Honest conversation needed. Will JJ McCarthy succeed with the Giants?

Sure as hell has a better chance than he did with the Vikings

Duh, what do you think? LMAO...😂😂🤭

The fact you’re using college film from 3 years ago tells you all you need to know

Probably not, but hopefully he grows with them enough to get a serious look by a team that needs him more long term

I would love it if he did!!!

No, honest conversation had.

Give him protection and teach him how to attack the blitz. He's got the arm, but if the protection breaks down mix in some RPO's. The kid is mobile and can run like hell. Harbaugh should take advantage of this like he did with Lamar Jackson.

I miss #9 man 🫩🫩

YES

JJ's future success boils down to one thing: 👉🏽 He needs to learn how to read/work a progression, a skill he has NEVER demonstrated (yet). Look at every compilation of successful passes from him. Every time he throws it to the first guy he looks at, who luckily gets open or makes a hero catch. 👉🏽You can have a good quarter or a good game that way. But not a good season.

No

That was dam near the same throw he did to Malik yesterday!

Would he have been QB1 in 2025?

Yeah, he will for this year but darts are future. We’re gonna build JJ up and then dump them for her first or second round pick maybe even keep them till his contracts about to run out just in case.