Whose career would you rather have? Aaron Rodgers or Eli Manning?

Eli also beat Rodgers’ 15-1 Packers in one of those Super Bowl runs

Eli’s not even a question

One of the few times I actually agree with Colin cowherd 😂😂

I mean if I was a QB I may have to choose Rodgers but as a fan of the Giants, I’d much rather have Eli with 2 rings instead of Rodgers with big stats but only one Super Bowl

Stopped caring about these arguments a long time ago. My QB gave me 2 incredibly memorable championship runs and 15 years of stability at the most important position in sports along with class, character & dignity. People can think whatever they want, nobody I’d rather have

Eli can also walk down the street without a large % of people wanting to punch him in the head, unlike Rogers.

Argument to be made that Eli is the most clutch QB of all time. 2 ridiculous 80 yard+ drives in the closing minutes of 2 SBs to beat the goat twice while preventing a perfect season.

Gimme 10s career. Don’t agree with Cowherd much often, but he’s right that 2 SBs is rarified air. Gimme 2 over Bill and Tom over Rodgers’ 4 MVPs and epic NFC Chip losses

Eli, go back and watch some of his career highlights. Underrated. Pics,yes. But some really great throws. Fbhof

To the victor goes the spoils. Rodgers was more talented & a better player but 20 years from now Eli will have had the better career. His burgeoning media career & family name will also only add to his ubiquity.