Should the Vikings trade JJ McCarthy to the Giants?

Why not? Seems like the entire fanbase hates him anyway, so to shut them up send him off. I hope he has a baker mayfield type of resurgance and makes all the vikes fans loom stupid.

For nothing less than a 1st, which means no. So many qb injuries already this season, you really think Kyler and Wentz aren’t going to both be injured at the same time this season? When 1 game can be difference between 1 seed and Super Bowl favorite and 5 seed on the road for super wild card weekend, you don’t put your season in the hands of Max Brosmer for a day 2 pick.

We have an injury prone starter and backup. Max Brosmer can't do it. Hold onto your QB's. Offense has changed for the better. JJ doesn't have to be the focal point.

You should see giants fans reaction to this idea

Stupid coach and stupid franchise if they trade him this year. Let the kid sit and learn and get better. Love this organization but absolute stupidity if they trade him. Especially considering the 2 geriatric QB's in front of him right now. He'll see the field this year..no doubt

No we should start him.

Why are we even debating trading a QB that had experience in the system on a rookie scale deal when injuries at the positions have forced this team to go to QB3 multiple seasons under KOC? No mid round pick is worth the insurance if the season is supposed to be competitive.

Yes. And the stupid cult with him.

I'm with you on wanting to see more games with JJ to see what he can be. But, if the Vikings are committed to continuing to be a dismal QB team that never reaches for greatness, then getting the best possible pick in '27 is the best way to go.

Hell nah, Trade Murray first.

No

The way you glazed this guy, we're going to need two firsts and their starting center. You know better than anyone that McCarthy is the next Josh Allen. You don't get to soft-backpedal out of this, homie.

No. The Vikings have no future at QB. They will learn soon that Kyler is not the answer.

Yes for two 1sts

Two games into a 2-0 season and we're already shopping the quarterback? Let the kid develop behind this defense before detonating the plan.

Yes. For a Fifth Rounder or better. This kid's a BUST

we want three firsts

We have 3 QBs who have a rich history of injuries. I don’t think we want to see a repeat of Brosmer having to start. No way we trade JJ, in fact he could start some games this season.

No.

Nope.

No

NO unless the Giants are desperate enough to send a second round pick

No.

No

Unless its a conditional 2nd or 3rd......

No

Must Keep JJ or it'll haunt us in 10 years

No we will need him likely

YES! Let the Giants have JJ McCrappy.

Lol ohhh okkk so the giants just accept the trade when they can go get Levis cheaper

A third then maybe These QBs are dropping like flies I wouldn’t trade McCarthy for anything less than a third for team cohesion if things go sideways

please

Absolutely

Let's see how Murray plays on Sunday if it's not great we should trade Murray to them we know wentz can be ok and who knows maybe kid developes