Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Why Stoicism fails when treated like self-help | Massimo Pigliucci

bigthink's profile picture

Big Think

194,861 subscribers

14,197 views • 6 months ago •via X (Twitter)

LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Comments

No comments available

Comments from the original post will appear here

Related Videos

5 Stoic lessons to become your best self in 2026 | Massimo Pigliucci
47:10

5 Stoic lessons to become your best self in 2026 | Massimo Pigliucci

Big Think

17,447 views • 6 months ago

Has metaphysics become redundant? Philosopher of science Massimo Pigliucci proposes that in an age of flourishing science, metaphysics is no longer a necessary area of study. Tap here to watch his full interview on stoicism, pseudoscience, and metaphysics.
1:02

Has metaphysics become redundant? Philosopher of science Massimo Pigliucci proposes that in an age of flourishing science, metaphysics is no longer a necessary area of study. Tap here to watch his full interview on stoicism, pseudoscience, and metaphysics.

Institute of Art and Ideas

24,961 views • 2 months ago

Why Karmelo Anthony's Self-Defense Claim Fails Where ChudTheBuilder's Succeeds
3:24

Why Karmelo Anthony's Self-Defense Claim Fails Where ChudTheBuilder's Succeeds

Andrew Branca Show

33,406 views • 2 months ago

Stoicism for people who don’t want self-help | Massimo Pigliucci: Full Interview 0:00 Chapter 1: What is Stoicism? 2:11 Role ethics 4:29 Eudaemonia 4:59 What constitutes a Eudaemonic life? 5:31 Being a Cosmopolitan 5:45 Epictetus’ 3 fundamental disciples 6:10 Desire 6:39 Action 7:05 Assent 8:00 3 general areas of study 8:22 Physics 9:43 Action 10:07 Logic 11:07 Does Stoicism work? 12:02 Cognitive behavioral therapy 16:03 The risk of Eclecticism 18:42 Philosophical pessimism 21:04 Modern Stoic writers 22:01 Chapter 2: The Stoic toolkit 22:22 Managing our emotions 28:45 Preparing for difficult situations 36:00 Finding peace in a chaotic world 45:08 Making difficult decisions 51:00 Becoming a better person 1:08:21 Chapter 3: Debunking misconceptions about Stoicism 1:10:21 Stoicism’s resurgence 1:13:52 Stoicism as a remedy for bad times 1:16:29 The “stiff upper lip” myth 1:21:05 Two ways to misconstrue Stoicism 1:26:16 Stoicism and pleasure 1:28:00 Preferred indifference 1:34:30 The Stoic Opposition
1:51:14

Stoicism for people who don’t want self-help | Massimo Pigliucci: Full Interview 0:00 Chapter 1: What is Stoicism? 2:11 Role ethics 4:29 Eudaemonia 4:59 What constitutes a Eudaemonic life? 5:31 Being a Cosmopolitan 5:45 Epictetus’ 3 fundamental disciples 6:10 Desire 6:39 Action 7:05 Assent 8:00 3 general areas of study 8:22 Physics 9:43 Action 10:07 Logic 11:07 Does Stoicism work? 12:02 Cognitive behavioral therapy 16:03 The risk of Eclecticism 18:42 Philosophical pessimism 21:04 Modern Stoic writers 22:01 Chapter 2: The Stoic toolkit 22:22 Managing our emotions 28:45 Preparing for difficult situations 36:00 Finding peace in a chaotic world 45:08 Making difficult decisions 51:00 Becoming a better person 1:08:21 Chapter 3: Debunking misconceptions about Stoicism 1:10:21 Stoicism’s resurgence 1:13:52 Stoicism as a remedy for bad times 1:16:29 The “stiff upper lip” myth 1:21:05 Two ways to misconstrue Stoicism 1:26:16 Stoicism and pleasure 1:28:00 Preferred indifference 1:34:30 The Stoic Opposition

Big Think

43,636 views • 6 months ago

Flight status update: Why are we treated like slaves and criminals when we fly? Why is it such a miserable experience?
2:26

Flight status update: Why are we treated like slaves and criminals when we fly? Why is it such a miserable experience?

Owen Shroyer

392,046 views • 3 months ago

Dhruv Rathee Students are being treated like suspects while the system fails to stop paper leaks 🇮🇳
0:39

Dhruv Rathee Students are being treated like suspects while the system fails to stop paper leaks 🇮🇳

Uzma Shah

20,133 views • 2 months ago

Why was Phyno treated like that? 💔😭
0:37

Why was Phyno treated like that? 💔😭

SCRUMMY

599,622 views • 7 months ago

Why do Christians get treated like this in Israel ?
0:33

Why do Christians get treated like this in Israel ?

Parody Jeff

144,951 views • 5 months ago

Stoicism is a Coping Mechanism | Great Books Interview Stoicism is often just a coping mechanism and we should be alarmed by the rise of stoicism today. In the late Roman republic, Stoicism was the coping mechanism of choice for the losing side of the civil war: defeated on the battlefield Cato’s defining act of stoic defiance was suicide. His ally Cicero turned to Stoic ideals for consolation. And as the republic gave way to empire, Stoicism rose from a fringe school to the dominant philosophy as citizens saw their freedoms curtailed. Is it not an issue that Stoicism seems tailor-made to those with the least amount of control of their lives (its greatest exemplars are a slave and an emperor)? And can these ideas actually be lived out in reality? My guest, leading Columbia classicist Katharina Volk, wrestles with these questions by examining Stoicism in the late Roman Republic. In this interview, we cover: - Stoicism’s implausible understanding of happiness - Why Stoicism appealed to the losing side in Rome - How modern self-help twisted ancient Stoic wisdom - What the rise of Stoicism and Buddhism reveal about our society TIMESTAMPS: 02:35 The Stoic secret to happiness 07:31 Why the Stoics saw politics as the highest calling 09:19 The odd life of Cato the Stoic 14:04 The bizarre reason Cato divorced then remarried his wife 15:09 From Cato to Aurelius: How Stoicism changed 21:24 Did Stoicism destroy the Roman Republic? 23:24 What is a “preferred-indifferent”? 28:52 Was Cato's Stoicism just political theater? 33:41 How the Stoics coped with defeat against Caesar 36:20 Consolation as a genre of philosophy 39:01 Is Stoicism a philosophy for losers? 44:01 Why Stoicism’s popularity today is a bad sign
48:56

Stoicism is a Coping Mechanism | Great Books Interview Stoicism is often just a coping mechanism and we should be alarmed by the rise of stoicism today. In the late Roman republic, Stoicism was the coping mechanism of choice for the losing side of the civil war: defeated on the battlefield Cato’s defining act of stoic defiance was suicide. His ally Cicero turned to Stoic ideals for consolation. And as the republic gave way to empire, Stoicism rose from a fringe school to the dominant philosophy as citizens saw their freedoms curtailed. Is it not an issue that Stoicism seems tailor-made to those with the least amount of control of their lives (its greatest exemplars are a slave and an emperor)? And can these ideas actually be lived out in reality? My guest, leading Columbia classicist Katharina Volk, wrestles with these questions by examining Stoicism in the late Roman Republic. In this interview, we cover: - Stoicism’s implausible understanding of happiness - Why Stoicism appealed to the losing side in Rome - How modern self-help twisted ancient Stoic wisdom - What the rise of Stoicism and Buddhism reveal about our society TIMESTAMPS: 02:35 The Stoic secret to happiness 07:31 Why the Stoics saw politics as the highest calling 09:19 The odd life of Cato the Stoic 14:04 The bizarre reason Cato divorced then remarried his wife 15:09 From Cato to Aurelius: How Stoicism changed 21:24 Did Stoicism destroy the Roman Republic? 23:24 What is a “preferred-indifferent”? 28:52 Was Cato's Stoicism just political theater? 33:41 How the Stoics coped with defeat against Caesar 36:20 Consolation as a genre of philosophy 39:01 Is Stoicism a philosophy for losers? 44:01 Why Stoicism’s popularity today is a bad sign

Johnathan Bi

41,228 views • 2 years ago

Why Buddhism should be treated like I$lam, Christianity &…
3:04

Why Buddhism should be treated like I$lam, Christianity &…

Pulkit Tyagi

10,945 views • 4 months ago

LOVE NEVER FAILS… ❤️🙏❤️🙏 Why don’t scenes like this go viral?
0:36

LOVE NEVER FAILS… ❤️🙏❤️🙏 Why don’t scenes like this go viral?

Texas 🇺🇸

11,592 views • 5 months ago

Why self love, when you can love others instead
0:22

Sensitive content

Why self love, when you can love others instead

Snowey

22,999 views • 1 year ago

This is proof that creatives have zero protection. When creative talents are treated like this in the open, it’s honestly scary. God help us in this country.
0:54

This is proof that creatives have zero protection. When creative talents are treated like this in the open, it’s honestly scary. God help us in this country.

Chichi

16,750 views • 7 months ago

max deserves the biggest apology. the way they all treated her like she was crazy when she was the only one who was trying to help him.
0:46

max deserves the biggest apology. the way they all treated her like she was crazy when she was the only one who was trying to help him.

lu ★

49,715 views • 1 year ago

COLDCARD + Cove makes self-custody extremely simple. Quick setup. Clear work flow. No guesswork. This walkthrough shows how it works. We're giving away a COLDCARD Q to help some upgrade their self-custody. To Enter: - Like - Repost - Comment why self-custody matters 👇
2:03

COLDCARD + Cove makes self-custody extremely simple. Quick setup. Clear work flow. No guesswork. This walkthrough shows how it works. We're giving away a COLDCARD Q to help some upgrade their self-custody. To Enter: - Like - Repost - Comment why self-custody matters 👇

COLDCARD

18,534 views • 4 months ago

I miss when animators treated the environment like a weapon
1:00

I miss when animators treated the environment like a weapon

Yuri 🌸 (百合)💫

1,478,343 views • 1 month ago

Massimo Those Fish are Hippo’s 🦛 cleanser Like when he said “To the Fish hippos 🦛 are mobile Cafeteria”
1:29

Massimo Those Fish are Hippo’s 🦛 cleanser Like when he said “To the Fish hippos 🦛 are mobile Cafeteria”

Hesh

744,339 views • 2 years ago

When our politicians travel, why don’t they ever feel like their own home state deserves to look like the places they visit abroad? Is it self hate?
2:20

When our politicians travel, why don’t they ever feel like their own home state deserves to look like the places they visit abroad? Is it self hate?

Osarogie Ogbonmwan

48,029 views • 9 months ago

Throwback to 2014 when Dhoni treated rayudu like a dog 😭
0:36

Throwback to 2014 when Dhoni treated rayudu like a dog 😭

M.

841,179 views • 1 year ago