Would you rather have Drake Maye or Caleb Williams?

I will simply not be convinced that this enormous chasm in efficiency is the product of "the schedule" especially when the Bears didn't exactly play a murder's row either

This doesn’t matter in any way to any of our lives but I think every bears fan on the planet would cum if Caleb just had the season Maye just had. Kinda seems like one’s hypothetical ceiling is what the other just did, no?

Patriots fans will say Drake May. Fans of the other 31 teams will say Caleb Williams.

caleb would get more votes if he got to play the jets and dolphins twice a year 💀😪

Coached by Jerod Mayo, Drake Maye beat Caleb Williams head to head in 2024

Personally I’d just go with the guy who is a lot better? Sorry if that’s just me

Just so fucking dumb to say his ceiling is higher like deadass gotta be rage bait

Caleb’s def not bad but yall can have him. A few good games wouldn’t have me overlook a 58% completion pct, right in between Cam Ward & JJ McCarthy. I’ll take Drake.

If we banned the word ceiling from sports discussions it would immediately make sports discussions 5* less dumb.

Caleb has to be one of the most overrated players I’ve ever seen

Drake is the only player left from the Patriots draft that year. It’s Drake Maye

Caleb’s regression is going to be immaculate.

This is not a serious question lol

Drake by every qb’ing measure blows Caleb away. 2 years younger and complete 20% more passes with a passer rating 25 points higher. But sure Caleb can run around and give you a 50% chance of a 38 yard completion or throwing an incompletion into the ground to a receiver 8 yds away

Who is this idiot?

@Da_Bear_Claw18 Caleb

This isn’t even a close debate. Drake maye should have 100% of the vote. He has Caleb beat in everything. Arm Talent, mental, leadership list goes on

I'm tired of this "talent" cop out talent- a natural, inborn ability or aptitude to do something well without needing a lot of instruction who has shown more talent? one person lead the league in completion %, the other guy was bottom 5.

PR queen at it again

Caleb 💯

Caleb

Dumbest take anyone’s ever had. If you wanted to try the Caleb gimmick during the draft it’s one thing but after 2 seasons of the NFL it’s not even close. One guy should’ve been the MVP and the other tosses meatball subs to the defense every 3rd play.

Caleb 🐐

Accuracy matters. Caleb isn't accurate and that is hard to fix. Maye's sack rate is a product of a bad line and receivers who did not get separation easily. It is more likely Maye improves his "deficiency" than Caleb throws more accurately.

Caleb’s ceiling is higher what an insane take.

both teams got their guys

lamar jacksons “ceiling” is higher than mahomes it doesnt matter when there are no obvious limitations to Drakes ceiling

@KevinOConnor Caleb Williams

@KevinOConnor Bozo.

I just realized why they're delusional. Let them be mad about making the wrong draft choice.

Yeah I’d rather listen to paint dry than Mike sandwich

Drake alll day ,Caleb has stinker all game and makes 1 great play Drake is consistent