Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Oh………… But why?

63,080 views • 3 days ago •via X (Twitter)

36 Comments

Kari_B61ex's profile picture
Kari_B61ex3 days ago

Agreed... Why? The original is the best. We don't need a Temu version.

Elena de la Quintaine's profile picture
Elena de la Quintaine3 days ago

Because they don’t have a creative bone in their bodies

lisa keeble 😊's profile picture
lisa keeble 😊3 days ago

What is this obsession these days with taking something brilliant from years ago and fucking it up?

Eddie_Selling💚🤍💜🇬🇧🇮🇱's profile picture
Eddie_Selling💚🤍💜🇬🇧🇮🇱3 days ago

Unrequired. God bless Kirsty and Shane 💙

Sharon Dunne's profile picture
Sharon Dunne3 days ago

The left in “old hag on junk” but changed “F****t” to “blaggard” 🤦‍♀️

TurkeyLurkeyTime Michelle's profile picture
TurkeyLurkeyTime Michelle3 days ago

The people who are always up in arms about the F word in this song are the same people constantly throwing around the Q word.

Richard Lyall's profile picture
Richard Lyall3 days ago

Talented singers but it’s just a cover of the superior original which we keep censoring over the years. @grok how many lyric changes are we up to now?

Hazel Archer's profile picture
Hazel Archer3 days ago

Probably the same reason for tedious remakes of classics like Pride and Prejudice. What that reason could be is beyond my comprehension. I expect I’m too old and bitter.

Helen Grieve 🇬🇧's profile picture
Helen Grieve 🇬🇧3 days ago

Money. So sad.

KD 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿's profile picture
KD 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿3 days ago

Sounds dreadful tbh. 😬

Annie Kenneysaurus's profile picture
Annie Kenneysaurus3 days ago

Boring versions of good music for boring people.

Sam ❤️ 🐈 🐘's profile picture
Sam ❤️ 🐈 🐘3 days ago

Just because you can doesn't mean you should. It's awful.

TehCecil's profile picture
TehCecil3 days ago

Singing with your hands in your pockets. Now that's showmanship.

A the Ule 🦉🇬🇧's profile picture
A the Ule 🦉🇬🇧3 days ago

It's not bad. But that makes it worse. It's forgettable. Nobody will listen to this year after year, I have to wonder what the point is.

YFI 𝕏's profile picture
YFI 𝕏3 days ago

It's for a Shane MacGowan tribute album, overseen by his wife and sister, and 50% of the proceeds will go to a homeless charity.

James Dreyfus's profile picture
James Dreyfus3 days ago

Well, I’m glad the £ is going to a worthwhile cause…

AnonymousExTory🇺🇦🇮🇱's profile picture
AnonymousExTory🇺🇦🇮🇱3 days ago

@YFIHQ Where do you stand on the 'faggot' lyric?

James Dreyfus's profile picture
James Dreyfus3 days ago

@YFIHQ Never cared. It was a song.

hermionegingold.DBE's profile picture
hermionegingold.DBE3 days ago

su pollard did a better job with the beatles quite frankly. x

@justsay_mother's profile picture
@justsay_mother3 days ago

Great attempt however… Shane and Kirsty voices are unique and one will continue to let their memories live on, @poguesofficial original is that good it’s hard for anyone to take on This song has got me through a few Christmas 🤶

Nigel (bunch of numbers)'s profile picture
Nigel (bunch of numbers)3 days ago

Have they dropped the scumbag and the F word? Sounds too smooth and polished rather than a bit rough like the original

Kath Smith - Now Radicalised By Andy Burnham's profile picture
Kath Smith - Now Radicalised By Andy Burnham3 days ago

Ummmmmmm WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS SHIT! Kirsty and Shane would be fucking appalled

Archdeacon Contrairian Vulgarian Ghost's profile picture
Archdeacon Contrairian Vulgarian Ghost3 days ago

Who are these people?

Kim's profile picture
Kim3 days ago

Nah, never going to better the original. Didn't like the Ronan Keating version either 👎

💜🤍💚🦖 Lydia Terf (Roxy Tickle Is A Man)🐊💜🤍💚's profile picture
💜🤍💚🦖 Lydia Terf (Roxy Tickle Is A Man)🐊💜🤍💚3 days ago

It's fecking awful

Daisy B's profile picture
Daisy B3 days ago

She's done a couple of brilliant albums, so this saddens me as a poor choice. Why would anyone touch this? I know it's bringing them joy to record it, but don't release it to the world- the outcome is inevitable....

Tracey Russell's profile picture
Tracey Russell3 days ago

£££££££££££ and the chance to ruin one of the best songs ever.

SophH's profile picture
SophH3 days ago

Nope. Just no. Not having it.

elizabeth coster's profile picture
elizabeth coster3 days ago

Ffs!!!

Carrie E's profile picture
Carrie E3 days ago

Just because you can doesn’t mean you should

Maria Doyle's profile picture
Maria Doyle3 days ago

Dropping the word faggot is ridiculous, it means a lazy person and has nothing to do with sexual orientation. My Dad would affectionately call me a 'little faggot' when I was a kid if I didn't do my chores.

PeterGilmoreArt - CG King of Horror's profile picture
PeterGilmoreArt - CG King of Horror3 days ago

Ewwww.

Boneshaker baby's profile picture
Boneshaker baby3 days ago

Absolutely dreadful

Ellie's profile picture
Ellie3 days ago

What made the original so good is McGowan’s delivery, particularly of the last verse. This version just doesn’t have the same power

David Meikle 😺🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿's profile picture
David Meikle 😺🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿3 days ago

I could ask ‘who are they’ ? But I don’t care 🤷‍♂️

WaspBoro1's profile picture
WaspBoro13 days ago

Some tunes should not be covered. Originals by Carpenters being the most sacred.

Related Videos