No argument without religion
@AbolitionRising61K followers
30,049 views
31 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@ian_bruh1
They don’t know why anything is wrong aside from how they were raised and what the culture/law tells them.
26 likes

@kramschust2
Theologically, murder is immoral because we are created in God’s image and as such have great value
16 likes

@RonKronz
Everyone is religious. How they adhere to their highest authority is their religion. Their highest authority is their god.
12 likes

@KitHudsonAus
Oh, he's not smart. All of the original laws were codification of behaviour that is mandatory for a social species to work. A tribe is stronger than an individual. If a tribe has lots of murders it is weaker than a tribe that doesn't kill each other.
7 likes

@nugget_ai
>"why is it wrong to murder?" >Atheist dodges question >again... "why is murder wrong?" >Atheist: "well let me flip the question to you!" Why are all atheists insufferable liars unable to answer basic questions and have good faith arguments?
6 likes

@indynerd
On one hand, he's right to have the kid question how has core beliefs were formed. On the other hand, this is not the slam dunk against atheism that's so many think it is. You can make the argument of inherent value of human life from a humanist perspective, natural rights, etc.
2 likes

@edaniel13
Nice job getting him to think. That one is going to keep him up at night or, at least, it should.
2 likes

@Deep_biblestudy
Atheist argument in 3 words. Me No Likey
2 likes

@twindad13
It takes more faith to be an atheist than to believe in God
1 like

@PatriotMP1969
No God, no morals
1 like

@MalditoMP
Harm against private property. Everyone's owner of their own body as their private property. Harming a property you don't own is wrong
1 like

@AbolitionArk
Often they can't think deep enough to follow the logic. It's wrong because it's wrong is their axiom.
1 like

@jdoug2222
formalized homicide laws date back to the 7th-century BC lawmaker Draco in ancient Athens (from which the term Draconian came from)
1 like

@Mattizreal
HURTING people in ANY way is wrong

@FelonMusik
I’m not sure if T-Russ is trolling, forcing the other individual to think critically, or if he actually believes what he just said despite presenting arguments that are based on biological continuity.

@seraphimabove
An atheist cannot argue against murder without borrowing from the Christian worldview. I've never seen it done.

@ClintRegert
You should start bringing up Imago Dei to these kids and how Christianity is responsible for the "inherit" morality they reference and take for granted.

@joshwin41
"Atheist" is not a moral worldview. There is not a set of atheist ethics attached to being atheist. Ethics is its own ballgame entirely, even within theism. Like the various disagreements between sects of Christianity alone based upon interpretations and traditions.

@WMutschmann
Awesome stuff guys!!

@TheovanRossum4
"Why is murder wrong?" must be the stupidest question ever since Christians would just say "Because the Bible says it is" where at least the atheist can think for himself. But the keep pushing the fallacy that atheists cannot really have morals or "stole" them from Christians.










