Roxy literally described this exact encounter when talking about how she wanted to meet her future…
@fuzz_lord_33.2K followers
25,182 views
5 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@karsten6491
My knowledge is limited to the anime, but I think Hitogami was also lying when he told him that, had he not gone, Paul would have saved Roxy and wouldn't have died while saving Zenith.
4 likes

@fuzz_lord_3
Yes, I’m certain Hitogami lied about what would happen if Rudy stayed behind. Rudy was the key to conquering the Teleportation Labyrinth, and Roxy would’ve died without him. Hitogami lied to convince Rudy to follow his advice and check the basement.
3 likes

@Kinamuranyan1
And Elinalise heard her fantasy, then watched it happen. That's why she pushed and eventually lied to get Rufy to accept that he loved Roxy and would take her as his second wife. It was Roxy's one real chance for happiness
2 likes

@Lord_Hokage_PTS
Classic Roxy
1 like

@kaichikin3
Nah man. If you're a solo adventurer and dive dungeons either alone or with a temporary party. It's bound to happen eventually. This is actually the 2nd time Roxy got saved inside a dungeon.