What is Xtina doing?

Cynthia Erivo sang it the best. Everybody else performed without an emotion.

Christina was doing too damn much

Christina girl water you doing

Right ? Lol

Yet Etta liked Christina’s version the best. That’s what matters

Because she knew it wasn’t better than hers

@cruelyouthordi3 Beys isn’t better either yet she still preferred Xtina’s

@cruelyouthordi3 Bey being better is exactly why are was jealous

Beyonce flowed evenly and didn't try to outdo the song. Cynthia was good, but a little airy at times. Celine was strong as always, but didn't pivot to sultriness as smoothly as the others. Christina is highly skilled, but played too much instead of allowing the song to flow out of her. It's all subjective. You like what you like, so don't take my opinion as anything special.

She's feelin it and making it her own! And Etta certainly enjoyed her so....

From this clip, Beyoncé understood the song and delivered a better version than the others. It Celine sounds too nasal, and Xtina is always trying to prove she’s a great singer instead of just singing… In this order: Beyoncé Cynthia Celine Xtina.

She’s American Idoling it. 🤮 I think Erivo gets it for vocals. Beyoncé for connecting with lyrics

Beyoncé hands down, Cynthia is second

Singing of course 🙄

That’s a terrible way of singing

Xtina the best followed by Celine then Cynthia. The other should be crossed off.

The only one invited to sing it for my president at his inauguration of course….

I'm impressed with Celine. Beyonce is normal. Cynthia didn't sustain. Christina... Just no

Cynthia Erivo’s version is the best here, effortless and authentic. Cristina Aguilera’s is the worst, pretentious and inauthentic. Beyonce is just relying on looks. Celine Dion is ok vanilla.

Too fucking much per usual. As always, Beyoncé bodying this song and singing it the way it should be sang

Damn! All of them are vocalist. But one is making a mess

Beyonce can’t b fckd with

The battle here is between Cynthia Erive and Celine Dion The other two can go to bed

Beyoncé can body any rendition!

Some of you should listen to The Orignal before choosing. Beyoncé & Cynthia 🔥

Cynthia, Cynthia, Cynthia 👏 Her voice is so smooth and soft like silk sheets!

Christina Aguilera is having fun with it. Even if you took away the belts, she would still sound amazing singing it with the softer vocal approach she uses here. When you have the range, you can do whatever you want with your voice. Etta James loved Xtina’s versions of At Last.

I enjoyed all of them surprisingly! I thought they all did it beautifully. I am most surprised by Cynthia, her voice is stunning. I really liked this whole video! Thank u for sharing it!🔥♥️🔥♥️🔥♥️🔥♥️

Beyoncé sounds the best and understands the song. Some people just be singing to be singing.

The only one making the song her own? Even if you don’t like her you gotta respect her talent. And she’s been singing it like that since she was 17.

I like Celine Dion’s and Erivo’s. Versions.

#beyonce clearly was the best and she even won a Grammy for it too!

Beyoncé could’ve done what Xtina is doing, but she knew the song didn’t call for all that. She killed it and still kept it classy.

Christina could’ve did a better job she dragged the vocals too hard but the winner for me was Celine she did just enough and hit the notes perfectly

Xtina did exactly what an artist should do… she put her stamp on it and made it her own. She didn’t just do what Etta did. That’s why Etta loved hers and why Etta’s family had Xtina sing it at her funeral.

Why bey here.

Oooh this one is hard!!! I did not expect Cynthia and Celine to eat this song up like this!! I feel like all of them did good. Xtina just oversings. Tie between Celine and Cynthia though for the best

Outsinging the other 3.

Xtina is the best here followed by Celine followed by Cynthia. Beyoncé sucks

Etta approved Xtina's version. Period.