Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Good visualization for the “why are jet engines harder than rockets?” crowd. Those little blades deal with scorching temps and high pressure—consider too the J-79 here is an old one There’s a reason more countries can make nukes than jet engines

245,050 views • 3 years ago •via X (Twitter)

10 Comments

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

One issue w jet engines that makes them a unique challenge is their required durability Jet engines must run reliably (carrying people!!) for thousands and thousands of hours with countless start/stop cycles Even “reusable” rockets go for a few minutes ~10 times

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

I think this NASA report provides an excellent summary. Some have rightly noted in the comments the unique difficulties associated with liquid rocket turbopumps—the NASA summary here is great in highlighting the uniqueness of this environment…

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

But just look at the cycle times! The engines as designed only had to hold up to ~6 cycles or < 1hr! The engineering gets an awful lot easier when it’s ok for things to crack/fatigue/wear within an hour Source:

Turbo's profile picture
Turbo3 years ago

Cool visualization. Jets are formula 1 cars; rockets are top fuel dragsters. They’re hard in different ways.

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

Great analogy

Gooney Bird Drone's profile picture
Gooney Bird Drone3 years ago

Any idea what methods were used to design early axial compressor blades? Momentum blade element analysis?

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

Probably same way they did airfoils. Some analytical potential flow solutions and method of characteristics perhaps, followed by testing

Oliver Morton's profile picture
Oliver Morton3 years ago

Isn’t it more why good jet turbines are harder than basic rockets? Full flow staged combustion looks pretty damn hard

Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)'s profile picture
Chris Combs (iterative design enjoyer)3 years ago

Kind of. Added some context to the thread here

cayniarb's profile picture
cayniarb3 years ago

You're saying smashing together two blobs of appropriately enriched materials is easier than this? Several demon core researchers might agree... You know, if they were able...

Related Videos