Frank Rossi's banner
Frank Rossi's profile picture

Frank Rossi

@FrankRossi6,960 subscribers

Attorney in NYS. Adj. Law Prof. at UMiami. @D3FBHuddle Co-Host. Flag f'ball ref. Mayor of the Village of Ballston Spa, NY since 4/2022.

Shorts

In perhaps the worst #d3fb referee call since the Alma/Hope debacle, this is ruled as Plymouth State FB’s RB (in green) being down and retaining possession. I honestly have no words. PSU is tied with AMCAT Football, 7-7 early in the 2nd quarter. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb RedditCFB

In perhaps the worst #d3fb referee call since the Alma/Hope debacle, this is ruled as Plymouth State FB’s RB (in green) being down and retaining possession. I honestly have no words. PSU is tied with AMCAT Football, 7-7 early in the 2nd quarter. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb RedditCFB

82,348 просмотров

We will have a new National Champion this season. Zac Boyes comes up short of the Springfield Football 1 on 4th Down, and Drew Heenan kneels down in victory formation to send Springfield to the Quarterfinals, 40-28 over SUNY Cortland Football. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

We will have a new National Champion this season. Zac Boyes comes up short of the Springfield Football 1 on 4th Down, and Drew Heenan kneels down in victory formation to send Springfield to the Quarterfinals, 40-28 over SUNY Cortland Football. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

69,055 просмотров

EJ Talarico gets the TD pass from James Rinello and the 2pt conversion is good. Johns Hopkins Football trails Mount Union Football 45-37 (3;26 4th). In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

EJ Talarico gets the TD pass from James Rinello and the 2pt conversion is good. Johns Hopkins Football trails Mount Union Football 45-37 (3;26 4th). In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

26,346 просмотров

Meanwhile, controversy at 𝗥𝗔𝗡𝗗𝗢𝗟𝗣𝗛-𝗠𝗔𝗖𝗢𝗡 𝗙𝗢𝗢𝗧𝗕𝗔𝗟𝗟 (Video from the RMC Digital Sports Network) — in OT, Hobart Football appears to convert a 4th & 1, but the QB fumbles according to RMC. Spots all initially show the QB achieved more than the 15. After deciding there was no fumble, the officials decided also that the spot was short. RMC wins in OT, 14-7. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

Meanwhile, controversy at 𝗥𝗔𝗡𝗗𝗢𝗟𝗣𝗛-𝗠𝗔𝗖𝗢𝗡 𝗙𝗢𝗢𝗧𝗕𝗔𝗟𝗟 (Video from the RMC Digital Sports Network) — in OT, Hobart Football appears to convert a 4th & 1, but the QB fumbles according to RMC. Spots all initially show the QB achieved more than the 15. After deciding there was no fumble, the officials decided also that the spot was short. RMC wins in OT, 14-7. In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

14,834 просмотров

Videos

FrankRossi's profile picture

A number of you have asked about the call at the end of the 1st Half of the Bethel Football game at NCC Football in which there was a potential fumble/TD wiped off the board for Bethel that eventually led to no score by the Royals. The full play and a breakdown of issues with the call are in the video below. To be clear, though: 1) It appears that the receiver did not possess the ball at or past the NCC 8, which was needed for the 1st Down (the officials gave the ball to Bethel at the 8 after the overturn, awarding a 1st down). 2) It seems like the wing official was marking forward progress but may not have blown his whistle. It is unclear how he affected the overturn decision in the first place. What is clear is that the officials on the field awarded a fumble and TD, meaning they did not rule forward progress had been stopped. As a result, this aspect of the play is NOT reviewable by rule, as it is a judgment call in real time. 3) No TD should have been awarded before the review in the first place, as the ball clearly was fumbled to the lineman, and fumbles on 4th down in college football can only be advanced by the fumbling player. The ball would have been marked at the spot of the fumble in that case. 4) The officials missed a clear Roughing the Passer call, as the NCC defender went for the Bethel QB's legs while he was in his passing stance. This would have been a half-the-distance and automatic-first-down foul. If this play was called correctly in the first place, it should have been called dead with forward progress stopped at the 8 1/2 yard line and the Roughing foul pushing the ball to the 4 1/4 yard line, 1st & Goal Bethel, with the clock stopped due to penalty. No matter what, though, the Roughing penalty would have ensured Bethel had the ball closer to the goal with 16 seconds left (when forward progress stoppage should have been called). In The (D3FB) Huddle #d3fb

Frank Rossi

28,420 просмотров • 5 месяцев назад

FrankRossi's profile picture

The targeting foul against Zack Orr of NCC Football has been overturned, and he will be eligible to start in Saturday's #d3fb National Semifinal vs. Susquehanna Football at 3:30pm EST / 2:30pm CST. I spoke with Steve Shaw, the NCAA's National Coordinator of Officials, about the overturn this morning. Note that the provision in question is whether or not Springfield Football QB Drew Heenan qualified under the rules as a "defenseless player," as the following is one such definition in the NCAA Football Rulebook: "A ball carrier already in the grasp of an opponent and whose forward progress has been stopped." If a defenseless player is hit in the neck or head region by an opponent, then targeting is a proper call under the rules. Steve said: “We’re very clear that he's not defenseless until he is down. And if you go back and look at the video on the play…he's wrapped up and he's going down. And the contact is with [the] runner just as he's going to the ground. So he really has not transitioned to a defenseless player yet. You know, you can make the argument that, well, if he's wrapped up, he's defenseless and he can't really defend himself. But from a replay perspective, we needed a bright line that that was not a judgment, but a bright line. And that is, [he] has to be down, considered down before he's defenseless….He's just beginning to go down and be down. And so we wouldn't consider him down at the time that he's hit. And there's no crown of the helmet involved. The helmet is clearly to the side. And so, from a replay perspective, rules are very clear. You've got to be able to confirm all aspects of targeting for it to be targeting. You couldn't confirm that he was down and then hit. So we didn't give him defenseless status....And that's why the targeting was overturned.” Steve also taught me about something that is important. While regular replay reviews can come out as "confirmed," "overturned," or "stands" (which means that there is not conclusive evidence to overturn, but there isn't a full confirmation of the original call either), targeting calls do not have a "stands" option when they are reviewed. In other words, they are viewed anew and either every element necessary for targeting must be confirmed, or it is overturned. Think of it as being innocent until proven guilty in the review process for targeting. In this case, he was clear to underscore that the elements could have been argued to have existed, but it would have, at best, been a "call stands" decision, which is not sufficient to uphold a targeting call. Steve also expressed the hopes that the instant replay model that has been developed and used in Division 2 will become more utilized in Division 3, related to more-universal instant replay using a coaches' challenge approach (except for targeting), much like we saw in the Centennial Conference this year. He understands the challenges, but he also feels that having two HD camera angles plus the normal web stream (basically at least three cameras) is sufficient to embrace the needs of instant replay. He is not in favor of a D1 type of replay at the lower levels because of the desire to not have constant game interruptions and more technological challenges at the lower levels than we see at D1 -- he stressed his support of a coaches' challenge system in our conversation multiple times. In The (D3FB) Huddle and I give thanks to Steve for his transparency, which is always on display in the CFO training videos he releases on YouTube. I always learn something when I watch his videos, and today was no different in our conversation.

Frank Rossi

29,464 просмотров • 1 год назад