Video yükleniyor...

Video Yüklenemedi

Bu video yüklenirken bir sorun oluştu. Bu geçici bir ağ sorunundan kaynaklanıyor olabilir veya video kullanılamıyor olabilir.

Ana Sayfaya Dön

"Does reservation harm merit?" 🤡🤣 Educator Aditya Ranjan says how SC-ST and OBCs faced historical discrimination, so they need reservation for opportunities. Dwij Hindus enjoy EWS benefits but oppose Bahujan reservation just to sound cool.

Suraj Kumar Bauddh

357,719 subscribers

19,560 görüntüleme • 5 ay önce •via X (Twitter)

Eğitim Haberler & Politika

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Yorum

Yorum bulunmuyor

Orijinal gönderinin yorumları burada görünecek

Benzer Videolar

🚨Our Constitution Makers Ensured that Reservation should only be on basis of Caste, in other words only for Hindus ! 🚨But !! Today Mu$lim are getting … - EWS Reservation ! - OBC Reservation ! - ST Reservation ! And soon they will get SC Reservation also! And with this they are getting Minorities benefits too !! 🚨Our Fraud Politicians kept us Divided in General/OBC/SC/ST and Secretly handed over Entire Reservation to Muslims ! 🚨And now Congress has started giving them Reservation in Government Contracts also ! 🚨They are slowly slowly Making India a Mu$lim Country ???

🚨Our Constitution Makers Ensured that Reservation should only be on basis of Caste, in other words only for Hindus ! 🚨But !! Today Mu$lim are getting … - EWS Reservation ! - OBC Reservation ! - ST Reservation ! And soon they will get SC Reservation also! And with this they are getting Minorities benefits too !! 🚨Our Fraud Politicians kept us Divided in General/OBC/SC/ST and Secretly handed over Entire Reservation to Muslims ! 🚨And now Congress has started giving them Reservation in Government Contracts also ! 🚨They are slowly slowly Making India a Mu$lim Country ???

Mona Patel 🇮🇳🐅🌳

27,954 görüntüleme • 7 ay önce

🚨Our Constitution Makers Ensured that Reservation should only be on basis of Caste, in other words only for Hindus ! 🚨But !! Today Mu$lim are getting … - EWS Reservation ! - OBC Reservation ! - ST Reservation ! And soon they will get SC Reservation also! And with this they are getting Minorities benefits too !! 🚨Our Fraud Politicians kept us Divided in General/OBC/SC/ST and Secretly handed over Entire Reservation to Muslims ! 🚨And now Congress has started giving them Reservation in Government Contracts also ! 🚨They are slowly slowly Making India a Mu$lim Country ???

🚨Our Constitution Makers Ensured that Reservation should only be on basis of Caste, in other words only for Hindus ! 🚨But !! Today Mu$lim are getting … - EWS Reservation ! - OBC Reservation ! - ST Reservation ! And soon they will get SC Reservation also! And with this they are getting Minorities benefits too !! 🚨Our Fraud Politicians kept us Divided in General/OBC/SC/ST and Secretly handed over Entire Reservation to Muslims ! 🚨And now Congress has started giving them Reservation in Government Contracts also ! 🚨They are slowly slowly Making India a Mu$lim Country ???

Mona Patel 🇮🇳🐅🌳

50,394 görüntüleme • 9 ay önce

🚨 Wow reservation issue has now reached even schools. A class teacher made two rows of students. One for General and one for SC/ST. Both students had to talk about reservation. The SC girl talked about General getting the benefits of EWS but the General girl instantly replied why every SC/ST person gets reservation. There's no rich and poor among them which is unfair. Only the poor ones should get reservation. No one from the SC/ST row had a reply to this. Girl alone ended the whole debate 🙏

🚨 Wow reservation issue has now reached even schools. A class teacher made two rows of students. One for General and one for SC/ST. Both students had to talk about reservation. The SC girl talked about General getting the benefits of EWS but the General girl instantly replied why every SC/ST person gets reservation. There's no rich and poor among them which is unfair. Only the poor ones should get reservation. No one from the SC/ST row had a reply to this. Girl alone ended the whole debate 🙏

`

352,815 görüntüleme • 8 gün önce

RAJKUMAR BHATI TEARS APART THE FAKE MERIT ARGUMENT 🔥 Reservation gets attacked daily, but EWS, women’s reservation and management quota get a free pass. ₹1 crore donation seat gets no outrage. OBC/SC/ST student through reservation enters, and suddenly everyone becomes merit ka chowkidar. Bhati’s point is simple: reservation gives entry, not a free degree. The exam is still the same. One child studies in AC rooms. Another feeds cattle, works in fields, carries bricks, then reaches the same exam hall. That is not “less merit.” That is merit plus struggle. CHINA REPLY ⚡️: China did not cut Eklavya’s thumb, create untouchability, force people to carry brooms, or stop grooms from riding horses. India does not lack merit. India denied opportunity for centuries and then called it a merit debate.

RAJKUMAR BHATI TEARS APART THE FAKE MERIT ARGUMENT 🔥 Reservation gets attacked daily, but EWS, women’s reservation and management quota get a free pass. ₹1 crore donation seat gets no outrage. OBC/SC/ST student through reservation enters, and suddenly everyone becomes merit ka chowkidar. Bhati’s point is simple: reservation gives entry, not a free degree. The exam is still the same. One child studies in AC rooms. Another feeds cattle, works in fields, carries bricks, then reaches the same exam hall. That is not “less merit.” That is merit plus struggle. CHINA REPLY ⚡️: China did not cut Eklavya’s thumb, create untouchability, force people to carry brooms, or stop grooms from riding horses. India does not lack merit. India denied opportunity for centuries and then called it a merit debate.

Mr Sharma

57,416 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce

🚨 BIG NEWS! Centre firmly opposes plea in Supreme Court for Income-Based Sub-Quota within SC/ST/OBCs!🤯 > Govt makes it clear: Reservation is based on "historical & social backwardness", not just economic status. Petitioner wanted income-based preferences inside SC, ST, OBC and EWS categories for “more equitable” policy🎯 Centre’s blunt stand: The “creamy layer” concept was developed only for OBC reservations & does not apply to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Strong rejection of pure economic criteria.

🚨 BIG NEWS! Centre firmly opposes plea in Supreme Court for Income-Based Sub-Quota within SC/ST/OBCs!🤯 > Govt makes it clear: Reservation is based on "historical & social backwardness", not just economic status. Petitioner wanted income-based preferences inside SC, ST, OBC and EWS categories for “more equitable” policy🎯 Centre’s blunt stand: The “creamy layer” concept was developed only for OBC reservations & does not apply to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Strong rejection of pure economic criteria.

The Analyzer (News Updates🗞️)

328,247 görüntüleme • 10 gün önce

Suggested a name change to Reservation Reform Movement. With a Manifesto 🇮🇳 This is not a call to end reservation. It is a call to discuss reforms that make the system fairer, more transparent and more effective. ✅ Introduce a creamy layer in SC/ST reservation so the benefits reach the most disadvantaged families. ✅ No reservation below a minimum qualifying benchmark. ✅ Reservation should be available only once for OBC and twice for SC/ST across UG, PG, PhD and Government Jobs. ✅ Reserved category candidates should continue under the reserved category and not occupy general category seats. ✅ Review the reservation percentage. If SC/ST/OBC reservation is reduced after due review, the released percentage should be reallocated to EWS and Persons with Disabilities (PwD). ✅ Publish a nationwide reservation review every 10 years and make the findings public. ✅ Improve government schools, colleges and public education infrastructure. ✅ Only public funding. No external funding. ✅ Keep the movement peaceful and non-political. The only slogans should be Jai Hind, Jai Bharat and Bharat Mata Ki Jai. Agree or disagree, let’s have a respectful and constructive discussion.

Suggested a name change to Reservation Reform Movement. With a Manifesto 🇮🇳 This is not a call to end reservation. It is a call to discuss reforms that make the system fairer, more transparent and more effective. ✅ Introduce a creamy layer in SC/ST reservation so the benefits reach the most disadvantaged families. ✅ No reservation below a minimum qualifying benchmark. ✅ Reservation should be available only once for OBC and twice for SC/ST across UG, PG, PhD and Government Jobs. ✅ Reserved category candidates should continue under the reserved category and not occupy general category seats. ✅ Review the reservation percentage. If SC/ST/OBC reservation is reduced after due review, the released percentage should be reallocated to EWS and Persons with Disabilities (PwD). ✅ Publish a nationwide reservation review every 10 years and make the findings public. ✅ Improve government schools, colleges and public education infrastructure. ✅ Only public funding. No external funding. ✅ Keep the movement peaceful and non-political. The only slogans should be Jai Hind, Jai Bharat and Bharat Mata Ki Jai. Agree or disagree, let’s have a respectful and constructive discussion.

Praffulgarg

19,801 görüntüleme • 18 gün önce

#WATCH | Patna: In the Bihar Assembly, Bihar CM Nitish Kumar says, "The 50% (reservation) should be increased to at least 65%... The upper caste has 10% already (EWS). So 65 and 10 make 75%. The remaining would be 25%. Earlier, 40% was free now it would be 25%. The reservation for backward class and extreme backward class, ST-SC should be done 65% instead of 50%, this is my proposal..."

#WATCH | Patna: In the Bihar Assembly, Bihar CM Nitish Kumar says, "The 50% (reservation) should be increased to at least 65%... The upper caste has 10% already (EWS). So 65 and 10 make 75%. The remaining would be 25%. Earlier, 40% was free now it would be 25%. The reservation for backward class and extreme backward class, ST-SC should be done 65% instead of 50%, this is my proposal..."

ANI

1,384,561 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

General category students are expected to accept every disadvantage silently, but the moment they question the system, they are called anti-reservation Even in UPSC, General candidates get 6 attempts, OBC candidates get 9, while SC/ST candidates have unlimited attempts, subject to the applicable age and eligibility conditions So when we talk about a fair education and examination system, can we honestly say that everyone is competing under the same rules? This is not about disrespecting reservation or denying historical discrimination It is about asking whether the system needs reform Should genuine economic disadvantage, access to education, family background and actual opportunities also be considered more seriously? What do you think?

General category students are expected to accept every disadvantage silently, but the moment they question the system, they are called anti-reservation Even in UPSC, General candidates get 6 attempts, OBC candidates get 9, while SC/ST candidates have unlimited attempts, subject to the applicable age and eligibility conditions So when we talk about a fair education and examination system, can we honestly say that everyone is competing under the same rules? This is not about disrespecting reservation or denying historical discrimination It is about asking whether the system needs reform Should genuine economic disadvantage, access to education, family background and actual opportunities also be considered more seriously? What do you think?

Ojas Bhandari

25,170 görüntüleme • 21 gün önce

THIS SHOULD'VE BEEN DONE LONG AGO TO ALLOW BENEFITS OF RESERVATIONS TO THOSE WHO REALLY NEED IT! SC seeks response from Centre on ‘creamy layer’ in SC/ST quota. Plea argues that once a family member attains a Govt or Constitutional post, their children should not keep availing quota benefits. I can give 3 examples right here on how benefits of reservations are availed by those who are no-more oppressed or without access to resources to studies. Father → Kids 1. Jaswant Dabi (ITS officer, Group A central service) → Tina Dabi (IAS, 2015 batch) and Ria Dabi (IAS, 2020 batch)— Family availed ST reservation benefits. 2. Uttam Khobragade (IAS, 1984 batch) → Devyani Khobragade (IFS, 1999 batch) — Both availed SC reservation. 3. Sanwar Mal Verma (Promotee IAS, Rajasthan cadre) → Kanishak Kataria (IAS, 2018 batch) — Family from SC category; son topped on merit but eligible under SC framework. These are just 3 examples. There may be many. Now SC has asked Centre and States to reply to a petition seeking creamy layer application in SC/ST reservations. Question is: 'Are reservations being cornered by a few families across generations who have become affluent enough not to need those reservation benefits? Isn't it an injustice with those from humble background who really don't have free access to resources'. Good that finally this issue is being raised.

THIS SHOULD'VE BEEN DONE LONG AGO TO ALLOW BENEFITS OF RESERVATIONS TO THOSE WHO REALLY NEED IT! SC seeks response from Centre on ‘creamy layer’ in SC/ST quota. Plea argues that once a family member attains a Govt or Constitutional post, their children should not keep availing quota benefits. I can give 3 examples right here on how benefits of reservations are availed by those who are no-more oppressed or without access to resources to studies. Father → Kids 1. Jaswant Dabi (ITS officer, Group A central service) → Tina Dabi (IAS, 2015 batch) and Ria Dabi (IAS, 2020 batch)— Family availed ST reservation benefits. 2. Uttam Khobragade (IAS, 1984 batch) → Devyani Khobragade (IFS, 1999 batch) — Both availed SC reservation. 3. Sanwar Mal Verma (Promotee IAS, Rajasthan cadre) → Kanishak Kataria (IAS, 2018 batch) — Family from SC category; son topped on merit but eligible under SC framework. These are just 3 examples. There may be many. Now SC has asked Centre and States to reply to a petition seeking creamy layer application in SC/ST reservations. Question is: 'Are reservations being cornered by a few families across generations who have become affluent enough not to need those reservation benefits? Isn't it an injustice with those from humble background who really don't have free access to resources'. Good that finally this issue is being raised.

BhikuMhatre

47,644 görüntüleme • 7 ay önce

#WATCH | A study by the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) reveals that the population share of Hindus fell by 7.81 per cent between 1950 and 2015 while the share of minorities increased. BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi says, "In the census of 1951, there were 88% Hindus and 9.5% Muslims while in the census of 2011, there were 79.8% Hindus and 14.5% Muslims... The population of SC, ST, and OBC will increase based only on natural causes. But the population of these people will grow on three factors- natural causes, religious conversion, immigration, and polygamy. I want to ask the INDI alliance leaders if they want to give reservation based on population, will they go on increasing reservation on this ever-growing population? And whose reservation will they take away?... In India, there are nine states and dozens of districts in which Hindus have become a minority. This is a fact... When Rahul Gandhi's Nyay Yatra began in the Northeast, he gathered maximum support in Assam's Dhubri, Barpeta, and Karimganj, and West Bengal's Malda constituencies which have seen the maximum demographic shift due to infiltration. Congress is playing a dangerous fame, whose first target will be the SC, ST, and OBC reservation."

#WATCH | A study by the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) reveals that the population share of Hindus fell by 7.81 per cent between 1950 and 2015 while the share of minorities increased. BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi says, "In the census of 1951, there were 88% Hindus and 9.5% Muslims while in the census of 2011, there were 79.8% Hindus and 14.5% Muslims... The population of SC, ST, and OBC will increase based only on natural causes. But the population of these people will grow on three factors- natural causes, religious conversion, immigration, and polygamy. I want to ask the INDI alliance leaders if they want to give reservation based on population, will they go on increasing reservation on this ever-growing population? And whose reservation will they take away?... In India, there are nine states and dozens of districts in which Hindus have become a minority. This is a fact... When Rahul Gandhi's Nyay Yatra began in the Northeast, he gathered maximum support in Assam's Dhubri, Barpeta, and Karimganj, and West Bengal's Malda constituencies which have seen the maximum demographic shift due to infiltration. Congress is playing a dangerous fame, whose first target will be the SC, ST, and OBC reservation."

ANI

16,736 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

The reservation epidemic in Madhya Pradesh has gone totally insane!! CM Dr Mohan Yadav got approval from all parties to snatch 13% share of GC Hindus and give it to OBCs in direct violation of Indira Sawhney’s judgement. The high court had given a stay on this increase in reservation, yet the BJP-led government decided to challenge it in the Supreme Court using its might !! Why is this party doing this? Why does it hate Swarana Hindus so much? Even when they have been its loyal supporters? Is the price Swarana Hindus will have to pay for voting Sanghis to power? Absolutely mind-numbing stuff! Good that Brahmins & Kshatriyas have united to fight their apartheid !! Let’s support them with full force in whatever way we can!!

The reservation epidemic in Madhya Pradesh has gone totally insane!! CM Dr Mohan Yadav got approval from all parties to snatch 13% share of GC Hindus and give it to OBCs in direct violation of Indira Sawhney’s judgement. The high court had given a stay on this increase in reservation, yet the BJP-led government decided to challenge it in the Supreme Court using its might !! Why is this party doing this? Why does it hate Swarana Hindus so much? Even when they have been its loyal supporters? Is the price Swarana Hindus will have to pay for voting Sanghis to power? Absolutely mind-numbing stuff! Good that Brahmins & Kshatriyas have united to fight their apartheid !! Let’s support them with full force in whatever way we can!!

Ritu #सत्यसाधक

12,421 görüntüleme • 11 ay önce

This is how Annamalai’s political rivals ‘celebrated’ DMK win in Tamil Nadu - by slaughtering a goat in full public view, with a picture of Annamalai on it. Barbaric. This is how the anti- Santan I.N.D.I Alliance will butcher the Hindus, if they ever come to power. Initial data suggests that in 2024, 3 out of 4 Muslims have voted for the Congress alliance. Up from 2/4 in 2019. The Congress is now the new Muslim League. They will not stop, till they take away reservation of the SC/ST/OBCs and give it to the Muslims. We must stop them at all cost. Simultaneously, the Congress and its alliance will unleash caste divisions, in order to weaken the Hindu consolidation, just as they have tried this time. This is a long cherished project of the Breaking India forces. Hindus need to beware.

This is how Annamalai’s political rivals ‘celebrated’ DMK win in Tamil Nadu - by slaughtering a goat in full public view, with a picture of Annamalai on it. Barbaric. This is how the anti- Santan I.N.D.I Alliance will butcher the Hindus, if they ever come to power. Initial data suggests that in 2024, 3 out of 4 Muslims have voted for the Congress alliance. Up from 2/4 in 2019. The Congress is now the new Muslim League. They will not stop, till they take away reservation of the SC/ST/OBCs and give it to the Muslims. We must stop them at all cost. Simultaneously, the Congress and its alliance will unleash caste divisions, in order to weaken the Hindu consolidation, just as they have tried this time. This is a long cherished project of the Breaking India forces. Hindus need to beware.

Amit Malviya

480,016 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

An 18 yr old NEET General Category student who scored around 93 percentile was denied admission to an MBBS course despite qualifying on merit. The matter has gone from the High Court to the Supreme Court. The case mainly focuses on the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) quota and how private medical colleges allocate seats. The boy argues that some private colleges do not properly implement EWS quota seats. This situation disadvantages general category students and affects merit-based admissions. At the same time, the Supreme Court is also examines the sharp reduction in NEET PG qualifying cut offs. The cut off for the General category has been reduced significantly. The cut off for SC/ST/OBC candidates has reportedly gone into negative marks to fill vacant seats. Dear Narendra Modi Amit Shah We the GC, have no one to appeal to. You are out last hope. We the General Category, today, have become the "Persecuted" by the unjust policies of the reservation. Please amend the reservation policies.

An 18 yr old NEET General Category student who scored around 93 percentile was denied admission to an MBBS course despite qualifying on merit. The matter has gone from the High Court to the Supreme Court. The case mainly focuses on the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) quota and how private medical colleges allocate seats. The boy argues that some private colleges do not properly implement EWS quota seats. This situation disadvantages general category students and affects merit-based admissions. At the same time, the Supreme Court is also examines the sharp reduction in NEET PG qualifying cut offs. The cut off for the General category has been reduced significantly. The cut off for SC/ST/OBC candidates has reportedly gone into negative marks to fill vacant seats. Dear Narendra Modi Amit Shah We the GC, have no one to appeal to. You are out last hope. We the General Category, today, have become the "Persecuted" by the unjust policies of the reservation. Please amend the reservation policies.

Dr Poornima 🇮🇳

71,430 görüntüleme • 6 ay önce

#WATCH | Congress MP Jairam Ramesh says "...Congress party demands that the Constitution be amended so that the 50% limit which has come from the Supreme Court, should be removed for reservation of SC/ST and OBC. JD(U) does not say anything about this. They passed a resolution regarding category status. It is very easy to pass a resolution but will they put pressure on their ally BJP in Patna and Delhi? Will the Chief Minister say to the Prime Minister that we are supporting you, give us special category status, get the caste census done and get the 50% limit removed? They are silent on this, so it is very easy to say but it is very difficult to do and there is a huge difference between doing and saying..."

#WATCH | Congress MP Jairam Ramesh says "...Congress party demands that the Constitution be amended so that the 50% limit which has come from the Supreme Court, should be removed for reservation of SC/ST and OBC. JD(U) does not say anything about this. They passed a resolution regarding category status. It is very easy to pass a resolution but will they put pressure on their ally BJP in Patna and Delhi? Will the Chief Minister say to the Prime Minister that we are supporting you, give us special category status, get the caste census done and get the 50% limit removed? They are silent on this, so it is very easy to say but it is very difficult to do and there is a huge difference between doing and saying..."

ANI

224,546 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

In Kanpur, UP: Two Dalit Hindus of Pasi caste were brvtally beaten by Brahmin priest and his disciples for taking bath in Ganga. Upper castes have a problem even if a Dalit goes to a temple. Upper castes have a problem even if a Dalit converts to another religion. What can the Dalit do? Everyone sees the reservation and SC/ST Act given to Dalits, but upper castes do not see the atrocities and insults they face in the name of caste. ADG ZONE KANPUR kanpurpolice Please take appropriate action against the Casteist priests and his disciple.

In Kanpur, UP: Two Dalit Hindus of Pasi caste were brvtally beaten by Brahmin priest and his disciples for taking bath in Ganga. Upper castes have a problem even if a Dalit goes to a temple. Upper castes have a problem even if a Dalit converts to another religion. What can the Dalit do? Everyone sees the reservation and SC/ST Act given to Dalits, but upper castes do not see the atrocities and insults they face in the name of caste. ADG ZONE KANPUR kanpurpolice Please take appropriate action against the Casteist priests and his disciple.

Dhruvaa

46,985 görüntüleme • 2 ay önce

#WATCH | Former Uttar Pradesh CM and BSP chief Mayawati says "The people of the ruling party and the Opposition have joined together and they want to end the reservation given to SC, ST, OBC in the Constitution or they want to make it ineffective. This is why these people do not want to conduct caste-based census in the entire country. The opposition keeps saying this but it is not as serious as it should be. They have joined together and that is why these people do not want to conduct caste-based census, these people are doing politics for their votes only..."

#WATCH | Former Uttar Pradesh CM and BSP chief Mayawati says "The people of the ruling party and the Opposition have joined together and they want to end the reservation given to SC, ST, OBC in the Constitution or they want to make it ineffective. This is why these people do not want to conduct caste-based census in the entire country. The opposition keeps saying this but it is not as serious as it should be. They have joined together and that is why these people do not want to conduct caste-based census, these people are doing politics for their votes only..."

ANI

26,675 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

Huge respect that TVK Vijay won the Tamilnadu Election 2026 But the thing, The moment TVK Vijay entered politics, they rushed to support him instantly. No political maturity, no balanced perspective - just blind hatred towards one ideology. Debating with facts is different, but carrying pure bias everywhere only exposes the mindset more clearly. Simply because we have progressed in every aspect through what the Dravidian movement has done for Tamil Nadu, we must understand the struggles faced by our grandparents, parents, and earlier generations. They lived through inequality, lack of education, social discrimination, and limited opportunities. The Dravidian ideology and social justice movement changed that path by giving importance to education, self-respect, reservation, women’s rights, and equal opportunities for all communities. Today’s younger generation is born into a better and more educated society because of those reforms. That history should never be forgotten. We must teach future generations about the struggles our people faced and the changes brought through Dravidian ideology and social justice.

Huge respect that TVK Vijay won the Tamilnadu Election 2026 But the thing, The moment TVK Vijay entered politics, they rushed to support him instantly. No political maturity, no balanced perspective - just blind hatred towards one ideology. Debating with facts is different, but carrying pure bias everywhere only exposes the mindset more clearly. Simply because we have progressed in every aspect through what the Dravidian movement has done for Tamil Nadu, we must understand the struggles faced by our grandparents, parents, and earlier generations. They lived through inequality, lack of education, social discrimination, and limited opportunities. The Dravidian ideology and social justice movement changed that path by giving importance to education, self-respect, reservation, women’s rights, and equal opportunities for all communities. Today’s younger generation is born into a better and more educated society because of those reforms. That history should never be forgotten. We must teach future generations about the struggles our people faced and the changes brought through Dravidian ideology and social justice.

Dr Mubarak

19,199 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

My zero hour speech in Parliament today on Manipulated Roaster system followed by DOPT to suppress marginalised communities from entering mainstream positions such as heads of organizations and secretaries of the department. ****************************************** Thank you, Deputy Chairman Sir. There is deliberate tinkering of the Department of Personnel and Training reservation roster system used in public employment within the Union Government and its agencies. This manipulation has systematically deprived Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) of their rightful representation in public employment and also to head the Government organisations. Reservation was introduced as an instrument of social justice to ensure fair representation for historically marginalized communities, and the reservation roster is a crucial component in implementing this policy. However, the reservation roster, as outlined in the Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT) Office Memorandum dated 2.7.1997, is fundamentally flawed. The issues continued with the subsequent memorandum dated January 31, 2019. These anomalies have resulted in the wrongful excess allocation of posts to Unreserved (UR) candidates at the expense of reserved categories. For example, according to the 2019 memorandum: - In the 13-point model roster, 9 out of 13 posts (including 1 EWS) are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the rightful 6—an unjust gain of 3 additional posts. - In Departments/organizations with only 2 sanctioned posts, both positions are assigned to Unreserved candidates, completely eliminating representation for reserved candidates. - In a cadre strength of 6, five positions are allocated to Unreserved candidates instead of the appropriate 3. - In small cadres (with less than 10 posts):- 70% of posts in a cadre of 10 are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the correct 50.5%. - 83% of posts in a cadre of 6 are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the correct 50.5%. - 100% of posts in a cadre of 3 are assigned to Unreserved candidates, completely eliminating reservation. These data’s furnished by me are not mere statistical discrepancies; they are systematic efforts to eliminate reserved candidates and favor Unreserved candidates, which constitutes a direct violation of the constitutional mandate for social justice. The first roster point, which carries significant importance, has been exclusively assigned to Unreserved candidates across all government institutions, leading to a deliberate distortion that ensures SC, ST, and OBC candidates are denied fair representation in Group ‘A’ and ‘B’ posts. Sir, to perpetuate an error is a sin, but to correct it is an administrative duty. The existing roster system represents a structured deception designed to suppress the rightful opportunities of marginalized communities, preventing them from entering mainstream positions such as heads of organizations and secretaries of the department. This constitutes a constitutional betrayal and an ongoing injustice that has persisted for decades. I urge the Hon’ble Prime Minister of India and Hon’ble Minister of State for Personal Pensions and Public Grievances to take immediate action to end this rigged reservation system and form a high-level committee with a retired supreme court judge from the disadvantage communities as Chairperson along with members ensuring proportionate representation from SC,ST, OBC and Unreserved categories to investigate the scam and devise a fair roster system. This committee should identify the total losses suffered by reserved categories since 1997 in public employment, recommend measures to compensate for these losses through additional recruitment drives, and propose solutions to ensure that SC, ST, and OBC candidates have fair and equal opportunities to lead government organizations atleast in future. M.K.Stalin Udhay All India Federation For Social Justice DMK

My zero hour speech in Parliament today on Manipulated Roaster system followed by DOPT to suppress marginalised communities from entering mainstream positions such as heads of organizations and secretaries of the department. ****************************************** Thank you, Deputy Chairman Sir. There is deliberate tinkering of the Department of Personnel and Training reservation roster system used in public employment within the Union Government and its agencies. This manipulation has systematically deprived Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) of their rightful representation in public employment and also to head the Government organisations. Reservation was introduced as an instrument of social justice to ensure fair representation for historically marginalized communities, and the reservation roster is a crucial component in implementing this policy. However, the reservation roster, as outlined in the Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT) Office Memorandum dated 2.7.1997, is fundamentally flawed. The issues continued with the subsequent memorandum dated January 31, 2019. These anomalies have resulted in the wrongful excess allocation of posts to Unreserved (UR) candidates at the expense of reserved categories. For example, according to the 2019 memorandum: - In the 13-point model roster, 9 out of 13 posts (including 1 EWS) are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the rightful 6—an unjust gain of 3 additional posts. - In Departments/organizations with only 2 sanctioned posts, both positions are assigned to Unreserved candidates, completely eliminating representation for reserved candidates. - In a cadre strength of 6, five positions are allocated to Unreserved candidates instead of the appropriate 3. - In small cadres (with less than 10 posts):- 70% of posts in a cadre of 10 are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the correct 50.5%. - 83% of posts in a cadre of 6 are assigned to Unreserved candidates instead of the correct 50.5%. - 100% of posts in a cadre of 3 are assigned to Unreserved candidates, completely eliminating reservation. These data’s furnished by me are not mere statistical discrepancies; they are systematic efforts to eliminate reserved candidates and favor Unreserved candidates, which constitutes a direct violation of the constitutional mandate for social justice. The first roster point, which carries significant importance, has been exclusively assigned to Unreserved candidates across all government institutions, leading to a deliberate distortion that ensures SC, ST, and OBC candidates are denied fair representation in Group ‘A’ and ‘B’ posts. Sir, to perpetuate an error is a sin, but to correct it is an administrative duty. The existing roster system represents a structured deception designed to suppress the rightful opportunities of marginalized communities, preventing them from entering mainstream positions such as heads of organizations and secretaries of the department. This constitutes a constitutional betrayal and an ongoing injustice that has persisted for decades. I urge the Hon’ble Prime Minister of India and Hon’ble Minister of State for Personal Pensions and Public Grievances to take immediate action to end this rigged reservation system and form a high-level committee with a retired supreme court judge from the disadvantage communities as Chairperson along with members ensuring proportionate representation from SC,ST, OBC and Unreserved categories to investigate the scam and devise a fair roster system. This committee should identify the total losses suffered by reserved categories since 1997 in public employment, recommend measures to compensate for these losses through additional recruitment drives, and propose solutions to ensure that SC, ST, and OBC candidates have fair and equal opportunities to lead government organizations atleast in future. M.K.Stalin Udhay All India Federation For Social Justice DMK

P. Wilson

13,231 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce