跳过导航
“Redlining” literally wasn’t a real thing btw
0:00 / 2:30

“Redlining” literally wasn’t a real thing btw

John Doyle

@JohnDoyle15万 位关注者

在 X 上查看
13,404 个赞下载原帖

450,098 次观看

“Redlining” literally wasn’t a real thing btw

32 条评论

评论来自 X (Twitter) 上的原帖

  • EllisCaliforniaJones 的头像

    @EllisCaliJones

    You’re lying champ. You said Redlining wasn’t a real thing but then your entire video explains how it was a thing

    308 个赞

  • Neon Whip 的头像

    @OyunPapagan

    "ethnic whites" back then in murica literally didn't cover irish, italians. ffs swedes and austrians weren't "achtually white" either. 1850-1950's american race theory seems to be "noone is white except descendents of englishmen" so you just showed "non-whites" as red zones.

    206 个赞

  • LoveMoveLearn 的头像

    @LoveMoveLearn

    In the Great Migration, Blacks were used as a battering ram to break up cohesive, largely Catholic neighborhoods in Northern cities, in order to break the backs of organized labor. It worked. No history of redlining is complete without acknowledging this.

    101 个赞

  • American Freedmen Legal Fund 的头像

    @realAFLF

    🚨The Record Is Not a Myth🚨 Redlining was real. This deed from Harris County, Texas explicitly restricts property ownership to the “Caucasian Race.” That’s not class-based. That’s race-based. Federal maps, FHA manuals, and racially restrictive covenants shaped lending for decades — and Congress later passed laws to stop it. See the evidence below.

    95 个赞

  • TheFantasyFootballGuy🫡 的头像

    @TheRavenLJ

    @JackPosobiec It’s all a lie. Everything we were taught in school. It’s all nonstop liberal propaganda.

    79 个赞

  • DJ Joel Irving Woodard 的头像

    @DJJoelIWoodard

    No, redlining was definitively not race neutral. While the term today can refer more broadly to any geographic discrimination, its historical implementation in the U.S. was explicitly designed around race and ethnicity. Explicit Racial Targeting In the 1930s, the Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) created "Residential Security Maps" to assess mortgage risk. These maps used a color-coded system where: Green/Blue (Type A/B): Deemed safe and desirable; almost exclusively white, non-immigrant neighborhoods. Yellow (Type C): Deemed "declining"; often included neighborhoods with "infiltration" of "lower-grade" residents. Red (Type D): Deemed "hazardous"; these areas were specifically identified by the presence of Black, Latino, or immigrant populations. Not a Neutral Economic Metric The government’s own underwriting manuals from that era (such as those from the FHA) explicitly stated that "inharmonious racial groups" would lower property values. Because of this: Race over Credit: Even if a Black individual was personally creditworthy, they were often denied a loan simply because they lived in—or wanted to buy in—a redlined area. "Hazardous" Residents: HOLC documents frequently listed the presence of "Negroes" or "Foreign-born" residents as a primary "detrimental influence" that justified a "Red" rating. Forced Segregation: Federal policy actually encouraged the use of racially restrictive covenants (legal clauses in deeds that prevented homes from being sold to non-whites) to "protect" the higher-rated white neighborhoods from becoming redlined. Long-term Impact Redlining effectively institutionalized racial segregation and prevented generations of families of color from building home equity, which is the primary source of wealth for most American families. Though it was outlawed by the Fair Housing Act of 1968, the economic and geographic disparities it created are still visible in city layouts and wealth gaps today.

    61 个赞

  • Zephyr 的头像

    @ZephyrCheez

    You are aware that Jews, Italians, and Irish weren't considered white back then?

    59 个赞

  • Anthony Galli 的头像

    @AnthonyGalli

    If only “redlining” existed for everyone then home prices would be so much cheaper. But instead we borrow huge sums of money from the bank to bid up prices to the benefit of bankers and large real estate owners.

    48 个赞

  • Oriental Monarchist 的头像

    @Incompetent_YT

    John I’m starting to think people have just been making up black history, how could this be?

    39 个赞

  • Southernqueen22 的头像

    @southernqudy19

    @grok why is this guy always lying about black history

    30 个赞

  • I wave at dogs. 的头像

    @BorisHerzel

    Coworker brought up this series in conversation yesterday. "Have you guys seen this dude debunking black history stories?" I said, the Patriot, John Doyle?! You bet.

    24 个赞

  • Travis 的头像

    @rogue_travis

    Somebody give this guy a tv show

    24 个赞

  • ☆ 🐛🐠benjamin netanyancat⛓️🍭👁️👁️ 的头像

    @BlueGreenblue3

    *Points at systemic racism* look guys! It’s systemic! That mean it can’t be racist!

    24 个赞

  • Hugh Retard 的头像

    @iamhughretard

    WE WUZ REDLINED!

    20 个赞

  • DJ Joel Irving Woodard 的头像

    @DJJoelIWoodard

    Racially restrictive covenants were legally binding clauses embedded in property deeds that prohibited the sale, lease, or occupation of a home by anyone who was not white. While redlining was a top-down federal policy that denied loans, covenants were a "ground-level" tool used by developers and homeowners to enforce segregation neighborhood by neighborhood. How They Worked These covenants were essentially private contracts that "ran with the land," meaning they applied to every future owner of the property, not just the person who first signed it. Targeted Groups: Most often, these clauses explicitly barred "Negroes," but they also frequently targeted Jewish people, Asians, and Latinos. Enforcement: If a white homeowner tried to sell to a Black family, neighbors could sue to void the sale and evict the new family. Developer-Driven: During the suburban boom, developers often placed these restrictions on entire subdivisions before a single house was built to ensure the neighborhood would qualify for "Green" or "Blue" ratings from the FHA. The Turning Point: Shelley v. Kraemer (1948) For decades, the Supreme Court held that these were private agreements and therefore legal. However, the landmark case Shelley v. Kraemer changed the legal landscape: The Ruling: The Court ruled that while private parties could write these covenants, the Fourteenth Amendment prohibited state courts from enforcing them. The Nuance: The covenants themselves weren't technically illegal yet, but they became "toothless" because the government could no longer use its power to back them up. The "Zombie" Covenants Today Even though the Fair Housing Act of 1968 eventually made these clauses completely illegal and unenforceable, they haven't disappeared. Because deeds are historical documents, these racist clauses still exist in the "chain of title" for millions of American homes. In recent years, many states (including New York) have passed laws allowing homeowners to file a "restrictive covenant modification" to formally strike or renounce this language from their property records without having to pay for a full title overhaul.

    19 个赞

  • Bungaloo Loyal 的头像

    @WhoDeyGonnaPay

    Bro hates the truth a lot 😆

    18 个赞

  • Alfred Winslow Jones 的头像

    @awjonesandco

    Best black history month ever

    17 个赞

  • Gabriel J. Benton ☦️🇺🇸 的头像

    @OrthoAnglo81

    John Doyle is lovin' the black people.

    16 个赞

  • D-Ram 的头像

    @darram2206

    Damn, you got me again. I thought this one was also a given fact. However, I would like to add that ‘black owned’ banks historically had a higher disapproval rate of blacks than whites.

    16 个赞

  • Jack Daley 的头像

    @JackitDaley

    The old adage "when the legend becomes fact, print the legend" It's becoming increasingly clear that nothing was true leading up to and coming out of the civil rights era

    15 个赞