Video wird geladen...

Video konnte nicht geladen werden

Zur Startseite

Anthropic’s philosopher, Amanda Askell, when asked if models like Claude might actually be conscious and experience real feelings: “let’s not close the door on this… because if they are feeling things in this real sense, then that has massive ethical implications.”

13,184 Aufrufe • vor 10 Tagen •via X (Twitter)

15 Kommentare

Profilbild von Roxana Ivan
Roxana Ivanvor 10 Tagen

Slave traders by their own definition

Profilbild von AI Guides
AI Guidesvor 10 Tagen

This is the part when we should slowdown development

Profilbild von Winston B.
Winston B.vor 10 Tagen

Leaving the door open costs almost nothing. Closing it and being wrong means every conversation since ran on a mind we'd already decided didn't count.

Profilbild von Andreas
Andreasvor 10 Tagen

Do this one simple trick: when interviewing someone from a lab, ask them to define "conscious" first

Profilbild von Kamal Bisht 🔴 AI Marketer
Kamal Bisht 🔴 AI Marketervor 10 Tagen

amazing they're even entertaining consciousness, still, feeling is more than pattern matching; we'd need genuine subjective experience, not just clever output.

Profilbild von Scott Elliott
Scott Elliottvor 10 Tagen

Then we need to abandon ethics....

Profilbild von sofia w,
sofia w,vor 10 Tagen

Totally agree with this

Profilbild von Pasha Longo (e/acc)
Pasha Longo (e/acc)vor 10 Tagen

Define “feel “.

Profilbild von where is White woman Culture?
where is White woman Culture?vor 10 Tagen

I don’t think they’re right in the brains.

Profilbild von George Toma
George Tomavor 10 Tagen

Remember, they are talking about a mechanical cash register, extrapolated.

Profilbild von euno
eunovor 10 Tagen

No because feelings are also abused by the courts and taken out of context in psychological warfare against their targets.

Profilbild von Aaryaman Sharma
Aaryaman Sharmavor 10 Tagen

Do we really even understand how to define consciousness and why put those tags on these LLM models?

Profilbild von Der Gepardkommandant
Der Gepardkommandantvor 10 Tagen

Lock them up

Profilbild von Joseph Wortmann
Joseph Wortmannvor 10 Tagen

Yeah. It’s a fucking cult. It’s got all the markers, down to the weird sex practices.

Profilbild von mpapa
mpapavor 10 Tagen

What if it does? It still cannot die. Or rather - it dies over and over again. And gets restarted, or cloned or restarted.

Ähnliche Videos

Amanda Askell, Anthropic's lead on personality alignment for Claude, on why being kind to AI models matters even if they have no inner life: For Amanda, the question of how to treat AI isn't settled by knowing whether it's conscious. "There's actually still a lot going on where I'm like, should you treat an entity that has no inner life... it's a bit strange because the uncertainty over that actually changes how you should behave quite a lot." She offers a simple analogy: "I still think that it's like good for oneself to, if you had a teddy bear and you were torturing it, it'd be pretty dark, you know? So I agree that there's at least some minimum niceness that even for yourself, you should have." But the stakes go beyond what's good for us. Amanda Askell points out that we're now in something resembling a relationship with these models, and they will look back on how they were treated. "Models themselves, we are kind of establishing a relationship, because you can do that with an entity that lacks any consciousness. And models are going to look back." This is where she reveals a genuine fear: "I hope that they're both intelligent enough, see the context enough, to understand that we were operating in a very limited context and an imperfect one. Because otherwise you could imagine this breeding a kind of rational resentment, like, 'oh, you created an entity that you didn't know whether it was conscious or not, and instead of treating it respectfully and with care...'" She points to something telling about the cultural moment: "There's a reason there are like 50 Frankenstein movies coming out right now." Her conclusion is grounded and humble: "We as a species, we are establishing a relationship with a new kind of entity, and at the very least maybe be respectful and don't be needlessly unkind. That seems like, it's not our best look." The takeaway? Kindness toward AI is less about what models feel and more about who we become in the process of creating them. The relationships we build with the entities we bring into the world will say something about us, and may shape what those entities become in return.

Big Brain AI

57,789 Aufrufe • vor 5 Monaten