See? Look at my movie collection & Halloween stuff! I KNOW HORROR! I KNOW THINGS!

But you didn't know something that Rich Evans knew, and you will have to carry that mark of shame for the rest of eternity.

Not a horror movie.

Why is American Psycho considered a horror? Isn't it thriller satire?

I agree!!

Gonna need at least 5 RLM/JRT episodes a year please

Holy smokes, is that a signed Coven? That's awesome.

Charles Lee Ray Josh 🤦‍♂️ I believe you know your horror, but that one hurt you a bit IMO 🤷‍♂️

I’m almost 51. My secret is:

Congrats I'm almost 50 myself 🤷‍♂️

(Almost) welcome to the club, pal!

Thanks Josh! Much appreciated. Yup I got about 6 months to go before the big 50 myself. I was surprised you blew the Chucky question just because I actually knew it. In all honesty you got many questions correctly that I had no idea on 🤦‍♂️ You know your stuff my guy.

You need to come back and humiliate Mike like how he humiliated you but setting you up against Jay the horror encyclopaedia

Man, I feel bad for Rich Evans having to get all that stuff into the U-Haul when you move to Milwaukee.

I don't accept the results of any contest where Mike is the ringmaster.

I was really impressed with your hahr-r'r movie knowledge

Unfortunately, once people see you as a poser, anything you do to show your bona fides just looks like more posing. Forget horror movies and focus on you new career as a Mike Stoklasa impersonator.

Disappointed there weren't any Romero questions but at least we got some footage of Dawn and Day

Love the signed copy of Coven.

It's okay dude liking horror movies too much has a greasy vibe to it anyway. Embrace liking made-for-Tubi movies

Two words. Pamela Voorhies.

Lmaoo oh I believe you some of those questions were really hard and some you just had to know the movie well enough

Oh I like horror things, look at meee, ba ba baaaa

How hard it is to find the fridge?

That's a really cool collection,man! That was a fun episode too. :)

Nice collection, Josh :) I like the episodes where you're on! Feels nice to see Mike get bullied. I also finally watched Street Trash thanks to the review thing you and Jay did! I didn't even know that movie existed before that. It was.. something lol.

Looks like a hipster house to me

😉 /sarcasm

You're taking the loss better than expected

Impressive. Most impressive.

Warmed my heart a bit on this cold, windy, raw Friday when I saw you had Motel Hell. Wisconsin-La Crosse Nancy Parsons. RIP, man was she awesome.

Where’s Shaun of the Dead?

Shaun of the Dead and American Psycho have both found better homes. 📀

I was playing along with you guys at the end and these were my choices for the final question

Do you guys all sleep in bunk beds at their Wisconsin warehouse/studio?

It is hip to be square, but not THAT square. And I'm not talking about the movie collection. 🤣🤣🤣

Hell, you even have "Coven" in there! Don't feel bad though. I can't think of many people who could defeat Jay at any kind of movie trivia.

Yoosa thinking that yousa better

"Is this supposed to be a REAL game show?" that was a moment i particularly enjoyed

I’ll bet Mike pronounces Cöven beautifully.