Should this have been strike three?

Yes lol

Yes

Very very close I’m gonna say he went tho

Nope

To be fair to Bill Miller, might be hard for to tell from that angle.

Not with the new technology they’re testing.

that was called a swing vs PCA in NLWC 🤔

Yup

Yes

Look at that corrupt fat fuck at 3rd base

Watch that full speed, 3rd base view and make the call. Also, not egregious enough to call

Lol obv rays fan will say no and guards fab will say yes but what about a unbiased professional opinion? Cuz i honestly dont know it was close

It never is let’s b so fr

No

Nope. Not even close

Of course. Forget the plane, for players that stand far back, it’s if they break their wrists. Meaning if they make an attempt to hit it fair. Failure to do so is penalized with a strike. It’s the core rule of baseball. It was a terrible call.

No

according to the check swing review system they’ve been doing in the minors, this wouldn’t have been a swing

If the ump dropped his glasses I’d call it a perfect strike‑out for the camera crew.

Yes. No question.

HELL YES!

No

It's close, but I would say no. It's certainly not an obvious call that he went.

Yes.

Why is an obese 70 year old umping mlb games lol

Unfortunately, there is no definitive ruling for check swings that eliminates all doubt. The call could've gone either way. It is not reviewable yet, but will be in the near future, thankfully.

I dont think thats a swing

Definitely