正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

加载此视频时出现问题。这可能是由于临时网络问题，或视频可能不可用。

I think the IDF are actually underestimating how many Hamas combatants they killed. I went through the data, and I think that the civilian to combatant ratio in the Israel Hamas war is a testimony to the Israelis effort to spare civilian life.

Andrew Fox

140,483 subscribers

49,123 次观看 • 1 年前 •via X (Twitter)

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

10 条评论

Max 📟 的头像

Max 📟1 年前

Hamas claims that 41 children were kiIIed per day, which nobody actually believes.

Ant 的头像

Ant1 年前

The biggest issue the IDF face is that there's next to no distinction between a Hamas militant and a civilian, because many of the civilians themselves.. are Hamas.. They're one and the same..

Mephisto-Matt 的头像

Mephisto-Matt1 年前

What’s your methodology for actually differentiating a combatant and a non-combatant? The line is so blurred as to be meaningless as we saw from Bibas kidnapping and the fact UNRA were up to their nipples in assistance. Which is of course why a two state solution is impossible and without population dispersal this cycle will continue for perpetuity

Adino Ha'Etzni 的头像

Adino Ha'Etzni1 年前

He gets it.

Tony Arpi ⚛ 的头像

Tony Arpi ⚛1 年前

@MaxNordau Interesting. However: women in Gaza fulfill the role of "terrorist factories": complicit as hell. Also the qualification "child" is arbitrary; does a 15 year old carrying an AK-47 qualify as (innocent-) child? How many "innocent" civilian casualties does that leave us?...

Aaron Yarm 🎗️ 的头像

Aaron Yarm 🎗️1 年前

thank you for providing such objective moral clarity. All civilian life lost is a tradgedy, but as you say it is important to understand the wider picture especially when claims of 'ethnic cleansing' and 'genocide' are thrown about.

Joy 的头像

Joy1 年前

@Ok_Solly 😢👏👏

Zairalablatta 的头像

Zairalablatta1 年前

May i ask you where you think all these bodies are? How many under the rubble? Bc i dont wanto to be cinic or disrespect those who actually die, but it looks very few documentation of 'civilian' burials have been shown. They are a lot, in a small area....

Ismail Lamie 的头像

Ismail Lamie1 年前

Dude, what the hell are you still spewing at this point? You said it was the most precise operation in history by the most moral army in history. Result: Gaza is completely leveled and destroyed, Hamas is still operating. Over 2 million lives ruined for 30k combattants.

RedBrasco - RedLehi 的头像

RedBrasco - RedLehi1 年前

There should be a relentless search and destroy mission against all Hamas members now.

相关视频

IDF Spokesperson Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari: “Hamas sees civilian death as a strategy, we see it as a tragedy — which is why we use many measures to try and minimize the civilian harm and suffering — that is the tragic reality — in this war that Hamas started.”

IDF Spokesperson Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari: “Hamas sees civilian death as a strategy, we see it as a tragedy — which is why we use many measures to try and minimize the civilian harm and suffering — that is the tragic reality — in this war that Hamas started.”

Israel ישראל

77,652 次观看 • 2 年前

Leftists have nothing to say to Israelis once the truth of the war is confronted. Israel’s war in Gaza has the most impressive combatant to civilian casualty ratio of any war in history — ever.

Leftists have nothing to say to Israelis once the truth of the war is confronted. Israel’s war in Gaza has the most impressive combatant to civilian casualty ratio of any war in history — ever.

Marina Medvin 🇺🇸

1,038,292 次观看 • 1 年前

Primetime Alex Stein #99 asks 'Jewish Jess' Jewish Jess about the IDF's civilian to combatant ratio: "2 civilians die for every 1 Hamas terrorist. Even 2 to 1, that does seem like a humanitarian crisis." "The civilian to combatant ratio is very low in the Gaza war. If you look at the Iraq war, it was 7 to 1." "Which is not good." From After Hours with Alex Stein on Real America's Voice (RAV)

Primetime Alex Stein #99 asks 'Jewish Jess' Jewish Jess about the IDF's civilian to combatant ratio: "2 civilians die for every 1 Hamas terrorist. Even 2 to 1, that does seem like a humanitarian crisis." "The civilian to combatant ratio is very low in the Gaza war. If you look at the Iraq war, it was 7 to 1." "Which is not good." From After Hours with Alex Stein on Real America's Voice (RAV)

After Hours with Alex Stein #99

65,020 次观看 • 3 个月前

"Hamas went into Israel that day (Oct. 7) knowing they can't beat the IDF. They went in that day, knowing that the IDF would come after the hostages. They went in that day, knowing that they were going to use their own civilians on top of legitimate military targets, in an effort to increase civilian casualties." Video: Nick Freitas - Nick Freitas

"Hamas went into Israel that day (Oct. 7) knowing they can't beat the IDF. They went in that day, knowing that the IDF would come after the hostages. They went in that day, knowing that they were going to use their own civilians on top of legitimate military targets, in an effort to increase civilian casualties." Video: Nick Freitas - Nick Freitas

Am Yisrael Chai 🇨🇦 🇮🇱

115,637 次观看 • 1 年前

Hamas continues to exploit civilian infrastructure as a terrorist hub. Al-Shati is one of many areas where schools and civilian buildings are used to launch rockets, store weapons and carry out attacks against the IDF.

Hamas continues to exploit civilian infrastructure as a terrorist hub. Al-Shati is one of many areas where schools and civilian buildings are used to launch rockets, store weapons and carry out attacks against the IDF.

Israel Defense Forces

422,440 次观看 • 2 年前

The FP’s Coleman Hughes on the myth of moral equivalence in Gaza: “I believe that in the war between Israel and Hamas, the Israelis are the good guys and Hamas are the bad guys. “I’m not saying that everything the IDF does is justifiable… What I mean is that Israel’s goals as a country are far more benign and ethical than Hamas’s goals. Israel’s goal is to live in peace with its neighbors.”

The FP’s Coleman Hughes on the myth of moral equivalence in Gaza: “I believe that in the war between Israel and Hamas, the Israelis are the good guys and Hamas are the bad guys. “I’m not saying that everything the IDF does is justifiable… What I mean is that Israel’s goals as a country are far more benign and ethical than Hamas’s goals. Israel’s goal is to live in peace with its neighbors.”

Conversations with Coleman

869,048 次观看 • 1 年前

Imagine if Hamas used the same effort to protect their civilians as they do to embed their terrorism. At the heart of civilian areas in Shuja'iyya—IDF forces located and neutralized: * Hamas infrastructure * several terrorist tunnels * dozens of terrorists

Imagine if Hamas used the same effort to protect their civilians as they do to embed their terrorism. At the heart of civilian areas in Shuja'iyya—IDF forces located and neutralized: * Hamas infrastructure * several terrorist tunnels * dozens of terrorists

Israel Defense Forces

338,413 次观看 • 2 年前

Check out this Hamas footage. How many of the combatants are in uniform while fighting the IDF? None. When they'll meet their maker, how do you think the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry will describe them? You're right: "civilians". Another reason to question everything they say.

Check out this Hamas footage. How many of the combatants are in uniform while fighting the IDF? None. When they'll meet their maker, how do you think the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry will describe them? You're right: "civilians". Another reason to question everything they say.

Jonathan Conricus

651,022 次观看 • 2 年前

BREAKING: A spokesperson for Hamas just said that they are going to start executing civilian hostages they took from Israel on live TV for every IDF airstrike that hits a civilian in Gaza, which happens as a result of Hamas using them as human shields. These are the animals leftists are defending.

BREAKING: A spokesperson for Hamas just said that they are going to start executing civilian hostages they took from Israel on live TV for every IDF airstrike that hits a civilian in Gaza, which happens as a result of Hamas using them as human shields. These are the animals leftists are defending.

Greg Price

6,277,611 次观看 • 2 年前

"How many civilians have actually been killed?! You don't know, do you?" Piers Morgan grills John Spencer on his claim that Israel's ratio of civilian deaths to combatants in Gaza is "the best ratio in modern warfare". 📺 Piers Morgan | John Spencer

"How many civilians have actually been killed?! You don't know, do you?" Piers Morgan grills John Spencer on his claim that Israel's ratio of civilian deaths to combatants in Gaza is "the best ratio in modern warfare". 📺 Piers Morgan | John Spencer

Piers Morgan Uncensored

3,098,045 次观看 • 2 个月前

Breaking: A recorded conversation between a Hamas terrorist and a Gazan reveals that Hamas is using ambulances to transfer weapons and terrorist operatives in the Gaza Strip. Hamas terrorist operative: “I can leave with any ambulance I want.” Hamas exploits civilian infrastructure and uses civilians as human shields.

Breaking: A recorded conversation between a Hamas terrorist and a Gazan reveals that Hamas is using ambulances to transfer weapons and terrorist operatives in the Gaza Strip. Hamas terrorist operative: “I can leave with any ambulance I want.” Hamas exploits civilian infrastructure and uses civilians as human shields.

Israel ישראל

12,531,990 次观看 • 2 年前

🚨 JUST IN: Musk Analyzes Israel-Hamas Conflict "Hamas committed the worst atrocities they could, in order to provoke the most aggressive response possible from Israel" "For every Hamas Member you kill, how many do you create? And they will go on and die, killing Israelis" Is war the best way to prevent a repeat of October 7?

🚨 JUST IN: Musk Analyzes Israel-Hamas Conflict "Hamas committed the worst atrocities they could, in order to provoke the most aggressive response possible from Israel" "For every Hamas Member you kill, how many do you create? And they will go on and die, killing Israelis" Is war the best way to prevent a repeat of October 7?

Mario Nawfal

1,684,611 次观看 • 2 年前

John Spencer, Richard Kemp, and Andrew Fox are experts in the field of urban warfare, and I detail their findings in my new book, Israel on Trial: Examining the History, the Evidence, and the Law. In urban warfare, the average militant-to-civilian casualty ratio is about 1 to 9, meaning one militant killed for every nine civilians killed. That's not because every war that's ever been fought is a genocide. It's because war is horrible and urban warfare in particular is horrible. That's why Israel would much prefer to fight Hamas out in the open. It's Hamas who chooses to fight in Gaza underneath its civilian population precisely to increase—not decrease—the number of civilian casualties. In the American war in Iraq and Afghanistan, we and our allies set the gold standard. We had a militant-to-civilian kill ratio of about one to four-and-a-half, maybe one to five, and many experts believed no army would ever be able to meet that standard again. In much more difficult and complicated circumstances, Israel, even if you believe Hamas's bogus numbers—which you should not believe for all the reasons I lay out in the book—but even if you took Hamas at completely face value and you believed all of their numbers, Israel has a militant to civilian kill ratio of about one to one-and-a-half in Gaza. If Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, then the Americans committed genocide in Iraq and Afghanistan, then the Americans and the allies committed genocide in Germany and Japan, and literally every war that has ever been fought in human history has been a genocide. That's not what genocide means. We should reserve the label for the crime of all crimes, because otherwise the consequences will be dire.

John Spencer, Richard Kemp, and Andrew Fox are experts in the field of urban warfare, and I detail their findings in my new book, Israel on Trial: Examining the History, the Evidence, and the Law. In urban warfare, the average militant-to-civilian casualty ratio is about 1 to 9, meaning one militant killed for every nine civilians killed. That's not because every war that's ever been fought is a genocide. It's because war is horrible and urban warfare in particular is horrible. That's why Israel would much prefer to fight Hamas out in the open. It's Hamas who chooses to fight in Gaza underneath its civilian population precisely to increase—not decrease—the number of civilian casualties. In the American war in Iraq and Afghanistan, we and our allies set the gold standard. We had a militant-to-civilian kill ratio of about one to four-and-a-half, maybe one to five, and many experts believed no army would ever be able to meet that standard again. In much more difficult and complicated circumstances, Israel, even if you believe Hamas's bogus numbers—which you should not believe for all the reasons I lay out in the book—but even if you took Hamas at completely face value and you believed all of their numbers, Israel has a militant to civilian kill ratio of about one to one-and-a-half in Gaza. If Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, then the Americans committed genocide in Iraq and Afghanistan, then the Americans and the allies committed genocide in Germany and Japan, and literally every war that has ever been fought in human history has been a genocide. That's not what genocide means. We should reserve the label for the crime of all crimes, because otherwise the consequences will be dire.

Roy K. Altman

42,262 次观看 • 4 个月前

Lord Andrew Roberts, war historian, journalist, and member of the House of Lords: Even if you take Hamas’ wildly inflated numbers as fact, the ratio of civilian death to militant death is less than 2:1. For reference, the average ratio for modern urban warfare of this kind is 9:1, where civilians account for 90 percent of casualties. This ratio is “astonishingly low,” especially in a war in which one side, Hamas, routinely uses civilians as human shields. While every civilian life lost is a tragedy, it is a testament to the care, professionalism, ethics, and values of the IDF and Israel.

Lord Andrew Roberts, war historian, journalist, and member of the House of Lords: Even if you take Hamas’ wildly inflated numbers as fact, the ratio of civilian death to militant death is less than 2:1. For reference, the average ratio for modern urban warfare of this kind is 9:1, where civilians account for 90 percent of casualties. This ratio is “astonishingly low,” especially in a war in which one side, Hamas, routinely uses civilians as human shields. While every civilian life lost is a tragedy, it is a testament to the care, professionalism, ethics, and values of the IDF and Israel.

Hen Mazzig

330,445 次观看 • 2 年前

The IDF just announced that they conducted the largest operation of the war since October 7th, capturing 358 terrorists, including numerous senior leaders from Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, which is another terrorist organization in Gaza. Where were they hiding? In the Shifa Hospital. Yeah, the same hospital that the IDF cleared out in November and found signs that Israeli hostages were held there, underground terrorist tunnels, and Hamas’s central command under the hospital. Hamas went back to Shifa and barricaged themselves inside because Hamas hides in hospitals. I don’t know how many times I have to say this, but Hamas continuously puts Palestinian civilians in harms way, by turning hospitals into their terrorist hideouts. Meanwhile, the IDF has been supplying food, water, and generators to the hospital because this is a war against Hamas, not against the Palestinians in Gaza. This is what we’re going up against. And Israel will continue to do everything it can to protect civilians, while targeting Hamas terrorists. Gaza will only be free when Hamas is defeated.

The IDF just announced that they conducted the largest operation of the war since October 7th, capturing 358 terrorists, including numerous senior leaders from Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, which is another terrorist organization in Gaza. Where were they hiding? In the Shifa Hospital. Yeah, the same hospital that the IDF cleared out in November and found signs that Israeli hostages were held there, underground terrorist tunnels, and Hamas’s central command under the hospital. Hamas went back to Shifa and barricaged themselves inside because Hamas hides in hospitals. I don’t know how many times I have to say this, but Hamas continuously puts Palestinian civilians in harms way, by turning hospitals into their terrorist hideouts. Meanwhile, the IDF has been supplying food, water, and generators to the hospital because this is a war against Hamas, not against the Palestinians in Gaza. This is what we’re going up against. And Israel will continue to do everything it can to protect civilians, while targeting Hamas terrorists. Gaza will only be free when Hamas is defeated.

Noa Tishby

246,272 次观看 • 2 年前