Video wird geladen...
Video konnte nicht geladen werden
I have some issues with the 2009 Trek Reboot, but the one thing I cannot deny is that casting Karl Urban as McCoy was a stroke of pure, uncut, unabridged genius. “Space is disease and danger wrapped in darkness and silence” was delivered so well that I could imagine... show more
521,289 Aufrufe • vor 23 Stunden •via X (Twitter)
37 Kommentare

Karl Urban, as a true professional, studied DeForest Kelly's performances intently, trying to truly understand both the mannerisms and the character, then building on the original. So really, we have had it backwards all along: DeForestation leads to Urbanization

BOOOOOOOO. Bravo.

"Ex-wife took the whole damn planet in a divorce, all I get left are my bones" - entire origin story in a sentence, and the best damn line of the movie.

sometimes I think I'm misremembering how distracting the lens flare was, but nope it's there .

Yeah, I know that JJ Abrams was going for a "this is the future" shine (or he wanted the movie to look like a classic Spielberg shot but for 2 hours). But it can get annoying.

Leonard Nimoy was apparently brought to tears by Urban’s performance, because he felt it was like having his old friend back in the room with him 🥺

Honestly it’s incredible how well cast the movie is in general. They nailed every single role in this movie.

My respect for Karl Urban went up substantially after this scene. Not a fan of JJ's Trek timeline but this casting choice was excellent.

He was great in the role. But when is he not great in a role?

Karl Urban absolute peak casting. Astoundingly brilliant. A new take, the same take, new and old all at once. Absolutely astonishing performance that never once felt like a pale imitation or impression.

The part that bothers me is when he says his ex only left him his bones, do explain his nickname. It's actually from Kirk's knowledge of history that a slang term for a surgeon was "Sawbones" because amputation was so prevalent as the only recourse for so many injuries.

Karl Urban is awesome in anything.

My dad never watched movies but he always like TOS. I showed him this movie and he thought Urban was real good as McCoy.

We should be on “DREDD 4: Jury’s Out” and I should be on my second trip to the theatres to see it. Karl Urban is the man

Yep, Bones was the best part of the jjverse, Urban is the business. I shudder to think of the upcoming Dredd being made by that antipodean oaf waititi.

Agreed. Urban as McCoy was great casting.

At the same time he was playing Eomer. The guy played two of my favorite fictional characters practically simultaneously.

While it has many issues,I really enjoy the JJ Abrams trilogy and is one reason I was optimistic about the SW sequels To me it occupies the same space as the SW prequels do for a lotta people, only I do think this one has much better writing and plot and the cast was terrific

Casting Karl automatically improves your movie by 20% (it makes Dredd a 8,4/10 and Star Trek an 3,6/10)

There are issues with the reboot but K.U. was a good choice.

Urban was a good casting choice and the movie itself was entertaining, but they could have just called it Space Rangers. It wasn’t Star Trek.

That opening score, as the remains of the crew escape, and the 'Star Trek' title appears, give me chills every time.

I agree with you. Every actor's portrayal was outstanding. However, for me, Karl stole the show. When he said to Kirk about Spock, "I dont know who he is, but I like him!", I thought, "Give this man an Oscar!!"

Chris Pike as Kirk was also remarkably good considering who he replaced. First 2 movies were way better than the star wars reboot. However, this alternative history garbage is were it falls down. Why oh why do modern filmmakers feel the need to alter everything the fans love

The problem is, Abrams didn't get the character. He made him just another colorful background figure. McCoy is supposed to be #3, and the emotional & moral balance to Spock's logic & rational ethics. Instead we got Sassy Uhura who's also Spock's love interest.

Casting Karl Urban as almost anything is a stroke of pure, uncut, unabridged genius.

I have my issues with the 2009 Trek reboot, but one thing I will never argue is that casting Karl Urban as McCoy was a stroke of pure genius.

Hate we got so little

Karl Urban is great in everything. He improves any movie.

This was the movie thar killed my interest in ST. I haven’t stepped into a cinema since.

Well did you expect anything less from Johnny "F'ing" Cage? 😉

The casting was good. The stories - not so much. Star Trek Beyond was the closest thing to proper Star Trek.

Urban was fantastic as Bones. But, the whole Kelvin timeline cast was spot on. It felt natural. SNW not that much.

The best choice for that role.

Karl Urban was the best casting choice in that series of movies hands down

Agree

Casting Karl Urban in general is great. One of the very few actors today to have range, and he's got a LOT !
