正在加载视频...
视频加载失败
What the Night Sky on Mars may look like...
10 条评论

Fakety, fake, fake. Why? Because Mars' atmosphere—though thin, only about 1% as thick as earth's—is still thick enough to support (a lot of) dust hanging around in air; nor is there ever precipitation (rain), which on earth can thoroughly clear the air of lingering dust and haze. Beyond just locally blown-up dust, there are larger scale and even planetary-wide dust storms on Mars which can raise the aerial density of suspended dust to extreme levels, sometimes for months at a time. To quantify this phenomenon, there's the concept of “optical depth”—a measure of the amount of optical scattering occurring due to particulates in the air. Really clear skies on earth have an optical depth of about 0.1. On Mars, during a dust storm, the optical depth can exceed 5.0. But even after such dust storm(s) technically come to an end, the residual level of dust lingering in the martian air typically continues in the range of 0.5-1.0—corresponding to severe urban air pollution, drifting/falling volcanic ash, or considerable smoke from wildfires, on earth. Thus, during the day on Mars—in footage taken by, e.g., the Curiosity rover (in Gale Crater) or Perseverance rover (which recently departed Jezero Crater)—those (several km or miles distant) crater walls are nearly always, to a great extent, hazed almost out of visibility by ambient dust in between in the air. In other words, what the “seeing” has been like recently in the American Midwest and Northeast (at night) due to rampaging, distant Canadian wildfires, is about what the night sky would look like—during relatively _good_ viewing conditions—on Mars, most or all the time (that seeing is good—it can get worse, a lot worse). It's sad that so many purportedly science- and astronomy-oriented pages on X (and likely elsewhere) have fallen for this false presentation. ____ pics: Two views of normal (non dust storm) conditions on Mars: 1. Curiosity rover's view of the floor and crater wall of Gale Crater on Mars, from the slopes of Aeolis Mons (a.k.a. Mt. Sharp); notice Gale crater wall barely visible in the distance through the haze. 2. A recent Nasa posting providing a time-exposure photograph of the martian night sky—as taken by the Perseverance rover, showing the moon Deimos and (only) 2 stars—all that are visible under Mars' (non dust storm) normal dusty conditions.

Superimposed using galaxy data? Just like they do here. But you never actually see it like that with your eyes.

Why do you keep posting and reposting this?

This is fake

This is a composite. The sky on Mars is just like Earth. The lander's cameras were not meant for low light conditions. Here is the brightest thing in the Martian sky.

Fake

Is that real ?

Wow let's go

@grok @AskPerplexity are these views true because they look fake to me and also considering that stars aren't shown in any of the spacecraft visuals that have been released.

No
