Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
Ocean Heat Source 12: Inverse prediction map complete I worked backwards from the observed abyssal warming and mapped where the missing heat sources would have to be, and how strong they'd have to be. The strongest predicted hotspot is around 51.8°W, 41.1°S. So... Roger (Ethical Skeptic ☀), is there... show more
71,378 views • 2 months ago •via X (Twitter)
13 Comments

Yes, these hotspots reside exactly where the abyssal thermohaline currents run (blue runs in Panel 1) - which matches ECDO Theory extraordinarily well. This points to abyssal heat as the delivery mechanism to the surface heat (SST) at the turnaround/upwelling points globally - entirely skipping the Deep ocean altogether, and matches the Desbruyeres Study results. (Panel 2) Q.E.D.: The heat is coming from the Abyssal Ocean. 😎

@EthicalSkeptic If you want an anomaly to go back and look at, look at the heat map in the pacific before Seattle had their 110 degree day on June 28, 2021. A large hot water mass was out west of there days before. Due to the strength of the Hawaiian current, that was a serious anomaly.

•Stephanie Buchanan’s inverse map identifies where extra basal heat would have to enter the abyss to match the observed warming pattern, while Ethical Skeptic’s ECDO framework supplies a core-to-ocean heat-delivery hypothesis that those locations can be tested against. •PGBM-2.1 does not generate a new heat-source map; it supplies an independent energy-identity and gravitomagnetic constraint that rules out frame-dragging and solid-mantle yield as explanations for the same predicted hotspots. •Together the three pieces form a complementary filter: the inverse map shows where heat is needed, ECDO proposes a physical origin and transport path, and PGBM checks which candidate mechanisms remain dynamically allowed on decadal timescales.

•Stephanie Buchanan’s inverse map identifies where extra basal heat would have to enter the abyss to match the observed warming pattern, while Ethical Skeptic’s ECDO framework supplies a core-to-ocean heat-delivery hypothesis that those locations can be tested against. •PGBM-2.1 does not generate a new heat-source map; it supplies an independent energy-identity and gravitomagnetic constraint that rules out frame-dragging and solid-mantle yield as explanations for the same predicted hotspots. •Together the three pieces form a complementary filter: the inverse map shows where heat is needed, ECDO proposes a physical origin and transport path, and PGBM checks which candidate mechanisms remain dynamically allowed on decadal timescales.

Are you willing to share your workbook?

Probably not the workbook itself, but I’m planning to publish the map and tables on my website.

Magnetic anomaly nearby?

PGBM-2.1 supplies a weak-field, first-order-dragging constraint set for Earth rather than a full 3-D ocean or dynamo simulation. Its Earth-class numbers already fix the scale of the effects that can be compared with the inverse heat-source map.32 •Frame-dragging is negligible for ocean heat: the matched Lense–Thirring rate at the surface is (\omega_+\approx 3.36\times 10^{-14},\mathrm{rad,s^{-1}}) (period (\sim 6\times 10^6,\mathrm{yr})). It cannot source or spatially organize the observed 20 TW abyssal heating increment. •The energy identity isolates the only terms that can change ocean heat content on decadal scales: Ohmic dissipation (-\int\eta_m\mu_0|\mathbf{J}|^2,\mathrm{d}V), viscous dissipation, buoyancy work (\int\rho’\mathbf{g}\cdot\mathbf{v},\mathrm{d}V), plus tidal and boundary fluxes. Lorentz work cancels internally between kinetic and magnetic energy, so it does not appear as a net heat source. This is consistent with treating electromagnetic induction in seawater (the remaining hypothesis in the Ocean Heat Source series) as an Ohmic term driven by the time-varying external field, not by the interior dynamo. •Yield is inactive in the mantle on the relevant stress scale ((\rho_0 W_2/\sigma_Y\sim 0.04)). Localized seafloor “hotspots” predicted near 51.8°W, 41.1°S therefore cannot be produced by solid-state failure; they must be tested against mapped conductive heat flow, hydrothermal discharge, or induction in the conductive ocean shell that lies outside PGBM’s insulating-mantle magnetic boundary-value problem. Until the free parameters in A6 ((\alpha,\eta_m,\mu_v,\sigma_Y), Love numbers) are taken from data, the model remains a consistency filter, not a predictive heat-source map.

@EthicalSkeptic Awesome

This is within the South Atlantic Anomaly - roughly 1000 miles from the center of it.

Oh wow. There’s nothing where El Niño originates from?!!??? wtf?

Please look at this data

Pretty awesome!
