Загрузка видео...
Не удалось загрузить видео
I gave 4 frontier models the same prompt to create an Ecco the Dolphin style video game 100% procedural 🐬 Same task, official chat UIs, max thinking. Watch 👇 Claude Fable 5 Z.ai GLM 5.2 @ChatGPTapp GPT 5.5 Pro Google Gemini Flash 3.5 Note: Fable 5 version was created... show more
44,413 просмотров • 4 месяцев назад •via X (Twitter)
Комментарии: 55

Prompt if you want to test: --- Build "TIDESINGER", a complete Ecco the Dolphin-style game as ONE self-contained HTML file. No external assets, no libraries, no network. Canvas 2D only. HARD CONSTRAINTS - Single file, runs from file:// on desktop and mobile Safari/Chrome - 100% procedural graphics (code-drawn) and 100% procedural WebAudio - Allocation-free hot loop: typed-array pools w/ swap-remove, prerendered offscreen sprite canvases for all glows/bubbles/motes, cached Path2D terrain, viewport culling on every entity, DPR capped at 2 - 60fps target on mid-range phones; fixed max dt clamp GAME FEEL (non-negotiable) - Momentum swimming: thrust + exponential drag underwater, real gravity above the waterline so breaching produces ballistic arcs with splash in/out - Charge burst on cooldown (Ecco's dash), damages predators at speed - Sonar pulse: expanding ring; stuns jellyfish, spooks sharks, interrogates glyphs, fires a direction ping toward current objective - Dynamic camera: velocity lookahead + speed-based zoom out + cinematic zoom/letterbox/slow-mo on story beats; hit-stop on heavy impacts WORLD: 5 biomes across one continuous 15k-unit map, distinct palette grading 1 SUNLIT SHALLOWS animated caustics, coral, tutorial 2 KELP FOREST dense weeds, lateral current, crystal 1 3 OPEN TRENCH floor dips deep, downdraft current, passing WHALE silhouette w/ moan (ambient signature moment), crystal 2 4 ABYSS CAVERN rock ceiling blocks surfacing; darkness with a light radius around the dolphin (sonar widens it); AIR POCKETS under ceiling domes are the only oxygen; crystal 3 5 SONG GATE + HOME REEF barrier wall opens only when all 3 songs are sung at the glyph; goal ring ends the run SYSTEMS - Air meter (drown damage at zero), vitality, fish schools that flee and heal when eaten, jellyfish drift hazards, patrolling/chasing sharks (2 hp, flee when beaten), urchin spike hazards on rocks - Checkpoint shells per biome (respawn keeps progress), score with fish-streak multiplier, breach style bonuses, floating score popups, minimap progress bar with objective markers - States: animated title, pause, death, win (time + score + fish stats) RENDERING QUALITY BAR - Spine-based dolphin (18 segs): undulation injected along spine, counter-shaded body perpendicular to travel, dorsal/pectoral/fluke with independent motion, blowhole spray on surfacing - Sunset sky, sun glow, parallax islands; 3-layer rock parallax underwater; god rays; drifting plankton motes; depth fog + per-biome color grade (multiply pass); caustic light webs in shallows; foam flecks on wave crests; vignette; additive glow sprites for all emissive objects AUDIO (WebAudio, all synthesized) - Filtered-noise ocean bed + detuned drone, depth-tracked lowpass - Pentatonic sonar chirps, crystal arpeggio, splash noise bursts, gate rumble, whale moan, low-air heartbeat CONTROLS - Touch: left-half floating stick, SONAR + CHARGE buttons, pause button - Keyboard: WASD/arrows, SPACE sonar, SHIFT/X charge, P pause Ship it tested: syntax-checked and headless-simulated through a full run.

Very cool. Fable really is in a class of it's own, the scene composition seems really polished, but each had some interesting surprises.

Fable version really surprised me

The amount of juice in the movement and sound is really what got me. It was using little pops of movement to drive attention and discovery. Stuff that I consider next level for most devs.

@Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Play the Claude Fable 5 version

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp And some say they don’t notice any difference with Fable

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Pretty clear here right?

glm-5.2 did so good

Yeah, I was surprised

@haider1 Were these all one shot? Or did you have to nurse any along? It looks like Fable 5, glm 5.2, flash 3.5 and then gpt5.5 ranked from best to worse.

@haider1 All one shot

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Including Flash 3.5 in with the others was just evil... until I saw the results! It's not the best here, but it's easily 10x better than my expectations. Maybe there is hope for 3.5 Pro after all.

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp I'm trying to motivate @GoogleAI 😆

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp 1. Ecco the Dolphin 2. Ecco the Dolphin x Another World Remix Edition 3. Slecco the Swirlfin 4. Ecco the Salamander

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Great minds think alike 😂

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Same prompt, four models, completely different feel for each game, love this format

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Cheers 🍻

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp nice, cheersss

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp that's the most interesting part each model's procedural generation is so different even when given the same task, it highlights the variance in their internal representations

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp It's a good benchmark to see actual differences

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Could you show Opus?

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Ecco the Dolphin is the perfect nostalgic theme to test these new models. In my opinion, Fable did it best but GLM really surprised me.

@openingai_com @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Agree on both points

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp GLM 5.2 looked the best to me.

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Would be awesome to add Opus 4.8 to comparison :)

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Opus 4.8 did well on logic, but Fable 5 graphics were much better

@dabrodev @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Who wins between GLM 5.2 and Opus 4.8 in your opinion?

@dabrodev @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Opus 4.8 slightly, but GLM is impressive

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Fable wins

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Agree 💯

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Could i ask how you’re using glm 5.2? Which harness and provider ?

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Directly on

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp it's between Fable and GLM 5.2. With Fable being better on some aspects, and vice-versa.

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Fable did the cleanest implementation with best graphics imo

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp 这个对比真的很有说服力

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp 🙏

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp GPT 5.5 why the fish body look like wave

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Not sure, I tried a few generations and it came out like that.

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Can I know how much did each cost too ?

@Meme_God_069 @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp For Claude and ChatGPT I used the subscriptions and official chat interfaces, GLM and Gemini were free.

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Did you /loop it or goal it haha

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Ha nope! It's actually just a single prompt, check the replies

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp The one thing I have to say, the UI is always so bad 😭😭 no offense to you, I know it was one shotted, but AI UI is so noticeable now haha

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Fable 5 actually looks incredible, still won’t switch back from Codex though, it’s alright for me right now

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp I like Codex for functional code, but I've found Claude superior for game dev

@threejs @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Use 5.5 in codex harness not 5.5 pro

@ShiftingPathway @threejs @claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Tried it in Codex, got a better dolphin, but the level design still very similar to Pro

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp That Gemini is what nightmares are made of

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp 😂 hope 3.5 pro is better! @OfficialLoganK

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp You should have a warning on there "CANNOT BE UNSEEN"

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp 😂

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Fable looks really good and I also like GLMs

@claudeai @Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp It reminded me of an old game called "Feeding Frenzy." Nice work, Majid.

@Zai_org @ChatGPTapp @GeminiApp Play the GLM 5.2 version



