Hit or error?

Error. Maybe a hit if it’s definitive proof that JP’s speed beats it out on a clean play but it doesn’t look to be that way.

comical that this is even up for debate

Maybe some of the most over the top home cooking I’ve ever seen by an official scorer, lol.

Wow. Tough one. I'd go error. Should have been an out somewhere there....

Let’s reframe the question properly: error or error?

At home a hit, on the road an error.

Hit. In opposite land

error thats routine

Doesn’t matter to me either way he’s on base

Error.