Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Excerpt from this interview. Physicists always understood that missile defense is extremely hard, but our military and civilian leaders did not. Now they can't ignore this brutal truth, because of the Iran war.

49,742 views • 3 months ago •via X (Twitter)

16 Comments

steve hsu's profile picture
steve hsu3 months ago

Related article: Realities of Modern War

Tiger Cat's profile picture
Tiger Cat3 months ago

Thus my opinion, growing stronger by the year: Every leader at a high level should be STEM elite.

Adam Messinger's profile picture
Adam Messinger3 months ago

To what extent do you think we landed here because there was a recognition that the full SDI vision (which had emphasis on energy weapons) would destabilize MAD? So instead we built a bunch of inferior systems precisely because they could only work against smaller countries.

steve hsu's profile picture
steve hsu3 months ago

No one believed the proposed energy weapons would work! The effectiveness of missile interceptors has been overstated, although Ted Postol exposed Patriot failures in the Gulf War. It's been MIC selling overpriced systems of questionable effectiveness for 40+ years now.

steve hsu's profile picture
steve hsu3 months ago

Even if the interceptors worked as claimed, the cost and mfg scaling challenges would still remain.

Adam Messinger's profile picture
Adam Messinger3 months ago

Agree with this. An interceptor strategy can probably work if you are 1000X richer than enemy (North Korea) but maybe not if you are only 100X richer than enemy (Iran) and definitely not if you are only 10X richer (Russia) or on par (China).

jzac's profile picture
jzac3 months ago

Thank You.

James Smyth's profile picture
James Smyth3 months ago

I have to compare this "defending missile has to be more accurate than the target missle" to what I've been going through recently.... AI analysis of resumes that is necessary to combat AI-generated resumes. There are obviously more interesting and consequential comparison we could come up with but its what I spent my day doing, so it struck a chord.

Lost in the crowd's profile picture
Lost in the crowd3 months ago

As one revolutionary told the reactionary dictator: "You have to be lucky every time to escape; but we have to be lucky only once!"

Igor Carron's profile picture
Igor Carron3 months ago

Politicians don't want to hear it because if anti-balllistic defence were not possible, it would lead to a "strike first" before the boost phase doctrine.

Kaven Borbon's profile picture
Kaven Borbon3 months ago

@M_Simonyan @SocialistMMA @ChrisHelali

Out of The Cave's profile picture
Out of The Cave3 months ago

We aren't even in a war time economy for one. For two as you stated Lockheed figured out the cost issue hence directed energy scale out. Also to be clear we aren't doing massive scale bombing runs, instead we aee fighting a precision fight, somewhat at tbe behest of Arab countries being attacked.

lyntwo's profile picture
lyntwo3 months ago

The followers have failed our glorious leadership.

Kaven Borbon's profile picture
Kaven Borbon3 months ago

@mitchpresnick @RnaudBertrand @pati_marins64 @jwdwerner @roas_TT

Just use a 🖊️'s profile picture
Just use a 🖊️3 months ago

The reasons interception is so hard seem like reasons to pursue it anyway. Cracking these problems would pay off well beyond missile defense. Does that seem right to you

Pugnacious Polk's profile picture
Pugnacious Polk3 months ago

richard garwin go brrr

Related Videos