Skip navigation
Who made the cake? 🍰👀
0:00 / 0:58

Who made the cake? 🍰👀

Justin Brierley

@JusBrierley33K followers

Visit on X
228 likesDownloadOriginal post

25,484 views

Who made the cake? 🍰👀

21 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Untried Amok (@untriedamok@bsky.social)'s profile picture

    @KindKerfuffler

    Imagine interviewing very smart people from all sides of the spectrum on all of the nuances for years on your podcast, and still end up doing this kind of sloppy deceptive reasoning. I hope your book is better.

    6 likes

  • Prophet Rob's profile picture

    @thesaviorweneed

    I guess assuming the universe is a thing that was intentionally created gets just gets you to the conclusion you're looking for as fast as possible, without any of that pesky thinking about what if it isn't the sort of thing that was intentionally created.

    5 likes

  • Matthew Taylor (Still Unbelievable! podcast)'s profile picture

    @vteclimey

    I'm always puzzled by why this analogy is considered persuasive. How does pointing to things that we know (and can see) people create have any baring on the hypothesised idea of a creator god? A god who's alleged creation acts can not be witnessed.

    4 likes

  • Brandon Byrd's profile picture

    @Sui_Sibi_Se_Se

    This is silly and false. Science answers "why" questions all the time. That's what empirical causal inquiry is all about. And it's not as though scientists couldn't ask the maker of the cake why they made it. Psychological researchers ask people why they do things all the time.

    1 like

  • #Freethinker's profile picture

    @vaktothemax

    ... you are assuming a "person" made it and proceeded to attribute human features to that "person". I can therefore say that your God js a creation of your own little mind!!!!

    1 like

  • Nobby Clarke's profile picture

    @NobbyClarke82

    “Why” you’re here assumes a maker in the first place. That’s an assumption. A “leap of faith”, some may say.

    1 like

  • 🌿 PanDeism: An Anthology 🌌's profile picture

    @Pandeism

    Pandeism fully accounts not only for the cake, but for the person who baked the cake, and the myriad religions of cake bakers of all the cultures of the world. The question is simply whether those committed to any such culture can give Pandeism fair consideration.

  • meowsaky's profile picture

    @ooSMDBoo

    if u wanna know why the maker is how he is or why he does what he does. just shut the fuck up

  • Nozer's profile picture

    @JohnThePapist

    Well, 'what' makes you think there is a 'why' for the world?

  • The Shaken Fist / @theshakenfist.bsky.social's profile picture

    @AShakenFist

    Of course it can. Biology and pschology can tell you about how the body needs food and why you find it tasty and a treat. It can tell you why you wife decided to do it if she had a neral net on we could watch which parts lit up and we can then tell why.

  • Therese Ortl ✝️'s profile picture

    @PilgrimBlues79

    The Truth! Amen!

  • TheBossTweets's profile picture

    @TheBossTweets

    Cake has a maker therefore everything has a maker. Sounds like a very convincing argument for a maker

  • Daniel Pugh's profile picture

    @DnlPgh60

    Yes! Theism explains absolutely nothing!

  • Matt's profile picture

    @MattEngine

    Ewwwww 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

  • Alice Potter's profile picture

    @Welshwonderland

    Thank you Justin. wonderful!!

  • Tiberius Pantera's profile picture

    @offender_repeat

    Publicising your own stupidity....

  • Omar Nizam's profile picture

    @OmarNizam

    Hello Justin, This is Omar Nizam from @BookCafePodcast . I interview authors about their published books and would like to have you on the show to talk about your book. Could you please follow me back so that I can DM you? Thank you.

  • Zeynep's profile picture

    @eskrimencair

    Make sense

  • Spaceinvader65's profile picture

    @Spaceinvader65

    Thinking Faith…. Faith means, strong belief in the doctrines of a religion, based on spiritual conviction rather than proof. Therefore the cake maker can be anyone you like.

  • Anatoly Dyatlov's profile picture

    @Dyatlov0912

    Why is the maker here? Who made the maker?