Skip navigation
Did relativity kill time?
0:00 / 1:14

Did relativity kill time?

Institute of Art and Ideas

@IAI_TV31K followers

Visit on X
52 likesDownloadOriginal post

20,450 views

Did relativity kill time? In this debate, physicist Avshalom Elitzur rejects Einstein’s theory of the block universe, labelling it as “stupid”. Tap here to watch him go head-to-head with fellow scientists Ivette Fuentes and Jonathan Oppenheim in “Spacetime and the framework of the world”.

6 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • TheRealVerbz (Jason Verbelli)'s profile picture

    @TheRealVerbz

    Time is not relative. Relativity killed the entire scientific community with the concept of the fourth dimension and the invention of space-time. It was one of the worst ideas to ever infect the scientific community the history of all humanity. Lighter Flick From Mars Scenario: Mind Melting Thought Experiment About Absolute Time:

    7 likes

  • Summer in the Dark Ages's profile picture

    @DarkSummer777

    I was just thinking about this; when people say that the universe is 13.8 billion earth years old, does an "earth year" mean something completely different 13 billion earth years ago in the Universe as it does today?

    6 likes

  • Tobie Venne's profile picture

    @Tobie_Venne

    Time is a relative, subjective, species specific experience, crafted through a process and rendered by biophysics into our consciousness / Umvelt

    6 likes

  • FJ Cuesta G's profile picture

    @CuestaGFJ

    Time does not exist by default in the Universe and, therefore, in the Quantum realm. Time is emergent, which is why its arrow always moves in the same direction ie it's not possible to come back. This is perfectly compatible with Special and General Relativity.

    2 likes

  • Dr Garry Dulgar's profile picture

    @GDulgar72468

    There is a cohesiveness throughout the Universe that is categorized by “time” that Einstein showed as “relative” depending on variables that are not constant. Ultimately we are in a state of constant flux caused by a force that is beyond our grasp & not revealed until our passing

  • John Robert Lamarr Greer's profile picture

    @HCPhysicsHokage

    Time Dilation (The compression of the medium(space) radiating away from the oscillating mass source) Because heat cannot travel in the vacuum of space, a different from of energy can traverse the span. The medium moves instead(Gravity) and is radiated away(Time dilation) with the information of the heat from known as Time. All phenomena are different forms of heat. This is why you cannot destroy energy. Only convert it. Because all energy is heat in different forms and regimes. Everything else appears to emerge from these relationships. The expansion of space is not newly created space. It is the same sheet stretched thinner and further. Heat is radiated out thinner and further. Without action there is no information. Without time there is no space. Without a canvas an artist cannot paint. Without pigment he cannot paint. Each alone is nothing. Canvas with no paint is not a portrait. Pigment with no canvas has nowhere to sit. Medium and mark are both required. Reality is the portrait, not the unused canvas and not the unused pigment. Gradient starts the canvas. Action is the brush. Time is the paint that stayed in the stroke. Gravity is the canvas pulled toward the artist’s effort. That is the same dependency circuit, carried in many styles. One method. There is no past. There is no future. There is only the here and now, and a record of what has been. The record is space.