正在加载视频...
视频加载失败
Can’t share this enough! This is precisely why laws need to be interpreted by the courts and not politicians looking to weaponize the notwithstanding clause! If only there was a lawyer on the premiers senior staff… #abpoli #ableg #cdnpoli
38 条评论

No…the Notwithstanding Clause was specifically put in the charter to check the judiciary who are UNELECTED and do not represent the will of the electorate. DEAL WITH IT.

leftists are normalizing p3d0phillia again, using a random scenario of an 18 and 17yr old to justify this horrible policy is insane. these people are disgusting fr34ks.

Based on her haircut, I’m not up for listening to another LBGTQ2S+ activist today. Lets just lock up pedophiles

Makes up hypothetical. Uses hypothetical to strike down minimum sentence. Allows that to apply to real case while claiming to deplore the actual case. How about assessing the actual case and telling us whether the minimum was appropriate or not. Here's a clue: it was.

This is why we need s33 because judges will not stop broadening an argument to utter absurdity while congratulating themselves for their wisdom. Their use of hypotheticals and scenarios will soon have violent home invasions treated the same as stealing apples. At this rate courts will soon be unnecessary.

Lougheed has been quoted as stating that it should only be invoked after the SCC has declared a law unconstitutional, and the legislating government must then justify its use to the electorate.

(And with a supermajority in the body)

It's not about judges over-riding the will of the majority, it's about judges protecting the rights of the minority from the tyranny of the majority. And given that only a small percentage of the Alberta population actually voted for the UCP, it is not even close to a majority.

@Jason___YYC Yep everything they don't like will be NWC.. 🤦🤦🤦🤦

The reason for invoking s. 33 of the Charter is that the legal advice likely indicated that the Act would not withstand judicial scrutiny. That is, it would be found in violation of the Charter and declared a nullity.

Niccolaides admitted that they had other options, but given that they didn’t provide guaranteed permanant resolution they opted with the version that used s. 33

The primary function of the Minister of Justice/Attorney General is to advise Executive Council on legal matters. There are hundreds of lawyers employed by the Ministry of Justice.

(We were making a crack about Bobby)

Courts are appointed, government are elected. Do you feel the difference?

Thinking this is why the NDP will never form government in this province again. 🙄

"This is precisely why laws need to be interpreted by the courts" Hell no. Judges are appointed by politicians. Remember the Supreme Court saying women were not persons case 1929.

The one that was then overturned by... The courts?

Exactly! But the politicians that are raged farming are the ones that are there just to rage farm, so there’s nothing we can do about them, except get that petition signed about politicians and outright lying and get it before the government.

kyla lee is awesome!

This distinction can’t be made? You are all nuts.

Underage is underage.. whether you're 18 looking at a 17 yr old or not

She is very good.

Correct me if I'm wrong here but the check is being found guilty of processing such materials for said use, and the balance is after said judgement the law prevails. So this example would only be subject to the law after being found guilty?

How dare this woman make a logical and thoughtful statement! Our Queen Danielle would never accept this! She would never associate with anybody that has been accused of child predator crimes….oh wait….crap.

Mandatory minimum sentences are a BAD way to structure justice.

That was not the stance on appeal. The NWC was precisely included to limit the power of the judiciary in cases where interpretations of the law are not aligned with interests of Canadians. Canadians want tougher laws on child porn. Two teens exchanging pics is not the norm!

What she fails to acknowledge is that no Crown attorney would ever bring charges where the two were in a consensual relationship. And even more impossibly, no judge/jury would find guilt. So sentencing minimums are moot.

Thank you for sharing this.

Well said!

.@IRPlawyer is such a treasure!

The “Notwithstanding clause” protects government from overreach. It’s constitutional & necessity or you would have unions, governments & groups determine to take a government down. That’s fact. Also, the government could & should make Education a essential service.

Unfortunately most people don't have the capacity for this amount of logic.

Let's differentiate it! Teenagers having fun = a small but serious punishment Prepubescent = public execution by stoning

Anyone could come up with a million hypothetical scenarios to justify their views. Where do you draw the line?

I wish we could roll back the clock on some technology. Or download wisdom into each generation born so the brain can catch up quick to the technology in parallel with wisdom.

So undemocratic.

They arnt gojng after their typed of ppl and those are such a low .majority lol

Thank you for sharing this.
