NEW ATC AUDIO: Controllers Warned Learjet 60 Pilots
@afg1911a111K followers
307,275 views
37 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@BhallalYadav9
The atc warned her its pretty bad, she replied, “we’ll look into it” thats incompetency right there. Should have just ask for a new plan/course deviation.
48 likes

@JohnnyGWatson1
This was absolutely avoidable
37 likes

@SoloScritura
It looks pretty nasty... 100 miles in diameter- that was not a standard statement. This sad incident will entirely change the way pilots approaching storms and responding ATC will interact with each other.
36 likes

@afg1911a1
It was already standard procedure to avoid flying through storms—it’s just that pilots sometimes forget. -40… leigo I get scared even at 21.
15 likes

@smithsrsn
Generally the way it works. ATC gives broad warnings of areas of storms around your route. Then you as the pilot will analyze (you probably already knew it was there and have a plan) and request deviations. Once you have been cleared to deviate, ATC leaves it up to the pilot to deviate as needed. This is what happened in this scenario. They were Ultimately given clearance to deviate left and right and asked to report when they were direct to Freeport. I would expect them to report "directly to freeport" when they believed they were done deviating. Which they eventually did report "we are turning direct to Freeport". Does ATC have a responsibility to inform you if you are headed into something after they clear you to deviate? I'm not sure, but they already warned you, so that may meet their requirement. They are also super busy during times when dozens of planes are deviating, and probably aren't capable of watching every aircrafts specific deviation plan perfectly. OR Another common occurrence: ATC warns you of storms and assigns you specific routing around them. This has been the most common method in my experiences in Florida. But this is not what happened in this incident. Ultimately they asked to deviate, and we're given clearance to deviated left and right. And they did deviate for nearly 20 minutes prior to the crash. So, I suspect, they never saw the final thunderstorm cell on the radar because they did actually report "we are turning direct to freeport" which would indicate that they believed no further deviations were necessary. Unfortunately they were wrong and that turn direct to freeport took them directly into that last storm cell.
28 likes

@RonUSFF
That’s my flight into Palm Beach the following day after the crash. Look for the black circle. The approach controller didn’t like the rain ahead of us so he turned us to the west to go around it. I’m flying a Boeing 737MAX8. Our onboard radar is awesome and it didn’t show a threat. It also displays turbulence using its own Doppler radar and no turbulence was showing. The rain did start to display as red but no shadows behind it and just a few miles across. That area was solid green until just before the controller called us. My iPad app, that shows ground-based weather radar and a lot of additional information about storms, showed just rain, nothing convective like a thunderstorm. The second pic is what we see on the iPad. That screenshot was from earlier in the day, on a previous flight. I was preplanning the flight to Palm Beach on my way to Philly. I didn’t see any need to change heading to the west, but out of RESPECT to the controller, I thanked him for being proactive and accepted the turn. Once below the clouds, I could see 15 miles. It was nighttime but the city lights were easy to see through the heavy rain. No lightning anywhere, confirming what we saw on our radar and the iPad. No turn was needed. Pilots are always looking to confirm what they see on the radar screen in order to build trust in the equipment. The controller handling the Lear 60 flight could’ve told the pilots to change heading. Likely, next time he will.
24 likes

@don_bowler
Lawyers are gonna have a FIELD DAY with this one.
20 likes

@eatnaintcheatn1
When she said "370 climb"....her voice was shaky. She knew it then.
9 likes

@Testrun071
They never “warned” it is a generic statement that they give to everyone. They knew the Wx was there. They probably didn’t know that individual cell was there, or greatly misjudged its severity. Climbing whilst picking up ice at a high altitude is not a good idea.
7 likes

@RajanSinghNT
She asked for another route. The ATC says they were far from danger. Then says weather is good ahead. Then suddenly, ice starts to build and crash. ATC could have done better.
7 likes

@LeoSaintJuste1
nothing new here; audio has been around
6 likes

@mdf188
I don't understand the playing down of the turbulence calling it moderate while it clearly wasn't. What would be the reason?
6 likes

@1tr9y
Nathalia was not calling the shots, the captain was.
6 likes

@sabooky15
ATC dropped the ball.They wanted to go right and ATC stopped them and said it was good ahead. Seconds later they were smack dab into an updraft and then died.
5 likes

@zenpointglobal
Looks like the “lionesses” should have concerned herself with storms.
5 likes

@TheAngeloLester
Fuck off. Old news. Loser
4 likes

@TheodoreMasters
At 1:57 of the clip sounds like the back ground voice of a male says hallowed be thy name ? Prayers possible ?
4 likes

@1ofmanydoomed
Some more information on the actual pilot that was busy praying while the girl was screaming trying to save them. That said “it looks pretty nasty” sounds like gross incompetence for everyone who heard that and proceeded.
2 likes

@Wepz511
No Pilot anywhere will knowingly and willingly fly through a storm again with this as the lesson.
2 likes

@wasfamily1
are we blaming the man yet?
2 likes













