Skip navigation
Which QB would you rather have?
0:00 / 2:21

Which QB would you rather have?

Barstool Sports

@barstoolsports6.9M followers

Visit on X
260 likesDownloadOriginal post

210,869 views

Which QB would you rather have?

35 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Hänsel's profile picture

    @UberHansen

    Steve Young vs Troy Aikman is not a debate, it's Young and it isnt remotely close. Aaron Rodgers vs Matthew Stafford is the same. Rodgers has an argument for the QB Mount Rushmore, Stafford does not.

    77 likes

  • sul's profile picture

    @Navillusdp

    Can’t believe I watched this. Fucking clowns.

    76 likes

  • Sal Vitro's profile picture

    @SalvatoreVitr0

    Stafford over Rodgers is completely ridiculous lmao

    46 likes

  • Joe D.'s profile picture

    @joedSilence

    Brees was legit better every year that Stafford and Brees played in the league which was like 12 years lol

    34 likes

  • Chris's profile picture

    @twAtter0069

    They were doing decent until they starting slurping Staffords hog. Montana > Stafford every day of the week. From there, it’s Montana vs Rodgers, edge goes to Montana (Rodgers is more talented though just doesnt have the clutch gene). Then Montana> Favre, Montana > Brees

    10 likes

  • Toe-Knee's profile picture

    @toeknee1114

    stafford over rodgers? this has to be a joke

    9 likes

  • Ryan Stagg's profile picture

    @staggles14

    The disrespect that Mahomes gets is wild these days. Already has a better resume than Stafford in half the time in the league. I would pick Pat over Montana but I understand not doing that. But then to turn around and pick Stafford over Montana is ridiculous

    8 likes

  • Woody's Wagers's profile picture

    @WoodysWagers

    Joe Montana all day, not even a debate!

    7 likes

  • Huey Delino's profile picture

    @HueyDial

    Whats the point of asking kids who never even watched these players play? Rage bait?

    5 likes

  • Shawn's profile picture

    @Shawn7dgh

    Stafford over Montana 😂 .. @stoolpresidente this is a grounds for termination

    4 likes

  • Apparent Pseudonym's profile picture

    @luckydogtwit88

    Aikman was much better and it’s not close

    3 likes

  • DudeBroski5000's profile picture

    @OCDudeBroski

    Taking Stafford over Montana and Rodgers is so stupid that I don’t even know what to say to refute it

    3 likes

  • 🅿️ip Davis III's profile picture

    @PipDavis69420

    Anybody that thinks Aikman over Young don’t know ball

    3 likes

  • Dan Porter's profile picture

    @tshirtlover23

    Lol. How you don't pick Drew breeze is absolutely hilarious.

    2 likes

  • Henry (Dude/Bro)'s profile picture

    @CoonassHenry

    These retards must not know who Drew Brees is

    2 likes

  • Rayray's profile picture

    @BritlandRay

    These dudes are too young they only know fuckn highlights

    2 likes

  • Greg Berge's profile picture

    @GregBerge

    Missing Tom Brady and Peyton Manning in this discussion.

    2 likes

  • Krame Diesel's profile picture

    @JR_Krames

    This is joke. Stafford is a clown

    2 likes

  • David McCall's profile picture

    @LemmeintheHouse

    These guys are dumbasses and should be banned from sports takes.

    2 likes

  • donvitosballcheese's profile picture

    @donvitosballchz

    These guys are goofs. Take Montana over mahomes no question then take stafford over Montana no question??

    2 likes