Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Expected Luke Morgan would get cleared. Clumsy, and so unfortunate for Ethan Hooker, but I don’t see a clear intent to injure. First time I’ve seen a long term injury from a rugby collision like this; I expect they may look to tweak the laws around it as a result

74,694 views • 6 months ago •via X (Twitter)

39 Comments

Gus's profile picture
Gus6 months ago

No clear intent? He dived with his elbow into his back after he grounded the ball. Rugby collision??? Really? He wasn't even going for the ball.

The 5 Metre Channel's profile picture
The 5 Metre Channel6 months ago

‘after he grounded the ball’ EH still moving to the ground when LM dives. Video displays this better than the photos. Also the impactful contact is with the forearm. Collisions during act of scoring a try happen all the time. People move on from them after 5 seconds if no injury

Gus's profile picture
Gus6 months ago

1st still: EH dived but not grounded ball yet. LM upright. 2nd still: EH grounded ball. LM still on both feet, getting ready now to dive.3rd still: EH sliding forward. LM in lower position but still on feet. 4th: Dogshot with elbow in back. No attempt to go for ball.

The 5 Metre Channel's profile picture
The 5 Metre Channel6 months ago

You are talking in stills because that completely removes any story of momentum from a 50m+ chase. Ridiculous. You can’t even detect if he’s upright in the first frame! You merely see his face and shin. Citing commission would have seen far clearer than us. No further action

Gus's profile picture
Gus6 months ago

Need to go to Specsavers pal. 1st still his head is higher than 2nd still. Perspective doesn't change. He had the option after 50m chase to dive left or right but chose to go into his back after the fact. Dirty cheap shot.

Dominic Ward's profile picture
Dominic Ward6 months ago

No one is suggesting ’intent to injure’ but why drop on him? Reckless at best. He had no business doing that. He could have run past without making contact. The try had been scored and he wasn’t going to stop it. The only point could have been to let him know he was there.

Nigel Clarkson's profile picture
Nigel Clarkson6 months ago

Yeah he easily could have pulled out of that. He was pissed that he couldn’t catch him and was trying to make a point. Was never going to stop that try, just doing a forearm smash to the back. You’re right, it happens quite a lot and it absolutely should be stopped.

Paul Wright's profile picture
Paul Wright6 months ago

Sorry blatant attempt to injure player. He led with his elbow arm in front of him. He hit him just under the shoulder in the back when he was on the ground. He was never stopping the try & it wasn't a tackle as no attempt to wrap. He wanted to hit as hard as possible. 3mth ban

Dr Johnny Bananas's profile picture
Dr Johnny Bananas6 months ago

For the panel to conclude that isn't a yellow card is wild, its now basically open season for this sort of cheap shot Lets hope its nothing worse than shoulders at risk as a result of this decision

Andrew Mileham 🇿🇦's profile picture
Andrew Mileham 🇿🇦6 months ago

Frankly, it was always just a penalty from the half way line. Match day officiating was up the pole.

TheRugbyMac's profile picture
TheRugbyMac6 months ago

That’s not clumsy at all. It’s hugely reckless. A cheap shot, the try was already scored. Absolutely no need.

Rashidy Tweets's profile picture
Rashidy Tweets6 months ago

It’s not Clumsy. He may not have intended to cause a serious injury but he’s done it to leave something on him. It’s dickhead behaviour.

malky's profile picture
malky6 months ago

Diving in on a try scoring player after he has crossed the try line and on the way to ground with an elbow knee foot or any other part should an automatic red no 20 minute mitigation there is no need for this kind of dangerous play in the game

Morne Viljoen's profile picture
Morne Viljoen6 months ago

"I don’t see a clear intent to injure" and "a rugby collision" must be two of the most low IQ retarded rugby takes of the last decade. The fact that they are in the same post from the same person convinces me that instructions on shampoo bottles are totally justified.

сняis сндмеLеои's profile picture
сняis сндмеLеои6 months ago

me hoping they don’t change the rules before the unclear and unintentional reciprocation

Geoff Francis's profile picture
Geoff Francis6 months ago

Look, let’s be honest, it’s a cheap shot, but, it’s one that happens in nearly every game but is rarely picked up by an Official! Should be a penalty restart from the halfway line, once a few of these are given players will soon stop it, well maybe Plumtree won’t!😉

DRB's profile picture
DRB6 months ago

Heap shot that cause serious injury , should get game ban , I hear this rubbish that he was diving to get the ball , load of bollocks , he was no where near getting the ball and clearly dived on player back

JonMoTay2023's profile picture
JonMoTay20236 months ago

Intent was to injure or hurt Hooker. These hits have happened for a long time & should be stopped as this was predictable outcome. Wouldn’t happen back in the day when Morgan knew next time he was in a ruck he’d be raked, stamped on etc……

BasPanic's profile picture
BasPanic6 months ago

Issue is there’s zero attempt to tackle, he just dives on top of him with his arms tucked and that’s why I don’t think it’s clumsy it’s just stupid and reckless and maybe the intent wasn’t to injure but it definitely was to hurt

Christiaan's profile picture
Christiaan6 months ago

Common sense to know that your "action" won't make a difference. Luke Morgan could not change the outcome except injury to someone else. You don't need a new rule, it's common sense. Same as faking an injury to have uncontested scrums. Just shows the real human...

Lorcan's profile picture
Lorcan6 months ago

Cheap shot - may not have intended that level of injury but it was a ‘leave your mark’ action.

David Paxton's profile picture
David Paxton6 months ago

It’s a cheap shot. An illegal one. Best possible take is massively lazy. And that’s a bad take. It’s not clumsy.

Pocks's profile picture
Pocks6 months ago

Not a fan of those kinds of cheap shots tbh. Yellow with a bunker review

Chicken's profile picture
Chicken6 months ago

Is there any situation on the field where one player is allowed to fall onto the back of another player? To make it worse - leading with the forearm? If Ethan was falling on a ball to clean up a kick-through and he jumped on him like that - is that legal?

Ferox's profile picture
Ferox6 months ago

Had exact same. Ball keeps arm up pressure down shoulder pops.

Miles's profile picture
Miles6 months ago

As a Kiwi, I’ll throw my two cents in. There is no way that is a legitimate attempt to stop the try being scored. It’s foul play and clearing him sends a bad message. If the intent is not to injure then what is it? You can be sure a Saffa would’ve been suspended.

Croí Na hÉireann's profile picture
Croí Na hÉireann6 months ago

Deegan got sent off v Ulster for something completely accidental. That by Morgan was a deliberate act.

stevo's profile picture
stevo6 months ago

Always hated that shit tbh everyone does it not surprised injuries occur it’s a cheap shot but it happens everywhere

SA Problems's profile picture
SA Problems6 months ago

"Rugby Collision"??? Is that what you call it now?

MARTIN NEWBURY's profile picture
MARTIN NEWBURY6 months ago

Look again, but didn’t seem bothered when he got up, but then a team mate jumps up and smashes into his shoulder, then he feels it

Sean O' Mahony's profile picture
Sean O' Mahony6 months ago

There doesn't have to be intent, too many fellas getting away with these cheap shots.

Phil's profile picture
Phil6 months ago

Cheap. Nothing to gain legitimately at that point. Red

Nathan Tiflin's profile picture
Nathan Tiflin6 months ago

Please explain how you gage that there is no intent to injure? He has no chance of stopping the try and merely dives on Hooker leading with the elbow. Please explain how you came to this conclusion? Is it because he is Welsh and any other nation would be intent to injure?

Charlton Park RFC's profile picture
Charlton Park RFC6 months ago

He had already scored - no reason to dive in him . It was a cheap shot like so many you see and they should be punished regardless of any injury or lack of injury

Ruhan de Kock's profile picture
Ruhan de Kock6 months ago

Where is the attempt to tackle or dislodge the ball? He clearly just falls on EH with forearm to the back, there is no wrap which is needed to be deemed a tackle

Phil not Bob's profile picture
Phil not Bob6 months ago

He looked fine when he got up then his team mate jumped on his arm. 🤷

Blueboy95's profile picture
Blueboy956 months ago

No one on the sharks reacts to it at all. Obviously it's a massive shame Hooker is injured, but the attempt from Morgan is competely normal. Of course crazy SA fans won't see it that way... they still hold a grudge on Koroibete for a legal tackle he made 7/8 years ago!

LaochDwarfJohn's profile picture
LaochDwarfJohn6 months ago

To be fair, there’s no realistic chance of stopping the try there. This sort of challenge should be outlawed if we’re serious about player welfare.

T'Chaka's profile picture
T'Chaka6 months ago

The Elbow was a bit excesive. to a point it cause an injury that may end Hookers season before it even started.

Related Videos