What are your thoughts on this scene?

Cringe. Bucky is alive is trillion times better.

No debate 🤷🏻‍♂️

Who the hell calls his mother by her first name?

THAT’S EXACTLY MY POINT!!!

In the ultimate edition, it’s amazing how Luther manipulated Bruce and Clark into this fight. In the theatrical release, this scene didn’t make a lot of sense. The entire Luther manipulation scenes had been cut by WB. The premise was that Batman was attacking Superman solely on his own. In the ultimate edition, those 30 extra minutes detail Luther’s manipulations and how they drove Bruce nearly to the brink of murder. Luther perfectly understood how to push Bruce over the edge. Give Batman time to plan and he can beat anyone. But this scene also shows Clark’s inherent goodness. At any point in the Batman fight (pre kryptonite gas), Superman could have easily separated Batman’s head from his body and returned it to Luther to save his mother. Clark didn’t do that. He couldn’t. He tried to appeal to Bruce. He try to punch Bruce into submission. But he couldn’t kill Bruce. And Bruce didn’t realize he was actually using Clark’s humanity against him. That the thing that was preventing Clark from winning the fight was the humanity Bruce claimed Clark lacked. Clark was holding back until the kryptonite weaken him to the point he couldn’t fight back. Sadly, later in the movie, Batman succeeds in causing Superman’s death. The Kryptonite exposure weakened Superman to the point where Doomsday could kill him. What did Ares say - only a god can kill a god. Typhon struck the killing blow against Zeus but Hades weaked Zeus and made him killable.

The worst scene in comic book movie history.

Over hated but still couldve been executed differently

Good idea but terrible execution. People act like those that hate this scene don’t get it but it’s just executed badly

I don’t understand why this scene is so controversial. It shows both Superman and Batman humanity.

It’s a good scene and people just didn’t get it outside of “we have same mom”

Loved it

A beautiful scene that parallels Bruce’s parents, his realization that Superman’s mother is also named Martha, and how the stages Lex set on two titans to clashed puts Batman in a turmoil and realization that he has become the very thing he had sworn to be against.

The most ridiculous scene ever

Pissed me off then and pisses me off now. The greatest super hero ever and the worlds greatest detective both tricked very easily and the conclusion is the name Martha

I actually liked the scene a lot

Stupid

Perfect tbh, I loved it when i saw it opening day and still do. Misunderstood scene fr

I understand what they were going for. I wish there was one moment.. one where we had Clark looking up Bruce and mentioning their moms had the same name. It really would have made it fall into place more.

Bad scene. And not just because of the Martha thing, but because Batman was actually willing to kill Superman. Snyder never understood Batman.

It was too deep for Marvel fans who need every piece of info spoon fed to them. They’ve also never experienced the trauma of actually having to make real decisions. This moment humanized CLARK to BRUCE. Bruce realized he wasn’t vanquishing some demon, it was a man with a mom.

I absolutely DETEST Snyder Cultists more than anyone. However… it's nowhere near as bad as others claim, and it makes perfect sense why Bruce was triggered upon hearing the name. Lois stepping in to say, “It’s his mother’s name!” adds a layer of humanity to Superman that is essential to Batman realizing Clark has a human side.

Alternate scene: S: Save her... save Martha... B: Why did you say that name? WHY DID YOU SAY THAT NAME?! S: My... mom.... save my... *B looks shocked, cue flashback* B: Your mom...? *B turns to scan around with his one flickering tech eye and sees her heat signature* #BvS #Batman #Versus #Superman    #Alternate #Take #Script #Moment #Could #Have #Been #Done #Better

Conceptually interesting but the execution is atrocious. It speaks to how bad Snyder is with emotional scenes that he thought this overwrought bs was good.

Evolutional

I wish I liked it, the execution is just poor imo

Trash

It forces Bruce to confront his own trauma and realize that Superman, despite his godlike powers, hes just as human in his vulnerability and love for his mother. It's a powerful moment that resonates on a deeply human level, especially for those who have experienced real trauma.

Dogshit scene

I actually liked the poetic aspect it; I don't recall the "Mom's with the Same Name" being brought up in the comics.

I love it, great moment for Batfleck’s character

Hilarious

Like with all Snyders writing it gives very much “I’m 14 and this is deep” vibes

He should've found out about this long time ago before deciding to kill Superman. World's greatest detective? scratch that.

comedy gold

It wants to be The Dark Knight Returns so bad even uses the iconic Batman line from the graphic novel but it’s not that, Batman and Superman don’t have the same type of relationship here and it just falls flat once the Martha line comes into play and Doomsday steps into the ring