B4 and cEDH are the equivalent to tuned street racing cars and Nascar/F1 racing. Nascar you have pure efficiency/speed. B4 you'll have more "flavor" like a street car would have "style"
3 个赞

@Pocky990707
maybe both formats are fake and people should be on 60 card if they want to play a competitive format 🤷
3 个赞

@UndesirableFowl
Bracket 4 isn’t fringe cedh for most pods, it’s just commander decks that are better than bracket 3s running strats that aren’t Cedh. Bracket 4 decks play combos like Kogla, E Wit, Extra turn spell not meta strats. heres my bracket 4 list for an example.
3 个赞

@wingenn69
I understand that the difference between low tier cedh and bracket 4 is weird but the best explanation I heard was from maldhound, bracket means you try to win with your commander in a certain way and try to do whatever you can to accomplish that as fast as possible. *
2 个赞

@TheSoullessEgo
Optimized strategy to play with a commander’s ability vs Optimized strategy to win. Bracket 4 plays optimized synergies, and winning is a symptom. CeDH plays optimized win cons, and synergy CAN be a symptom.
2 个赞

@KrakeJames
Hear me out, Bracket 4 is just Bracket 3 but without the soft bans where no one is allowed to bitch thay I played Wet Moon in my mono blue merfolk deck because I have islandwalk effects.
2 个赞

@OzEspen
The way I see it. You can make a strong combo deck in bracket 4 that does whatever wierd commander-centric combo engine or synergy you want. but when you put oracle/consult in your Yarok deck or led/freeze/breach in your Ghyrson Starn deck. its (bad) cedh.
1 个赞

@IsEltyr
What a dumbass take
1 个赞

@Euro_JV
"my deck is too strong for bracket 3"
1 个赞

@SeraphicLaw86
I'm not surprised you guys don't get it, but I do agree with your premise that brackets 4 and 5 are indistinguishable and therefor lack any real distinction beyond "this deck is better".
1 个赞

@teaseagee
I think the distinction on cedh vs bracket 4 is very nebulous and I should be allowed to call my deck a cedh deck because that is its intended purpose. Even though I play a “technically” bracket 4 deck because my commander is not in the metagame. It is built FOR CEDH.
1 个赞

@foodtimegaming
Because I like wincons outside of the usual cEDH thoracle/breach wins/etc, and b4 is "expected to play at least 4 turns" while cEDH I've seen people win on turn 0, that doesn't happen in B4
1 个赞

@Vuohenmor
Tbh I always thought B4 was for the retired cEDH decks.
1 个赞

@Nonesuch00
I still don't understand the difference between 4 and 5. 5 just means you have this niche little pool of cards you HAVE to include. I guess? But like if you're optimizing your deck fully, you'd be playing those ANYWAY if they were good into what you'd play against.












